Appeals court upholds California LCFS again

Spanish Market: Biofuels, Emissions, Natural gas, Oil products
18/01/19

A federal court today upheld California's Low-Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS), turning away the latest attempt by refiners and ethanol producers to overturn the program.

A three-judge panel of the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously dismissed the legal challenge from the American Fuels and Petrochemical Manufacturers (AFPM) and other groups, saying they had no legal ground on which to wage their fight. Previous court decisions and changes California has made to the program rendered the appeal moot, the judges said.

"To the extent plaintiffs raise new arguments on this appeal, we conclude that they are without merit," the judges said in their ruling.

AFPM, the American Trucking Associations and ethanol industry group Growth Energy had argued that the LCFS is unconstitutional because it unfairly discriminates against out-of-state crude oil and ethanol through its life cycle greenhouse gas emissions analysis, which California uses to set carbon intensity scores for fuels sold in the state.

But the court previously upheld the LCFS in 2013, dismissing similar arguments. And less than a month before holding oral arguments in the case in September, it rejected a similar challenge to Oregon's Clean Fuels Program.

Those decisions, along with the fact the California Air Resources Board amended and readopted its regulations in 2012 and 2015, left the court with little choice but to dismiss the appeal, the judges said.

Lawyers for the groups acknowledged as much during the oral arguments last year, suggesting they were likely to seek help from the full 9th Circuit or appeal to the US Supreme Court. AFPM, which was a party to the Oregon lawsuit, recently petitioned the high court to take that case. The group said it is reviewing today's decision.

The 9th Circuit previously upheld the program in 2013, saying it did not violate the Constitution's Commerce Clause, but sent the case back to a lower court to consider any unresolved issues. That court dismissed the case in 2017 year and the groups appealed that decision.

The LCFS requires a 20pc reduction in the carbon intensity of transportation fuels by 2030.

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

04/04/25

Tariffs and their impact larger than expected: Powell

New York, 4 April (Argus) — Federal Reserve chairman Jerome Powell said today tariff increases unveiled by US president Donald Trump will be "significantly larger" than expected, as will the expected economic fallout. "The same is likely to be true of the economic effects, which will include higher inflation and slower growth," Powell said today at the Society for Advancing Business Editing and Writing's annual conference in Arlington, Virginia. The central bank will continue to carefully monitor incoming data to assess the outlook and the balance of risks, he said. "We're well positioned to wait for greater clarity before considering any adjustments to our policy stance," Powell added. "It is too soon to say what will be the appropriate path for monetary policy." As of 1pm ET today, Fed funds futures markets are pricing in 29pc odds of a quarter point cut by the Federal Reserve at its next meeting in May and 99pc odds of at least a quarter point rate cut in June. Earlier in the day the June odds were at 100pc. The Fed chairman spoke after trillions of dollars in value were wiped off stock markets around the world and crude prices plummeted following Trump's rollout of across-the-board tariffs earlier in the week. Just before his appearance, Trump pressed Powell in a post on his social media platform to "STOP PLAYING POLITICS!" and cut interest rates without delay. A closely-watched government report showed the US added a greater-than-expected 228,000 jobs in March , showing hiring was picking up last month. By Stephen Cunningham Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

UK considers import tariffs on US oil products

04/04/25

UK considers import tariffs on US oil products

London, 4 April (Argus) — The UK government has included refined oil products from the US in a list of goods that could be subject to retaliatory tariffs. The government said it was considering "potential tariff measures on US goods, should this be deemed necessary" in response to a 10pc US import tariff on UK goods and services — excluding energy — due to take effect on 5 April. The consultation will last until 1 May. Light oils, gasoils, jet fuel, fuel oils, lubricants and bitumen all feature in the list of products possibly subject to retaliatory tariffs. The UK could be particularly exposed to any tariff impact on US middle distillate imports in the event of retaliation. The UK sourced over a quarter of its 14.37mn t of 10ppm diesel and gasoil from the US last year, according to Vortexa, while 3pc of its 10.15mn t of jet and kerosine imports were sourced from the US. It is not clear what tariff rate the UK is targeting in its potential retaliation. For other oil products, any potential import tariff impact would become more muted as US refined product imports become less significant. The UK received just 6pc of its 1.92mn t total fuel oil imports from the US last year, while the UK was the fourth largest gasoline supplier to the US and received none of the product from its trade partner. European refined product values have collapsed as a result of the escalating trade war which saw China retaliate today against the US' latest tariff action. Eurobob non-oxy gasoline barge prices dropped by 4pc to $700.75/t on 3 April at a time when trading activity typically picks up ahead of the US summer driving season. Indicated non-oxy barge values were set to drop further in the trading session today. The EU is similarly preparing countermeasures against US import tariffs, which Washington set at 20pc from 9 April in addition to existing rates. Ice gasoil futures had dropped by 10pc since President Trump announced the new tariff regime on 2 April to $615.75/t by the close today. Ice gasoil futures are used as the pricing basis against which diesel, gasoil and jet fuel grades are assessed in the European middle distillates markets. European refined products market participants have pointed to a darker global economic outlook triggered by the US import tariffs as the driving force behind the drop-off in European product values. By George Maher-Bonnett Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Indústria de SAF no Brasil deve decolar em 2027

04/04/25

Indústria de SAF no Brasil deve decolar em 2027

Sao Paulo, 4 April (Argus) — A indústria de aviação brasileira está atenta às regulações para o combustível sustentável de aviação (SAF, na sigla em inglês), enquanto o mercado doméstico aguarda o início da produção local para cumprir com o plano de mandato de mescla e com o potencial de exportação. A Lei do Combustível do Futuro visa aumentar as mesclas obrigatórias de biocombustíveis para reduzir as emissões de gases de efeito estufa (GEEs) em voos domésticos no período de dez anos, a começar por 2027. O Brasil se comprometeu a aplicar um mandato de 10pc de SAF até 2037. Os esforços do país para implementar o mandato de SAF estão alinhados às diretrizes do Esquema para Compensação e Redução de Carbono para a Aviação Internacional (Corsia, na sigla em inglês), da Organização da Aviação Civil Internacional (ICAO, na sigla em inglês), que prevê a redução de emissões de GEEs em voos internacionais. O programa determina duas fases até a implementação integral das metas de redução, pensando em uma adaptação mais eficiente das companhias aéreas e dos produtores. As companhias aéreas podem aderir voluntariamente ao programa entre 2024-26. As metas compulsórias globais são implementadas entre 2027-2035, o que incentiva o uso de SAF e a compensação de créditos de carbono. A fase obrigatória abrange todos os voos internacionais, incluindo aqueles com embarque e desembarque em países não-voluntários, exceto os considerados menos desenvolvidos e os de baixa participação no tráfego aéreo global. O SAF brasileiro é uma indústria recém-nascida com potencial para oferta de insumos , principalmente as rotas de produção envolvendo óleo de soja, etanol de milho e de cana-de-açúcar, bem como largas terras agrícolas destinadas à produção de biomassa sem a prática de mudança do uso da terra (MUT). Essa variabilidade também abre espaço para novos projetos que reutilizam terras degradadas e áreas agrícolas existentes em conformidade com os critérios de sustentabilidade da ICAO relacionados ao uso de terra e ao aprimoramento do solo. A inserção do SAF no Brasil enfrenta obstáculos econômicos à medida que a alta volatilidade do mercado pesa sobre os investimentos de longo prazo, disse o consultor da A&M Infra, Filipe Bonaldo. Segundo o consultor, a agenda política não afetará a transição energética no país como aconteceu nos Estados Unidos sob o governo do presidente Donald Trump, uma vez que a economia do Brasil depende fortemente da agricultura e as regulações do mercado são otimistas. Como uma potência agrícola, o Brasil oferece produção de baixo custo e múltiplas fontes para suprir as demandas internas e externas. O Brasil é o terceiro maior exportador global nos mercados agrícola e pecuário, liderando os segmentos da soja, suco de laranja e de carne, de acordo com a Confederação da Agricultura e Pecuária do Brasil (CAN). Estreia no Rio A Vibra foi a primeira distribuidora a oferecer SAF no Brasil, antes da mescla obrigatória entrar em vigor. A empresa importou 550m³ de SAF produzido a partir de óleo de cozinha usado (UCO, na sigla em inglês), a partir da Bélgica, em janeiro. O biocombustível está disponível para venda nas instalações da Vibra no aeroporto internacional do Rio de Janeiro após dez meses de operações logísticas. A Certificação Internacional de Sustentabilidade e Carbono (ISCC, na sigla em inglês) assegurou a validade de todas as etapas, desde a cadeia de suprimento do produto até a distribuição. A Vibra opera em mais de 90 aeroportos no território brasileiro e representa 60pc da participação de mercado da aviação nacional através da subsidiária BR Aviation, disse o vice-presidente executivo de operações, Marcelo Bragança. Por que tanta demora? Por muito tempo, o setor teve dúvidas quanto à viabilidade técnica do uso de biocombustíveis na aviação, especialmente quanto à segurança, disse a gerente de meio-ambiente e transição energética da Agência Nacional de Aviação Civil (Anac), Marcela Anselmi. A Anac e a Agência Nacional do Petróleo, Gás Natural e Biocombustíveis (ANP) seguem as regulações internacionais para o SAF ao exigirem que o biocombustível apresente semelhanças físico-químicas com o combustível fóssil de aviação para garantir a segurança das operações aéreas. Ainda não é possível usar 100pc de SAF nos motores de aeronaves, disse Anselmi. Há um limite de 50pc de mescla que inibe a adesão ao redor do mundo, considerando as restrições técnicas que ainda precisam ser superadas. O compromisso recente com as pautas de transição energética está incentivando a oferta de biomassa para a aviação, bem como aos modais rodoviário e marítimo, o que exige novas rotas de produção. Por exemplo, a rota alcohol-to-jet (ATJ) converte etanol em SAF, o que pode ser caro para instalar e implica alto investimento em bens de capitais. No contexto global, o Brasil está na vanguarda da pauta SAF, considerando que a Europa e os EUA publicaram legislações relacionadas à produção e ao consumo somente nos últimos dois anos, apontou Anselmi. Enquanto isso, a capacidade projetada de produção de SAF na América do Sul pode chegar a 1.100 m³/ano em 2030, de acordo com a Empresa de Pesquisa Energética (EPE). Por João Curi Envie comentários e solicite mais informações em feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . Todos os direitos reservados.

South Africa Natref to end bitumen production from Sep

04/04/25

South Africa Natref to end bitumen production from Sep

London, 4 April (Argus) — Bitumen production at Natref's 107,000 b/d Sasolburg refinery in South Africa will cease from September, ending all the country's output of the heavy oil product. Several South African bitumen market participants, including buyers from the refinery and suppliers of imported bitumen into the domestic and regional southern African markets, said officials from majority Natref shareholder Sasol had been informing customers of the planned move over the past week. Customers were told that final bitumen supply from stocks held at the refinery would be supplied to them into October, with all supplies ending thereafter. Market participants said the Natref plan is linked to a wider move of switching to sweeter crudes aimed at maximising output of light and middle distillates, which would also hit output of heavy products other than bitumen, notably high-sulphur fuel oil (HSFO). Officials at Sasol, which owns 63.3pc of Natref alongside UK energy firm Prax with 36.4pc, have so far not responded to Argus' requests for comment. South African market participant said the move had been under consideration for some time, even before Prax agreed to buy TotalEnergies' Natref stake in December 2023. South Africa turned from a major net exporter of bitumen, mainly to its southern African neighbours, to becoming increasingly dependent on imports after several of the country's refineries were either shut down or ended their bitumen production since 2020. South African cargo imports in bitumen tankers surged to nearly 200,000t in 2024, according to Vortexa data, mostly into Durban and some into Cape Town. Mediterranean supplies, mainly from Greece and Turkey, made up just over half of these, with Rubis and Continental supplying most. Mideast Gulf storage points, along with Bahraini state-owned Bapco's refinery and export terminal at Sitra, supplied around a third, while emerging exporter Pakistan shipped 8pc. According to a South African bitumen supplier, the Natref refinery's bitumen production fell last year to 45,000-50,000t — from an Argus estimate of 140,000t in 2023 — because of numerous plant halts and interruptions. The market effect of Natref ending its bitumen output will therefore be limited, with another leading South African participant saying truck flows from the inland refinery had become increasingly unreliable. The halt will nevertheless trigger more South African import requirements that are anyway likely to rise sharply in the coming years because of much-enhanced government infrastructure budgets. The Natref refinery was forced to stop all production for about two months following a fire in early January this year. French construction and bitumen supply firm Colas recently became the latest company to take a South African import asset position, agreeing a long-term deal with local firm FFS Refiners to operate four of five new bitumen tanks at an existing Durban facility once an FFS expansion there is completed, likely in the second half of this year. By Keyvan Hedvat and Fenella Rhodes Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

New tariffs could upend US tallow imports

03/04/25

New tariffs could upend US tallow imports

New York, 3 April (Argus) — New US tariffs on nearly all foreign products could deter further imports of beef tallow, a fast-rising biofuel feedstock and food ingredient that had until now largely evaded President Donald Trump's efforts to reshape global trade. Tallow was the most used feedstock for US biomass-based diesel production in January for the first month ever, with consumption by pound rising month to month despite sharp declines in actual biorefining and in use of competing feedstocks. The beef byproduct benefits from US policies, including a new federal tax credit known as "45Z", that offer greater subsidies to fuel derived from waste than fuel derived from first-generation crops. Much of that tallow is sourced domestically, but the US also imported more than 880,000t of tallow last year, up 29pc from just two years earlier. The majority of those imports last year came from Brazil, which until now has faced a small 0.43¢/kg (19.5¢/lb) tariff, and from Australia, which was exempt from any tallow-specific tariffs under a free trade agreement with US. But starting on 5 April, both countries will be subject to at least the new 10pc charge on foreign imports. There are some carveouts from tariffs for certain energy products, but animal fats are not included. Some other major suppliers — like Argentina, Uruguay, and New Zealand — will soon have new tariffs in place too, although tallow from Canada is for now unaffected because it is covered by the US-Mexico-Canada free trade agreement. Brazil tallow shipments to the US totaled around 300,000t in 2024, marking an all-time high, but tallow shipments during the fourth quarter of 2024 fell under the 2023 levels as uncertainty about future tax policy slowed buying interest. Feedstock demand in general in the US has remained muted to start this year because of poor biofuel production margins, and that has extended to global tallow flows. Tallow suppliers in Brazil for instance were already experiencing decreased interest from US producers before tariffs. Brazil tallow prices for export last closed at $1,080/t on 28 March, rising about 4pc year-to-date amid support from the 45Z guidance and aid from Brazil's growing biodiesel industry, which is paying a hefty premium for tallow compared to exports. While the large majority of Brazilian tallow exports end up in the US, Australian suppliers have more flexibility and could send more volume to Singapore instead if tariffs deter US buyers. Export prices out of Australia peaked this year at $1,185/t on 4 March but have since trended lower to last close at $1,050/t on 1 April. In general, market participants say international tallow suppliers would have to drop offers to keep trade flows intact. Other policy shifts affect flows Even as US farm groups clamored for more muscular foreign feedstock limits over much of the last year, tallow had until now largely dodged any significant restrictions. Recent US guidance around 45Z treats all tallow, whether produced in the US or shipped long distances to reach the US, the same. Other foreign feedstocks were treated more harshly, with the same guidance providing no pathway at all for road fuels from foreign used cooking oil and also pinning the carbon intensity of canola oil — largely from Canada — as generally too high to claim any subsidy. But tariffs on major suppliers of tallow to the US, and the threat of additional charges if countries retaliate, could give refiners pause. Demand could rise for domestic animal fats or alternatively for domestic vegetable oils that can also be refined into fuel, especially if retaliatory tariffs cut off global markets for US farm products like soybean oil. There is also risk if Republicans in the Trump administration or Congress reshape rules around 45Z to penalize foreign feedstocks. At the same time, a minimum 10pc charge for tallow outside North America is a more manageable price to pay compared to other feedstocks — including a collection of charges amounting to a possible 69.5pc tax on Chinese used cooking oil. And if the US sets biofuel blend mandates as high as some oil and farm groups are pushing , strong demand could leave producers with little choice but to continue importing at least some feedstock from abroad to continue making fuel. Not all US renewable diesel producers will be equally impacted by tariffs either. Diamond Green Diesel operates Gulf Coast biorefineries in foreign-trade zones, which allow companies to avoid tariffs on foreign inputs for products that are ultimately exported. Biofuel producers in these zones could theoretically refine foreign tallow, claim a 45Z subsidy, and avoid feedstock tariffs as long as they ship the fuel abroad. Jurisdictions like the EU and UK, where sustainable aviation fuel mandates took effect this year, are attractive destinations. And there is still strong demand from the US food sector, with edible tallow prices in Chicago up 18pc so far this year. Trump allies, including his top health official, have pushed tallow as an alternative to seed oils. By Cole Martin and Jamuna Gautam Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more