Spain exempts large power consumers from total lockdown

Spanish Market: Electricity
01/04/20

Spain has exempted much of its metals, chemicals, cement and other large power-consuming industries from the halt in non-essential economic activity decreed in the country from 30 March, although they will still have to cut output.

Large power consumers including steel mills, the automotive industry and plants supplying Spain's export market will have to reduce activity and staffing to "minimum levels", corresponding to the times of a plant's lowest productivity during the year.

Spain widened its restrictions on travel and economic activity to combat the spread of the coronavirus to all non-essential industry from 30 March as the country struggles to control the pandemic. Over 100,000 people have been infected and more than 9,000 have died in the country as of today, the second-highest levels in Europe after Italy.

Spain's government appeared to ease the stance regarding large power consumers in a clarificatory note published yesterday by the industry ministry and in comments after an emergency cabinet meeting.

The note describes the activities that are considered to provide essential goods and services during the crisis and the minimum activity levels for industries that are not seen as essential but for which shutting down plants is a lengthy, risky and expensive task.

It also specifies that workers that deal directly and indirectly in import and export sectors, including for non-essential goods, are also allowed to travel to work — indicating that Spain's cement and chemicals sectors will also be allowed to keep operating to the extent that they meet their international contracts.

Part of the confusion over the areas of the economy that can be qualified as essential was highlighted in an earlier note published by the regional government of Asturias, which houses much of Spain's metallurgy, mining and extractive industry.

Asturias pre-empted the declarations by the government yesterday and after talks with local businesses qualified large slices of its economy as linked, albeit indirectly, to the production of goods and services classed as essential during the crisis and requested the central government put no limits on their productive capacity during the lockdown.

Spain's association of steelmakers Unesid said late yesterday that it has also asked the central government to consider its business as essential for "guaranteeing the stability of Spain's power sector", and refrain from putting limits on output.

Despite the greater flexibility over production curbs shown by the government yesterday, steelmakers and other large power consumers will still be obliged to cut output to levels that restrict the movement of their workers to minimum levels, according to Spain's economy minister Nadina Calvino. "I think we have been clear enough on this point," the minister said.

By Jonathan Gleave

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

17/03/25

Norway cold on EU VAT power sales harmony

London, 17 March (Argus) — Norway will not harmonise its value-added tax (VAT) legislation for cross-border power sales with the EU despite pressure from market operator Epex Spot, with the country's finance ministry claiming that its current rules are "satisfactory", it told Argus . Norway's finance ministry has not "found any reasons" to consider better integrating its VAT procedures on cross-border power sales, the ministry said, adding that EU rules are not "binding" and that, as such, "there is no ongoing work" to align the Nordic country with the broader European market. The decision follows a series of letters sent by Epex Spot that highlighted its significant objections to the existing VAT arrangements. The market operator argues that the system allows for potential double taxation on some sales while others can go completely untaxed. They added that this increases the risk of VAT tax fraud in Norway, with the system "leav[ing] the door open to well-known tax fraud methods", Epex Spot's public and regulatory affairs director, Davide Orifici, told Argus last year . In response to the ministry's statement, Epex Spot told Argus that while the legislation "is not binding for Norway", it hoped that Norway would align with EU rules "on a voluntary basis" to "secure the Norwegian power market against VAT fraud". It added that Norway's "tax authorities themselves" had confirmed to the media that Norway was, in effect, "keeping the doors open to fraud". Epex conducted discussions with Norway's tax authorities late last year, which were characterised as "good", but the finance ministry appears to be unmoved on EU VAT harmonisation. This is the latest flashpoint in a lingering dispute within Norwegian politics over whether it is best to pull back or move closer to the EU power market. Norway's coalition government fell apart earlier this year as the country's centre party left the ruling alliance over lead-partner Labour Party's willingness to align Norway more closely with the EU and adopt the bloc's fourth energy package. This leaves the Labour Party to govern as a minority government until parliamentary elections take place on 8 September. By Daniel Craig Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Lower Rio Tinto Al output cuts New Zealand power demand

13/03/25

Lower Rio Tinto Al output cuts New Zealand power demand

Sydney, 13 March (Argus) — New Zealand's industrial electricity demand fell on the year in October-December 2024, after Rio Tinto cut production at its Tiwai Point aluminium smelter in the previous quarter. The country's industrial electricity demand was down by 9pc compared with a year earlier, data from the Ministry of Business, Innovation, and Employment show ( see table ). Rio Tinto cut production at Tiwai Point in late-July 2024, after New Zealand utility Meridian Energy requested that it reduce its energy use by 205 MW. Many of the plant's potlines remained off line until late-September 2024, when Rio Tinto began restarting production at a reduced level. The Tiwai Point Aluminium Smelter is New Zealand's largest industrial energy user, consuming 572MW of power, often accounting for 12-13pc of national electricity demand, according to New Zealand's Electricity Authority. But it only accounted for about 10pc of total demand in October-December because of its lower production level. Rio Tinto's decreased power use and the country's rising geothermal generation in October-December pushed New Zealand's coal- and gas-fired generation to their lowest levels since late-2022. Utilities produced 2.1PJ from coal- and gas-fired generation, down by 73pc on the quarter and by 42pc on the year ( see table ). Coal- and gas-fired plants accounted for just 6pc of total generation in the fourth quarter of 2024, down from 19pc in July-September and 10pc a year earlier. Meanwhile, New Zealand's renewable power generation grew in importance over October-December, even as the government continued taking steps to promote coal- and gas-fired generation. The share of renewable electricity rose to 94.3pc, the highest level since December 2022 and the fourth highest on record. The New Zealand government is eager to promote oil, gas and petroleum generation, resources minister Shane Jones told Argus in December 2024. New Zealand's government has rolled back a ban on offshore gas exploration and has been fast-tracking coal developments since taking office in 2023. The country's largest utility, Meridian Energy, also warned of a structural gas shortage in late February, calling for new gas exploration. By Avinash Govind New Zealand Energy Quarterly Oct-Dec '24 Jul-Sep '24 Oct-Dec '23 q-o-q ± % y-o-y ± % Electricity Consumption (PJ) Industrial 11.0 10.1 12.1 8.7 -9.0 Total 33.7 38.1 35.2 -11.4 -4.3 Electricity Production (PJ) Coal 0.5 3.2 1.3 -84.9 -64.2 Gas 1.7 4.6 2.4 -63.8 -29.8 Geothermal 7.6 8.5 7.1 -10.9 6.6 Total 37.7 41.5 38.2 -9.3 -1.4 Source: Ministry of Business, Innovation, and Employment (MBIE) Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Italian Bess necessary to reduce gas burn: Industry

11/03/25

Italian Bess necessary to reduce gas burn: Industry

London, 11 March (Argus) — As renewables become more prevalent in the Italian power mix, market participants support the buildout of battery energy storage systems (Bess) to replace gas-fired generation as a source of flexibility, Argus heard on the sidelines of the KEY25 Energy Transition Expo in Rimini last week. Italy has some of the highest electricity prices in Europe owing to the country's heavy reliance on gas-fired generation, with the single national price (Pun) averaging €107.75/MWh over 2024. While there has been a decrease in gas burn and an increase in renewables output since 2022, gas-fired generation still accounted for slightly over 40pc of the power mix on average last year, compared with combined solar and wind generation at 21pc. The Italian government has set ambitious renewable targets under the country's national energy and climate plan, aiming to reach 131.3GW — including solar, wind and hydro capacity — by 2030 from 77GW in January under Italy's climate and energy plan. There is general agreement among market participants that reducing gas burn in favour of renewable energy sources will lower electricity prices, but some gas-fired capacity may never be removed from the Italian power mix without having another technology that can provide the same flexibility at scale. Residual demand in Italy is falling, but thermal output remains essential to cover demand peaks during critical summer and winter periods, according to Italian transmission system operator (TSO) Terna's latest system adequacy report . But as renewables cover an increasing share of electricity demand — estimated to reach 335TWh in 2028 — thermal plants will become less economically viable and are likely to be decommissioned unless they are kept operating through ancillary services. "The more renewable generation we have, the less gas-fired plants will have to cover residual electricity demand. Only the most efficient — hence the cheapest — gas-fired plants will be accepted, and the others will be decommissioned," a power trader told Argus . But turning on a gas-fired plant from cold and with a stop-start operation would lead to exaggerated costs and higher maintenance prices. "Morning and evening prices could be used to cover the maintenance of the plant, and the average price would risk being the same but with very marked price differences," the head of power origination of an Italian utility told Argus . "This would lead to investing a lot in batteries that could exploit the spreads and lower them a bit," he added. Market participants attending the conference widely agreed that growing renewable capacity means there is a need to focus on the development of Bess, especially those with 6-8 hours duration to enable time shifting. Solar photovoltaic capacity is expected to grow by 6-8 GW/yr to 2030, according to industry body Italia Solare president Paolo Viscontini. The Italian energy ministry has recently accepted Terna's view that the country will need an additional 10GWh of Bess capacity by 2028 to avoid the risk of the grid becoming congested in periods of overgeneration. As of January 2025, Italy had 13.3GWh of Bess capacity — mainly in the south of the country and on the islands — and is expected to reach 50GWh by 2030. And Terna last week said it will hold its first auction for large-scale Bess with 2028 delivery on 30 September, for which it has already approved 9GWh, as reported by the operator's grid development manager Francesco Del Pizzo. Connection requests for Bess projects more than tripled in 2024 to 253GW worth of capacity, mainly because of a significant reduction in capital expenditure for the assets, which has dropped by around 40pc since 2022 and is expected to stabilise at a competitive price in the next few years. By Ilenia Reale Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Ontario adds fee for electricity exports to US: Update

10/03/25

Ontario adds fee for electricity exports to US: Update

Updates with comments from US utilities Calgary, 10 March (Argus) — Ontario is imposing a 25pc tariff on electricity exports to the US starting today, carrying through on its threatened retaliation for a trade war started by US president Donald Trump. "We will apply maximum pressure to maximize our leverage, that's why today we're moving forward with a 25pc surcharge on electricity exports for the 1.5mn American homes and business that Ontario powers," Ontario premier Doug Ford said today in Toronto. Ontario was the largest exporter of electricity to the US in 2023, sending 15.2 TWh to New York, Michigan and Minnesota. The neighbouring province of Quebec, which exported 13.4 TWh the same year to New York and New England, has said it is also considering its options amid the trade war. Ford said he feels "terrible" because average consumers will pay when it is really Trump who is responsible. The surcharge will cost the US up to $400,000/d, amounting to an increase of $100 for consumers each month, according to Ford. "I will not hesitate to increase this charge," said Ford. "If necessary, if the United States escalates, I will not hesitate to shut the electricity off completely." Trump on 4 March imposed a 10pc tax on Canadian energy imports, a 25pc tariff on non-energy imports from Canada and a 25pc tariff on all imports from Mexico. But executive orders that he signed on 6 March exempted North American trade covered by the US-Mexico-Canada (USMCA) free trade agreement from new tariffs after 12:01am eastern time on 7 March. Trump has said he is delaying the tariffs on Canada and Mexico until 2 April, but his executive orders make no mention of that restart date. Minnesota Power, a subsidiary of Allete, imports "a small portion" of its electricity from Ontario but expects the impact to be "negligible", the utility said. Minnesota Power receives 11pc of its of its energy supply from Manitoba Hydro, but Manitoba has not followed Ontario's lead and imposed a surcharge. Michigan's largest utility, Consumers Energy — which serves 6.8mn of the state's 10mn residents — does not purchase power from Ontario. Xcel Energy, which serves customers in Minnesota and Michigan, also said it did not buy power from Ontario. By Brett Holmes and Anna Harmon Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

France's energy plan to allow new fossil-fired plants

10/03/25

France's energy plan to allow new fossil-fired plants

London, 10 March (Argus) — A revised version of France's 10-year energy plan, released for final public consultation, cuts a pledge to no longer build any more fossil fuel-fired power plants, while the government is pushing a bill that allows coal-fired plants to be converted to gas firing rather than shut down. The PPE3 plan, which sets out a roadmap for how France will change its energy system out to 2035 in order to comply with the country's goals to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, is now in the last stage of public consultation, several years after it was due to be finalised. The latest version maintains a pledge to phase out coal, with France's last two remaining coal-fired power plants set to close by 2027. But the pledge included in the previous version to "not build new electricity generation sites based on fossil energy" has been removed. And a pledge to "launch studies or pilot projects" to convert existing or build greenfield thermal plants using 100pc decarbonised energy has been watered down. It now promises simply to "help" operators of such plants launch studies or projects, and on fuels that are "less emitting" rather than completely decarbonised. A bill is currently passing through the French parliament that allows the country's two remaining coal-fired plants to be converted to gas operation. Gazelenergie, operator of one of the plants, hailed the bill when it was announced last month. It has the backing of the government, as well as of parliamentarians from across the political spectrum in the Moselle region, where one of the coal-fired plants is located. The new version of the plan also cuts ambitions for solar power as revealed last month , in light of views that the previous aim was too high given France's extensive nuclear fleet. The government now aims for 65-90GW by 2035, down from 75-100GW in the previous plan. It hopes to achieve this aim by launching two tenders per year of 1GW each for ground-mounted solar and three tenders of 300MW each for roof-mounted solar. The roof-mounted tenders "may be adjusted" according to changes made to subsidies, the government said. And one technologically neutral 500MW tender per year will be held. In the past, these tenders typically have been dominated by solar projects. The government has not explicitly decided on a separate tender for agrivoltaic projects, as the solar sector had called for, but it may decide to hold them, deducting any capacity called for from other solar buckets. The trajectory for solar is set at 5GW of projects assigned per year, for 4GW constructed, assuming 20pc of projects do not advance. This then could be modified upwards from 2028-29, to a maximum of 7 GW/yr, if increases in demand and flexibility justify it. On onshore wind, two tenders of 900MW each will be held every year in order to hold the trajectory of construction at roughly 1.5 GW/yr. France's electricity is already substantially decarbonised, thanks to its large nuclear fleet and renewables installations. Fossil fuel-fired plants will only be needed to cover demand spikes and ensure energy security, the government said in the consultation. By Rhys Talbot Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more