Trafigura sees potential for H2 derivatives in shipping

Spanish Market: Biofuels, Emissions, Hydrogen, Oil products
23/05/23

Green hydrogen derivatives offer a more viable alternative to conventional bunkers than biofuels, trading firm Trafigura said in a white paper published today.

The company said it has shifted its focus away from biofuels as alternative marine fuels because production cannot be scaled to meet the demands of the shipping industry. It sees more potential in marine fuels derived from green hydrogen such as methanol and ammonia.

The shipping industry, which represents 3pc of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, will require a variety of alternative marine fuels to exceed current GHG emissions reduction targets by 2050, the firm said. It suggests the global south could be the primary producer of these fuels due to its access to renewable energy resources.

Combustion engines that run on ammonia are not yet available, and commissioning new vessels requires significant investment, in terms of time and capital — they take 3-5 years to build and have a lifespan of 20-30 years. There are also safety risks associated with ammonia, which is toxic, as well as concerns around the future availability of low-emissions fuels.

But Trafigura thinks these problems could be overcome by the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) setting decarbonisation targets for the industry to encourage new technological developments. The company reiterated its calls on the IMO to impose a carbon levy to incentivise the use of e-fuels, which are four times the price of very low-sulphur fuel oil in Europe, according to the white paper's findings. It pointed to 50 countries that already have a carbon levy, such as Japan, as examples to follow.

By Anya Fielding

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

27/12/24

Viewpoint: Consolidation looms in US methanol

Houston, 27 December (Argus) — The sale of Netherlands-based OCI's methanol production assets to rival producer Methanex is set to shift the market, with US methanol production most affected by the move. Methanex in the third quarter of 2024 announced the $2bn acquisition, which is expected to close in the first half of 2025. The boards of directors of both companies and OCI's shareholders approved the transaction, but it is subject to regulatory approvals. OCI operates the 1mn t/yr OCI Beaumont plant and is a 50:50 partner in Natgasoline, a 1.7mn t/yr joint-venture plant between OCI and Proman. Methanex operates three plants in the US, all in Geismar, Louisiana. These plants carry a collective 4mn t/yr capacity and represent one-third of total US methanol capacity. At front and center of the acquisition is the Natgasoline plant in Beaumont. Natgasoline, when operational, represents 14pc of domestic production. The plant opened in 2018, and throughout those six years, the plant has seen its share of operational issues. The most recent was a fire at the reformer unit in early October, resulting in a complete shutdown lasting nearly three months. When the deal was announced, Methanex made it clear that the transaction was subject to approvals by OCI shareholders, as well as a pending legal decision between OCI and Proman. "If it is not settled within a certain period, Methanex has the option to carve out the purchase of the Natgasoline joint venture and close only on the remainder of the transaction," the company said in September. Methanex and OCI declined to give further details, as the deal is still pending. Proman did not respond to a request for comment. If it goes through, the acquisition would result in the exodus of OCI from the US methanol market. But the issue of liquidity in the US spot barge market is also looming. Market participants said OCI is a frequent buyer when the Natgasoline plant goes down. In October, when Natgasoline was completely shut down, 340,000 bl of methanol moved for delivery at ITC, the terminal on the Houston Ship Channel where methanol is exchanged, according to Argus data. Market participants expect liquidity to be about the same until some time after the deal closes. When a plant goes down, a producer will emerge in the spot market for purchases. In the longer term, there are some questions around international distribution and where US methanol exports find a home. Methanex is a major exporter to Asia, whereas OCI sells into the European market. The low-carbon methanol sector will also experience some shakeup. OCI is a major participant in the bio-methanol space, selling volume into Europe. Methanex produces carbon-captured methanol, also known as blue methanol, which has not penetrated the EU market. By Steven McGinn Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Viewpoint: California-Quebec carbon faces murky 2025

27/12/24

Viewpoint: California-Quebec carbon faces murky 2025

Houston, 27 December (Argus) — The joint California-Quebec climate market, known as the Western Climate Initiative (WCI), is on tenterhooks going into 2025, stymied by rulemaking delays but on the cusp of a more mature phase. Both California and Quebec are eyeing more-stringent future programs and have floated a series of changes over the past year and a half designed to achieve those goals. The California Air Resources Board (CARB) is considering moving its program's mandate from the present 2030 target of a 40pc reduction in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, compared with 1990 levels, to a 48pc reduction to keep the state on target to meet its 2045 goal of net-zero emissions. In line with this increased ambition, CARB will need to remove at least 180mn metric tonnes (t) of allowances from the 2026-2030 auction and allocation annual budgets to start with, and up to 265mn t in total from the program budgets from 2026-2045. CARB has floated other changes , including toughening corporate relationship disclosure requirements, increasing the program's cost-containment allowance price tiers and updating a portion of the program's carbon offset protocols. Quebec has considered removing 17.5mn t of allowances, which correspond to carbon offset uses for compliance in the province over 2013-2020. The Quebec Environmental Ministry proposed to address this by removing these allowances from the province's 2025-2030 auction budgets in a November 2023 workshop. Quebec is also mulling changing the current three-year compliance period to align with statutory 2030 and 2050 GHG targets. But this a move that California, which had discussed similar compliance period changes in April , has not revisited since. Quebec is considering tapering the limit for carbon offset use for compliance in the province by 2030 and transitioning over to a provincial reduction purchase mechanism in 2031, although regulators have not gone in-depth on how a replacement system would function. The WCI rulemakings have been marked by a series of delays over this year, pushing past projections from the end of last year that it would finalize program changes by the second half of 2024. Quebec, which was set to deliver a draft of program amendments in September, rescheduled to early 2025, with implementation expected in spring 2025. While the regulation was nearly complete in late September, the Quebec Environmental Ministry chose to postpone, since it cannot publish before California, said Jean-Yves Benoit, the agency's director general of carbon regulation and emissions data. CARB has signaled it intends to publish its package of rulemaking amendments in early 2025. The agency on 19 December confirmed it expects to "complete and release the regulatory package for a 45-day public comment period" in early 2025 but did not explain the delay. The agency may be waiting for a formal extension of the cap-and-trade program when the legislature resumes on 6 January. California lawmakers have given CARB explicit authority to utilize a cap-and-trade system to reduce GHG emissions out to 2030. CARB maintains it has authority to operate a cap-and-trade program past 2030, but program participants have stressed the need for formal certainty around the program to aid future planning. CARB will begin invoking the post-2030 budgets starting in 2028 for the program's advance auctions. The various delays have compressed the timelines California and Quebec must achieve their statutory target ambitions, making 2025 a potentially pivotal year. By Denise Cathey Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Viewpoint: Trump tariffs may inflate midcon fuel costs

27/12/24

Viewpoint: Trump tariffs may inflate midcon fuel costs

Houston, 27 December (Argus) — President-elect Donald Trump's threat to impose tariffs on all Canadian imports would increase costs for producing US midcontinent road fuels, which are largely refined from Western Canadian Select (WCS) crude. Trump said in November that he plans to impose a 25pc tariff on all imports from Mexico and Canada after he takes office on 20 January. Canadian crude is the top feedstock for Midwest refiners, accounting for 66pc of the region's crude runs in September, according to US Energy Information Administration (EIA) data. Parts of the Midwest — as well as California and the northeast US — lack sufficient pipeline capacity to process domestic crude or to receive refined products from elsewhere in the country, according to the American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers (AFPM), which represents many US refiners. So AFPM wants Trump to exclude crude and refined products from his proposed tariffs. Most refiners in the US midcontinent depend on heavy sour crudes, with over 20 marketers and refiners importing crude from Canada in September, including BP's 435,000 b/d Whiting, Indiana, refinery; Cenovus' 151,000 b/d Toledo refinery in Ohio; Marathon Petroleum's 140,000 b/d Detroit, Michigan, refinery; and Phillips 66's 356,000 b/d Wood River refinery in Roxana, Illinois. Generally, heavier sour crudes are less expensive than lighter, sweeter crudes like WTI. The US in September imported 4mn b/d of crude from Canada, accounting for 62pc of total US crude imports and a record high for the month, according to EIA data. The US midcontinent imported 2.6mn b/d of Canadian crude in the month, also a record high for September. In 2023, the region imported 2.7mn b/d of Canadian crude, the highest annual imports recorded for the region, according to the EIA. Canada could move more of its crude through its 590,000 b/d Trans Mountain Expansion (TMX) pipeline to the Pacific coast, where it would head to international markets. US importers could also take more from countries like Saudi Arabia and Venezuela , which produce the heavy, sour crudes favored by refiners in the upper US midcontinent. Each supplied more than 200,000 b/d to the US in September, the largest exporters after Canada and Mexico, according to the EIA. Pipeline movements from the US Gulf coast to the US midcontinent would likely increase if the upper US midcontinent refiners try to replace Canadian heavy sour crude. The region received 23.5mn b/d of crude from the Gulf coast, as the southern US midcontinent processes WTI. But the region would probably face higher landed costs for crude originating from overseas. Refineries would have to be more disciplined with the increased feedstock costs that the threatened tariffs would impose, according to one market participant. The region would still have to rely on Canadian crude because US Gulf coast crude barrels would still cost more, and midcontinent refiners would have difficulty finding alternative sources. WCS Hardisty crude prices have averaged a discount of $17.08/bl to WTI Houston so far in the fourth quarter. For road fuel prices during the fourth quarter to date, Chicago gasoline prices averaged a 1.33¢/USG discount to the US Gulf coast and Chicago ultra low sulphur diesel averaged a 1.34¢/USG discount. But regional spreads between Chicago and the US Gulf coast could continue to narrow if midcontinent refiners reduce operating rates. By Hunter Fite Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Shell shuts oil unit at Singapore refinery

27/12/24

Shell shuts oil unit at Singapore refinery

Singapore, 27 December (Argus) — Shell has shut an oil unit at the 237,000 b/d Pulau Bukom refinery in Singapore to investigate a "suspected leak", said the Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore (MPA) and National Environment Agency (NEA) today. Shell informed the government agencies that they will have to shut one of its "oil processing units" at Pulau Bukom to facilitate investigations into a suspected leak. The exact oil processing unit cannot be confirmed, but it is a unit "used to produce refined oil products such as diesel". This means it is likely a crude distillation unit or a hydrocracking unit. Shell's initial estimates show that a few tonnes of oil products were leaked, together with cooling water discharge. Sea water is typically drawn to aid in the cooling process, according to the media release. This came after the 20 October leak at a pipeline at Pulau Bukom, when 30-40t of "slop" — or a mixture of oil and water — leaked into the sea, according to Shell. The gasoline market has shown little reaction so far with spreads being "stagnant" and "range bound", said a Singapore-based gasoline broker. But this could be because of a lack of market activity, with many traders away for holidays at the end of the year. The gasoil January-February spread last traded at $0.58/bl in backwardation at around 6:30pm Singapore time on 27 December, according to a Singapore-based gasoil broker. This marks a slight increase from an assessment of $0.55/bl in backwardation on 26 December, according to Argus pricing data. By Aldric Chew Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Viewpoint: SE Asian IMO2 MRs to rise on EU policy

27/12/24

Viewpoint: SE Asian IMO2 MRs to rise on EU policy

London, 27 December (Argus) — Rates for specialised Medium Range (MR) tankers in southeast Asia will be driven up in 2025 by changes in EU policy on deforestation, higher biofuels blending mandates, and new mandates in the aviation sector, all of which will support exports of biodiesels, feedstocks and palm oil. Demand for specialised MRs in southeast Asia is ruled by exports of palm oil to Europe and the US Gulf coast. Palm oil does not usually need to travel on IMO2 ships and can be moved on IMO3 vessels. But it is often moved as a part-cargo of between 5,000-15,000t so is often picked up by IMO2 or IMO2/3 vessels, which are more suitable as they have a higher number of segregated tanks. Kpler data show around 6.3mn t of palm oil was exported from Indonesia and Malaysia to the US Gulf and Europe in the January-November 2024 period. Palm oil deliveries from southeast Asia have been trending lower since 2020 with the product becoming less popular in Europe because of deforestation issues. On 4 December, an agreement was reached between the European Council and the European Parliament to delay the application of the EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) by one year. This means larger companies will not be required to prove that their products, such as palm oil, did not contribute to deforestation until 30 December 2025. This has averted a potential rapid loss in palm oil exports to Europe in 2025 but there will probably be a substantial decline in exports later in the year as businesses prepare for the EUDR. In the short term, the decision to postpone the EUDR will probably boost cargo numbers heading to Europe as traders had been holding off for clear regulatory guidance. This will support freight rates for IMO2 MRs in the new year by pulling more IMO2/3s and IMO3s away from the market and by increasing the number of part cargoes available for IMO2s. Feedstock exports ramp up Indonesia and Malaysia also export many specialised products that require IMO2s, such as waste based feedstocks palm oil mill effluent (POME), palm fatty acid distillate (PFAD) and used cooking oil (UCO), as well as finished biodiesels like Ucome. Kpler puts exports of these products to Europe at around 2.8mn t in the first 11 months of 2024, with POME cargoes making up 42pc of all shipments or around 1.2mn t. POME was included in Annex IX Part A of the EU's renewable energy directive (RED), meaning member states can count it twice towards their renewable energy goals. Exports of feedstocks and biodiesels to Europe will probably rise in 2025 as blending mandates rise and because of a reduction in the carryover of emissions tickets in Germany and the Netherlands. Argus estimates European demand for biodiesel Pomeme to rise by around 36pc on the quarter in first three months of 2025 to around 3.5mn litres. Higher requirements for biofuels and feedstocks in Europe should push up demand for products like POME, PFAD, and UCO from Malaysia and Indonesia and support higher IMO2 demand in southeast Asia. But this could be tempered by an Indonesian ruling to include an export permit for POME and PFAD that requires participants to fulfil their cooking oil domestic market obligation. SAF mandates begin in Europe Exports of HVO and SAF from Singapore to Europe also make up part-cargo demand for IMO2 MRs. Argus forecasts European HVO demand will rise by 85pc on the quarter to 2,582mn l in the first three months of 2025. New 2pc SAF mandates in the EU and UK in 2025 will provide a sizable rise in SAF demand. This should spur a jump in cargoes loading from Singapore — driving up demand for part-cargo space on IMO2 MRs. By Leonard Fisher-Matthews Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more