Q&A: EU solar gains nothing from trade war
The EU's net zero industry act (NZIA) could boost Europe's solar manufacturing and make it more resilient to competition from abroad. But Europe should avoid protectionism and escalating trade wars, industry association Solar Power Europe deputy chief executive Dries Acke tells Argus' Sian Morris.
How has the European solar industry fared in the past three years?
It has been quite an intense three years, because there was the energy crisis year, with the situation between Russia and Ukraine. So it was really important that Europe reacted and did something to substantially reduce gas imports from Russia and accelerate the energy transition to fill that gap. And that's really been the beginning of this acceleration story of solar. We're proud that solar delivered for Europe.
The other thing that also happened in the past few years was we saw Covid supply chain restrictions released and a strong decline in volume prices from China. That was a very difficult situation for European manufacturers. But we're quite happy, because through that we have the solar charter, which is political confirmation that European leaders and the industry are committed to maintaining and growing solar manufacturing in Europe.
What are the solar industry's goals for the future?
We have a very clear goal for ourselves in the solar sector. We want to reach at least 1,000 gigawatts (GW) by 2030 in Europe. That's a goal we launched three or four years ago and was received with a lot of scepticism. But you can see that projections are increasingly creeping closer to that goal. For example, if you look at the latest national energy climate plans, the new ones that will be finalised very soon aggregate to well above 650GW. And that's just the current plans of member states on paper, which we always know are developed a little bit prudently.
One of the goals of the NZIA is to make sure the renewables being rolled out are manufactured in the EU. How much of that 1,000GW do you think will be manufactured in Europe?
The NZIA has an overall goal of having 40pc of clean technology deployment made in Europe by 2030. But for solar, there is a specific target of at least 30GW of solar manufactured in Europe by 2030.
We project that in 2030, we will have a European market of well above 100GW, maybe around 120-125GW. But first, that 30GW goal for us represents meaningful scale. For the moment, we don't have scale and, depending on which supply chain step we talk about, we don't have more than 5GW of solar manufacturing in Europe right now. And that's what we need to overcome, we need to have industrial scale.
What are the mechanisms in place to increase solar manufacturing capacity?
There are a couple of things about the NZIA, but I think the most important are the provisions around non-price criteria, because they create demand for sustainable European products. And that's what the NZIA does, it creates a legal framework for non-price criteria around resilience and sustainability.
Sustainability is easy to understand. That's about carbon footprint or certain chemicals or recyclability, which need to be considered in public procurement. But resilience means that you are rewarded in public procurements and auctions if you have a product that is less composed by the dominant source of supply. So if you have a solar system that is not reliant on components that come from China, you get rewarded for that because you are valuable from a diversification point of view.
Looking further upstream, the raw materials used in solar manufacturing are very exposed to China, how much of a risk is that for Europe's solar manufacturers?
It's certainly a concern. The main raw material for solar is high-purity polysilicon, where we have this European player, Wacker Polysilicon, which already can cover a large part of the demand in Europe. The problem is that it's not followed through with capacity on the ingots and wafers, which then means that we have almost nothing on cells and only a little bit on the assembly of components.
But with [metals] such as germanium and gallium, the dependency on China is already exposed to a lot of geopolitics. For the moment, there is no problem with raw materials supply. But if the geopolitics around the energy transition and solar get more tense, and we move into more of an isolationist or protectionist trade war, then we may see that that becomes a problem.
It is very important for Solar Power Europe to make sure that we keep doing resilience and industrial strategy within an open trading mindset. Europe has nothing to gain from an escalating trade conflict. And in that sense, it also sets itself apart a little bit from the US, where the situation is very different. So, we want the EU to keep forging its own path and looking at its own interests.
Low polysilicon prices and high energy costs are really squeezing margins for polysilicon producers right now. Do you think in the long term that Europe will be resilient to competition from bigger players in China or the US?
There's a very important conversation happening on a European level now more and more about Europe's competitiveness in general. Europe's industrial ecosystem and competitiveness relies on cheap Russian gas, which we don't have anymore. We all know that ultimately the only way for Europe to be competitive is to accelerate the energy transition. Europe has no choice but to base its competitiveness on cheap solar and wind in a flexible electric grid system.
Related news posts
Australia’s Empire Energy signs deal to sell gas to NT
Australia’s Empire Energy signs deal to sell gas to NT
Adelaide, 26 July (Argus) — Australian independent Empire Energy has signed an agreement to supply the Northern Territory (NT) with gas from its Carpentaria project in the onshore Beetaloo subbasin. Empire will supply NT with up to 25 TJ/d (668,000 m³/d) of gas over 10 years, starting from mid-2025. This equates to an estimated total supply of 75PJ (2bn m3) of gas. The deal includes scope for an additional 10 TJ/d for up to 10 years if production level at the Carpentaria plant exceeds 100 TJ/d. The firm bought domestic utility AGL Energy's dormant 42 TJ/d Rosalind Park gas plant late last yearwith plans to reassemble the facility on site at Carpentaria, subject to a final investment decision on the project. Gas will be delivered to the NT government-owned Power and Water (PWC) via the McArthur River gas pipeline on an ex-field take-or-pay basis, Empire said on 26 July. PWC in April signed an agreement to buy 8.6PJ of gas from Australian independent Central Petroleum , to supply gas-fired power generation and private-sector customers. Low production at Italian energy firm Eni's Blacktip field, offshore the NT, has led PWC to court new supply while providing a new outlet for prospective producers operating within Beetaloo. The largest Beetaloo acreage holder, Tamboran Resources, has revealed ambitious plans for a 6.6mn t/yr LNG plant to be located near Darwin Harbour's two existing LNG projects, using the basin's shale gas resources as feedstock. By Tom Major Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
EU could launch 'other countries' HRC dumping probe
EU could launch 'other countries' HRC dumping probe
London, 25 July (Argus) — The European Commission soon could initiate a dumping investigation on some exporters selling into the 'other countries' quota for hot-rolled coil (HRC), according to multiple market sources. The 'other countries' quota in recent quarters has consistently filled rapidly upon resetting, and this pressure has been intensified by rising Chinese exports since August of last year. Some key 'other countries' sellers have seen the volumes they take from China balloon as a result. Vietnam bought more than 4.2mn t from China in the first six months of this year, compared with about 6mn t in the whole of 2023. China's increased exports has sparked talk that both India and Vietnam may start anti-dumping duty investigations. When announcing its 15pc cap on countries selling into the 'other countries' quota, the commission specifically alluded to the increase in Chinese exports affecting trade flows. Vietnam, Egypt, Japan and Taiwan are by far the largest sellers into the 'other countries' quota, and all of the countries initially exceeded their 141,849t cap quickly when the new quotas took force on 1 July. In April, before the cap was implemented, these four countries amounted for more than half of the 1.4mn t imported by the EU. The 'other countries' quota has essentially been reduced from 940,000 t/quarter to less than 600,000 t/quarter given the new cap. Sources suggested duties could be applied retroactively if the commission finds that material has been dumped. They also suggested it could be difficult to show dumping in some countries, such as Vietnam and Egypt, where domestic prices are often below export levels. A leading producer was gathering information on Egyptian cargoes arriving at EU ports in recent months, a trading firm said. The commission refused to comment on any potential investigation. By Colin Richardson Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
China raises EV, ICE vehicles trade-in subsidies
China raises EV, ICE vehicles trade-in subsidies
Beijing, 25 July (Argus) — The Chinese government has raised subsidies to boost trade-in of old internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles with new energy vehicles (NEV). The subsidy for consumers who trade in an old NEV registered before 30 April 2018 or an ICE vehicle that meets or is below China's national 3 emission standard for a new NEV has doubled to 20,000 yuan from a previous subsidy announced in May . Electric vehicles cost anywhere between Yn50,000 to Yn1mn, with consumers mostly purchasing those in the Yn100,000-200,000 range, according to industry participants. The government is also offering a Yn15,000 subsidy for consumers who trade in an old NEV registered before 30 April 2018 or an ICE vehicle that meets or is below China's national 3 emission standard, and purchase a new ICE vehicle with the displacement below 2.0 litre. Beijing in early March announced a plan to promote the replacement of industrial equipment and consumer goods through large-scale trade-ins, with NEVs making up the main part of the scheme, as part of Beijing's efforts to meet its annual economic growth target of 5pc. China's ministry of finance announced on 3 June that it will allocate Yn6.44bn to local governments to pay the subsidies for vehicle trade-ins in 2024, including Yn107mn to Tianjin, Yn90.81mn to Shanghai, Yn74.61mn to Beijing and Yn66.49mn to Chongqing. The central government announced on 29 May that it will remove purchase restrictions for NEVs during 2024-25, with the capital city Beijing allocating 20,000 additional purchase quotas for NEVs to families without a car. China produced 1.003mn NEVs in June, up by 28pc from the previous year and by 6.7pc from May, with sales increasing by 30pc from a year earlier and by 9.8pc from the previous month to 1.049mn, partly driven by the country's supportive measures, especially the trade-in subsidies. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Refining, LNG segments take Total’s profit lower in 2Q
Refining, LNG segments take Total’s profit lower in 2Q
London, 25 July (Argus) — TotalEnergies said today that a worsening performance at its downstream Refining & Chemicals business and its Integrated LNG segment led to a 7pc year-on-year decline in profit in the second quarter. Profit of $3.79bn was down from $5.72bn for the January-March quarter and from $4.09bn in the second quarter of 2023. When adjusted for inventory effects and special items, profit was $4.67bn — slightly lower than analysts had been expecting and 6pc down on the immediately preceding quarter. The biggest hit to profits was at the Refining & Chemicals segment, which reported an adjusted operating profit of $639mn for the April-June period, a 36pc fall on the year. Earlier in July, TotalEnergies had flagged lower refining margins in Europe and the Middle East, with its European Refining Margin Marker down by 37pc to $44.9/t compared with the first quarter. This margin decline was partially compensated for by an increase in its refineries' utilisation rate: to 84pc in April-June from 79pc in the first quarter. The company's Integrated LNG business saw a 13pc year on year decline in its adjusted operating profit, to $1.15bn. TotalEnergies cited lower LNG prices and sales, and said its gas trading operation "did not fully benefit in markets characterised by lower volatility than during the first half of 2023." A bright spot was the Exploration & Production business, where adjusted operating profit rose by 14pc on the year to $2.67bn. This was mainly driven by higher oil prices, which were partially offset by lower gas realisations and production. The company's second-quarter production averaged 2.44mn b/d of oil equivalent (boe/d), down by 1pc from 2.46mn boe/d reported for the January-March period and from the 2.47mn boe/d average in the second quarter of 2023. TotalEnergies attributed the quarter-on-quarter decline to a greater level of planned maintenance, particularly in the North Sea. But it said its underlying production — excluding the Canadian oil sands assets it sold last year — was up by 3pc on the year. This was largely thanks to the start up and ramp up of projects including Mero 2 offshore Brazil, Block 10 in Oman, Tommeliten Alpha and Eldfisk North in Norway, Akpo West in Nigeria and Absheron in Azerbaijan. TotalEnergies said production also benefited from its entry into the producing fields Ratawi, in Iraq, and Dorado in the US. The company expects production in a 2.4mn-2.45mn boe/d range in the third quarter, when its Anchor project in the US Gulf of Mexico is expected to start up. The company increased profit at its Integrated Power segment, which contains its renewables and gas-fired power operations. Adjusted operating profit rose by 12pc year-on-year to $502mn and net power production rose by 10pc to 9.1TWh. TotalEnergies' cash flow from operations, excluding working capital, was $7.78bn in April-June — an 8pc fall from a year earlier. The company has maintained its second interim dividend for 2024 at €0.79/share and plans to buy back up to $2bn of its shares in the third quarter, in line with its repurchases in previous quarters. By Jon Mainwaring Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
![](/_next/image?url=%2F-%2Fmedia%2Fproject%2Fargusmedia%2Fmainsite%2Fimages%2F14-generic-hero-banners%2Fherobanner_1600x530_generic-c.jpg%3Fh%3D530%26iar%3D0%26w%3D1600%26rev%3D-1%26hash%3DFC2BEDE406483FEF5FDB9549159BAC11&w=3840&q=75)
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more