Viewpoint: US fuel oil supply challenge to deepen

Spanish Market: Oil products
30/12/24

US residual fuel oil supplies are dwindling and face multiple challenges in 2025 because of reduced global inventories and a persistent backwardation in the domestic market.

Total US inventories of residual fuel oil fell to a historic 42-year-low multiple times during 2024, including nine instances in the fourth quarter alone, according to Energy Information Administration (EIA) data. Supplies hit rock bottom at just under 23mn bl in the week ending 29 November, down by 12pc year-on-year.

Despite the shrinking supplies, the US market has shown little reaction. Throughout 2024, ICE Brent futures — the basis for US residual fuel oil — remained in backwardation between the front and second month, averaging $0.60/bl. This is nearly double the full year 2023 backwardation average of $0.39/bl.

The persistent backwardation of the fuel oil curve means inventory figures lack the drive to encourage wholesalers and retailers to make purchases in anticipation of future demand, traders said. The diminishing future value results in potential losses for traders who are considering purchasing spot barrels for storage as forward prices are lower than current spot prices.

Residual fuel oil is primarily used as a maritime fuel for large ships, a fuel for backup power generation and for various industrial purposes. In the US it is often refined further into other road fuels.

The production of US residual fuel oil has been steadily increasing in recent years, beginning even before implementation of the International Maritime Organization's 2020 global rule imposing a 0.5pc sulphur cap on marine fuels. However, output averages over the past four years remain well below pre-2019 levels.

Since the US imposed sanctions on Russian fuel exports in February 2023, weekly residual fuel oil imports into the US have averaged just over 100,000 b/d, nearly half of the previous two-year average at 196,000 b/d. Mexico has now become the largest fuel oil exporter to the US, accounting for nearly 33pc of all US fuel oil imports over the past two years, claiming the top spot from Russia.

Planned expansion of Mexico's refinery infrastructure may crimp US supplies, however. Mexican state-owned Pemex's 400,000 b/d Dos Bocas refinery — which is still in the start-up process — would take a greater share of Mexico's Maya crude. Maya crude yields a significant portion of fuel oil when refined. This would leave less Maya bound for the US, which has taken nearly 60pc of Mexico's Maya over the past three-years, according to Vortexa data.

Pemex is also adding two new coker units to its Tula and Salinas Cuz refineries as part efforts to become more self-reliant and add an additional 168,000 b/d of road fuel output. Coker units process fuel oil to turn it into higher value road fuels, which would curtail flows to the US.

Refinery maintenance involving a few US crude distillation units is set to begin in January, which could further limit domestic fuel oil production. The National Weather Service's winter forecast for the east coast is expected to be warmer than usual, likely leading to reduced demand for both high-sulphur fuel oil used in power generation and low-sulphur blending components.

By Craig Ross

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

31/12/24

Viewpoint: USGC gasoline oversupply unlikely to ease

Houston, 31 December (Argus) — Refinery closures and increased export opportunities in the US Gulf coast (USGC) will likely do little to alleviate an oversupply of regional gasoline in early 2025 as refining capacity in Mexico expands. LyondellBasell's 264,000 b/d Houston refinery tentatively plans to shut down during the first quarter of 2025 after previously delaying an end to production from the final quarter of 2023. Though some refiners welcome refinery shutdowns to provide a lift to falling margins , market participants have suggested that the upcoming closures will not considerably reduce the oversupply of product in the region. The Gulf coast's weekly average output totaled 2.2mn b/d in 2024, over one-fifth of the US's 9.7mn b/d weekly average. LyondellBasell's Houston refinery closure could cause total weekly production in the region to contract by as much as 12pc if it goes as planned. Product supplied, a proxy used by the US Energy Information Administration (EIA) for finished motor gasoline demand nationwide, has not recovered to pre-pandemic levels. Demand had fallen to fresh lows of 8.15mn b/d in 2020, when Covid-19 pandemic restrictions limited travel, but marginally regained strength after those measures were lifted. In the five years prior to the pandemic, gasoline product supplied ranged between a yearly average of 8.86mn-9.34mn b/d. In 2024, it averaged 8.85mn b/d, just below the pre-pandemic five-year average, but has grown for a second consecutive year after hitting a record low of 8.1mn b/d for 2022. In its energy outlook for 2025, the Louisiana State University's (LSU) Center for Energy Studies said it expected domestic demand to remain relatively flat, but that increased US net exports could shave off excess supply. Gulf coast gasoline stockpiles have exhibited steady growth since 2022, largely outpacing demand for the product, EIA data indicates. In the five years prior to the Covid-19 pandemic, weekly inventory averages ranged between 75mn-83mn bl. After hitting a record weekly average of 86.9mn bl in 2020, stockpiles have hovered above the pre-pandemic range for every year since, with 2024 weekly average inventory levels totaling 83.1mn bl. Gasoline prices peaked in 2022 due to rebounding gasoline demand since the pandemic. Though prices remain above the $2/USG mark since 2020, cash prices for 87 conventional finished gasoline in 2024 averaged 68¢/USG lower than in 2022 and 23¢/USG less than 2023's average, further depressing refining margins from a year earlier. Exports: a closing door Both exports to Latin America and domestic shipments to the US east coast have historically absorbed excess supplies of Gulf coast gasoline, but increased refining capacity and a potential trade war between the US and Mexico could choke off exports to Latin America. Market participants point to exports as a favorable outlet for excess gasoline supply with export data showing a strong correlation with the stock build in the Gulf coast since 2022. The US Gulf coast exported an average of 251,000 b/d in 2024 after four consecutive years of gains, according to trade analytics firm Kpler. Export levels out of the region are more than double the pre-pandemic four-year average of 121,750 b/d. However, Pemex's 400,000 b/d Dos Bocas refinery in Mexico is projected to come on line in late 2025 and will likely reduce the Gulf coast's share of the gasoline export market. Mexico imports nearly 90pc of its gasoline from the US , while roughly 82pc of Gulf coast exports land in Mexico, according to separate Kpler data. Mexican president Claudia Sheinbaum has continued expanding Mexico's energy independence, with 2024 marking the closest in nine years that gasoline production has approached import levels . Furthermore, US president-elect Donald Trump's potential 25pc tariff on imports from Canada and Mexico, including oil and gas, could spark retaliatory tariffs from Mexico, previously threatened by Sheinbaum. Should Trump go through with the tariffs when he takes office on 20 January, the tariffs between both countries would cut off gasoline exports and leave stockpile levels in the Gulf coast significantly higher. By Hannah Borai Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Viewpoint: US Supreme Court tees up more energy cases

31/12/24

Viewpoint: US Supreme Court tees up more energy cases

Washington, 31 December (Argus) — The US Supreme Court is on track for another term that could significantly affect the energy sector, with rulings anticipated in the new year that could narrow environmental reviews and challenge California's authority to set its own tailpipe standards. The Supreme Court earlier this month held arguments in Seven County Infrastructure Coalition v Eagle County, Colorado , a case in which the justices are being asked to decide whether federal rail regulators adequately studied the environmental effects of a proposed 88-mile railway that would transport 80,000 b/d of crude. A lower court last year found the review, prepared under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), should have analyzed how building the project would affect drilling and refining. Business groups want the Supreme Court to issue an expansive ruling that would limit NEPA reviews only to "proximate" effects, such as how rail traffic could affect nearby wildlife, rather than reviewing distance effects. The court recently agreed to hear a separate case that could restrict California's unique authority under the Clean Air Act to issue its own greenhouse gas regulations for newly sold cars and pickup trucks that are more stringent than federal standards. Oil refiners and biofuel producers in that case, Diamond Alternative Energy v EPA , say they should have "standing" to advance a lawsuit challenging those standards — even though they could now show prevailing in the case would change fuel demand — based on the alleged "coercive and predictable effects of regulation on third parties". These two cases, likely to be decided by the end of June, follow on the heels of the court's blockbuster decision in June overturning the decades-old "Chevron deference", a foundation for administration law that had given federal agencies greater flexibility when writing regulations. Last term, the court also limited agency enforcement powers and halted a rule targeting cross-state air pollution sources. This term's cases are unlikely to have as far-reaching consequences for the energy sector as overturning Chevron. But industry officials hope the two pending cases will provide clarity on issues that have been problematic for developers, including the scope of federal environmental reviews and the ability of industry to win legal "standing" to bring lawsuits. Two other cases could have significant effects for the oil sector, if the court agrees to consider them at a conference set for 10 January. Utah has a pending complaint before the court designed to force the US to dispose of 18.5mn acres of "unappropriated" federal land in the state, including oil-producing acreage. Utah argues that indefinitely retaining the land — which covers about a third of Utah — is unconstitutional. In another pending case, Sunoco and other oil companies have asked for a ruling that could halt a series of lawsuits filed against them in state courts for alleged damages from greenhouse gas emissions. President-elect Donald Trump's re-election could create complications for cases pending before the Supreme Court, if the incoming administration adopts new legal positions. Trump plans to nominate John Sauer, who successfully represented Trump in his presidential immunity case, as his solicitor general before the Supreme Court. By Chris Knight Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Viewpoint: Chancay port may increase Peru bunker demand

30/12/24

Viewpoint: Chancay port may increase Peru bunker demand

New York, 30 December (Argus) — The opening of Peru's Chancay port next year likely will boost the country's bunkering demand and drive-up competition on the Latin American Pacific coast. Able to accommodate larger ships and vessels equipped with marine exhaust scrubbers, the unveiling of the new facility — likely in the first quarter — could spur demand for very low-sulphur fuel oil (VLSFO) and high-sulphur fuel oil (HSFO). Chancay, which is owned by Chinese state-owned port operating company Cosco Shipping and Peruvian mining company Volcan, has a 17.8-meter depth, compared with a depth of 16 meters in El Callao part, which is south of Chancay near Lima, Peru. Chancay's depth allows it to receive container ships with a capacity of up to 18,000 twenty-foot equivalent units The larger vessels will likely take on around 3,000-5,000 metric tonnes of marine fuel in one port call, according to one source familiar with the Peruvian bunker market. "The port is gradually beginning to receive container vessels, RoRo, and bulk carriers," said Augusto Ganoza, who heads Chilean bunker supplier Agunsa's operations in Peru. "I anticipate an increase in bunkering demand at Chancay, particularly if vessels call at Callao first and then proceed to Chancay, which I believe will be the case for most." But bunker buying appetite in Chancay also will depend on marine fuel prices in China. El Callao VLSFO was assessed at a $85/t premium to Zhoushan, China, in November. That differential tightened from its peak earlier this year at $143/t in April. That differential could temper the expected increase in bunkering demand in Peru. Other market contacts from outside Peru said that any increase in demand stemming from Chancay's opening is unlikely to drag down activity in competing ports such as Panama, largely because of higher prices in Peru and better quality of bunker fuel available in Panama. The VLSFO November monthly average in El Callao was $656/t, which was an $89/t premium to Panama VLSFO. By Luis Gronda Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Viewpoint: US midcon E15 shift looms again

30/12/24

Viewpoint: US midcon E15 shift looms again

Houston, 30 December (Argus) — A potential reformulation of gasoline in eight midcontinent states to accommodate year-round 15pc ethanol gasoline (E15) could lead to shortages in midcontinent fuel supply and an increase in retail prices in 2025. Approaching the 2025 summer driving season, Illinois, Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska, Ohio, South Dakota, Wisconsin and, now, Missouri once again await the US Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) enforcement of compliance on their exclusion from the 1-psi rule. The one-pound waiver in the Clean Air Act allows for a 1 psi higher Reid Vapor Pressure (RVP), a more expensive specification for 9-10pc ethanol blend that allows gasoline during the summer to be 9 RVP. Opting out would lead to the production of two separate grades of gasoline, the standard summer 9 RVP CBOB and a new, non-waiver 7.80 RVP CBOB that could be blended into E15. Many of the refiners and pipelines in the region would serve states that have opted out of the waiver, and states that will remain within the waiver and the lack of uniformity in specifications across the midcontinent would likely cause difficulty in logistics for refiners and pipeline operators. This new 7.80 RVP gasoline formulation would be a boutique grade CBOB that would only be found in the midcontinent during the summer, adding to the difficulty of producing the grade. The differences between the waiver and the non-waiver grades of gasoline would be mostly contained to the summer driving season, according to participants in the US midcontinent gasoline market. American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers (AFPM), a trade association for fuel makers, again petitioned the EPA to delay the midcontinent governors' request until 2026. AFPM cited a new study by US consultancy Baker and O'Brien that forecast a 131,000 b/d decrease in CBOB production if the midcontinent states were to opt out of the waiver. This would be the equivalent of a sustained refinery outage in the region and could lead to supply-cost increases of 9-12¢/USG, up from an estimated 8-12¢/USG a year earlier. Baker and O'Brien's study also indicated that supply costs could be between $700mn and $1.2bn, with the lower end using the 185 days of the summer driving season with no disruptions and the upper end of the range assuming at least a two-week regional supply shortage. The study also said that a delay until 2026 would allow for more time to implement the capital investments needed to fully accommodate the change to non-waiver gasoline in some of the states but noted that many of the improvements needed would take two years to complete. Many refiners and pipeline operators are hesitant to invest when a legislative solution could make the changes unnecessary. US Gulf coast supply lines The US midcontinent relies on the US Gulf coast to provide resupply in the event of a refinery outage in the region or to accommodate increasing demand. The Explorer Pipeline which connects from the US Gulf coast to the US midcontinent is one of the major pipelines to deliver product into the region. Transit time on the pipeline for delivery to the Chicago area is roughly two weeks. The US midcontinent in 2021-2024 averaged receipts of 1.16mn bl/month of finished gasoline during the May-September summer driving season, according to US Energy Information Administration data. The arbitrage for shipping CBOB into the US midcontinent from the US Gulf coast is already on average open across the summer. A change in formulations would likely increase the need for product. Southern US midcontinent CBOB averaged an 8.33¢/USG premium to US Gulf coast product during the summer, over the Explorer's 7.14¢/USG tariff for shipping product from Pasadena, Texas, to Tulsa, Oklahoma. Chicago's Buckeye Complex CBOB averaged a 10.10¢/USG premium to its Gulf coast counterpart, also over the 8.40¢/USG tariff for shipping. History of delays The governors of Iowa, Nebraska, Illinois, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, Kansas, South Dakota and North Dakota in 2022 requested an exclusion from the 1-pound waiver in the Clean Air Act by claiming the waiver was contributing to air pollution in those states, a request that would require blendstocks for E10 and E15 sold in those states to be reformulated. The EPA granted their request in February 2024, but delayed lifting the waiver for summer 2024, following a slew of petitions from trade associations, refiners and pipeline companies asking for delays. The measure is still pending. President Joe Biden's administration avoided a potential disruption to seasonal E15 sales by tapping emergency powers in April 2022 to allow for the sale of E15 during the approaching summer, citing supply disruptions in the wake of Russia's invasion of Ukraine. EPA issued similar emergency waivers ahead of summer in 2023 and 2024 to facilitate the sale of E15, using the waiver 9 RVP gasoline. The US Congress is considering legislation options to avoid requirements to reformulate gasoline. A stopgap government funding bill that would fund the government through March included language to extend the one-pound waiver to E15 year-round and make the shift by the eight midcontinent states and the attached reformulation unnecessary. But the E15 provision was pulled from the stopgap funding bill following criticisms from President-elect Donald Trump and Telsa chief executive Elon Musk . By Zach Appel Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Viewpoint: European diesel to stay under pressure

30/12/24

Viewpoint: European diesel to stay under pressure

London, 30 December (Argus) — The European diesel market appears to be in a period of transition defined by economic headwinds, a decline in structural demand and anticipated refinery closures in the new year. These factors are exerting downward pressure on diesel refining margins, with the IEA forecasting no return to the high margin environment experienced immediately after the Covid-19 pandemic. Margins in Europe have been trending downwards in 2024 to below $17/bl, lower by a third from $28.53/bl in 2023 and less than half the heady levels of $37.27/bl in 2022. The economic rebound experienced in the immediate aftermath of the pandemic bequeathed a high inflationary environment, and this became a significant headwind in Europe going into 2024. Central banks tightened monetary policy to counteract this, dampening economic activity and as a consequence demand for diesel, the primary fuel grade powering transport fleets, construction equipment and manufacturing. European demand has been notably lacklustre. The largest economies in the region, Germany and France, saw diesel consumption decline by 4pc and 3pc respectively in 2024, according to the most recent published data. The former's loss of cheap Russian gas has undermined its economic model, which appears to have had a structural effect on national diesel demand. Any improvement in European economic fortunes in 2025 will likely provide a tailwind for outright diesel values. Driving issues Europe is also experiencing a systemic decline in diesel vehicle usage as electric and hybrid vehicles take up an ever increasing share. Newly-registered diesel passenger vehicles made up 14.9pc of the German market and 6.1pc of the UK market in November, according to SMMT and KBA data, compared with 31.6pc and 45.8pc for pure gasoline vehicles. New hybrid vehicles claimed a 38.7pc market share in Germany. Delays to outright national bans on new diesel or gasoline vehicle sales may stem the decline in popularity for diesel vehicles, but the trend is unlikely to be reversed. European refinery closures could serve to rebalance the market next year. Petroineos' 150,000 b/d Grangemouth refinery in Scotland will become an import terminal. In Germany, Shell will cease crude processing at its 147,000 b/d Wesseling refinery and BP plans to permanently shut down a crude unit and a middle distillate desulphurisation unit at its 257,000 b/d Gelsenkirchen plant. The degree to which these capacity losses are baked into market pricing is debatable, as the refiners could decide to delay closures in the event that diesel margins recover. But the limited effect of recent unscheduled refinery outages in the Mediterranean region illustrates how Europe can bear to lose two crude units, at least in the short term. In 2025, European diesel prices may again take direction from developments outside the region, particularly the profitability of key arbitrage routes from the US Gulf coast, the Mideast Gulf and India. European diesel values and margins were affected by refinery turnarounds in supplier regions in 2024. Prices may come under further pressure in 2025 from the start of 10ppm diesel production this month at Nigeria's 650,000 b/d Dangote refinery, which could completely offset the loss in European refining capacity. Any easing in Yemen-based Houthi militant aggression in the Red Sea may encourage diesel cargoes back through the Suez Canal, cutting down delivery times and weighing on supply volatility. Price-supportive developments may come from the EU tightening sanctions on Russia's 'dark fleet', which could weigh on global supply, and an upcoming US refinery maintenance season that is is touted to be disruptive. Two US refineries will close in 2025. By George Maher-Bonnett Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more