European ammonia production remains uncompetitive
Domestic ammonia production remains uncompetitive with imports into Europe, even as European gas prices have fallen to their lowest since July 2021.
The front-month contract at the Dutch TTF — Europe's most traded gas hub — closed below €35/MWh on Wednesday for the first time since July 2021. It has fallen by around 50pc since the start of the year, and is almost 90pc below its all-time high of €319/MWh in August last year (see TTF graph).
Gas accounts for the majority of European ammonia production costs, meaning that the dramatic fall in gas prices has dragged down domestic production costs. But import prices have fallen even further, meaning it is still more economical to import ammonia than to produce it domestically.
Domestic ammonia production briefly became competitive with imports again early this year, having been uneconomical for the second half of last year. But imports have again become cheaper than domestic production since 16 March, although the gap has narrowed in recent weeks (see production vs import graph).
This has led to production curtailments in Europe in favour of imports. As of the end of April, Europe's largest ammonia producer Yara had curtailed 2.8mn t/yr — or 58pc — of its European capacity. It took its 600,000 t/yr Ferrara plant off line in late April, just three weeks after bringing it back on line following a nine-month shutdown, and is planning maintenance at its 383,000 t/yr Tertre plant in Belgium in the second quarter.
German chemicals giant BASF similarly reduced its first-quarter ammonia production, and plans to permanently close one of its ammonia plants.
Instead of trading its own output, Yara has said it will "use its global sourcing and production system to import ammonia to Europe and supply global customers where possible". Its European production facilities are located near ports, "enabling imports of raw materials like ammonia to limit production costs when European gas prices are high", Yara said.
Yara's EU plants — excluding its UK facility in Immingham — consume roughly 36mn Btu of gas per ton of ammonia produced according to Argus consulting services. This suggests that 2.8mn t/yr of idled capacity as of the end of April equates to an annual loss of just under 2.5bn m³/yr of gas consumption. And if the 42pc production rate at Yara's plants were mirrored across the entire EU's 19.6mn t/yr of production capacity, this would translate into a gas demand cut of just over 10bn m³/yr.
Weak chance of 3Q demand revival
The significant reduction in ammonia production costs is yet to stimulate much greater downstream demand for fertilisers, and seasonally low third-quarter demand makes it unlikely that there will be an uptick later this summer.
The significant fall in ammonia production costs in recent months has only spurred a small amount of additional demand in Europe, India and China.
And global fertiliser demand is normally at its lowest in the third quarter, while the US' 1.3mn t/yr Gulf Coast ammonia plant in Texas is due to come on line in July, suggesting an oversupplied market, according to Argus' latest ammonia outlook.
Ammonia demand may only pick up from around September, which is when buyers typically begin accumulating fertiliser stock for the autumn application season.
![](https://public-assets.argusmedia.com/2023/05/12/ammoniaproductionvsimportcosts12052023121142.jpg)
![](https://public-assets.argusmedia.com/2023/05/12/ttfmonth112052023121105.jpg)
Related news posts
India's Fact seeks 40,000t of 15-15-15 in tender
India's Fact seeks 40,000t of 15-15-15 in tender
London, 26 July (Argus) — Indian fertilizer importer Fact has issued a tender to buy two 20,000t lots of 15-15-15. The tender will close on 9 August, and Fact intends to open offers on the same day. The importer requests delivery of one cargo to Kakinada and the other to Tuticorin, both on India's east coast. In both cases, Fact seeks a laycan at the discharge ports of 15-31 October. In late May, Fact bought two 30,000t lots of 15-15-15 against a tender , paying $342/t cfr duty unpaid, with credit terms of 30 days, for Russian product. Prices around the latest tender will be higher, following a firming of the market. Fact's request marks the second major Indian tender for complex fertilizers this week, after fellow importer HURL requested 30,000t lots of 20-20-0+13S . By David Maher Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Australia’s Ichthys LNG to restart liquefaction train
Australia’s Ichthys LNG to restart liquefaction train
Singapore, 26 July (Argus) — The second liquefaction train at Australia's 9.3mn t/yr Ichthys LNG export terminal plans to resume partial operations today, after going off line unexpectedly during 18-19 July, according to traders. The export facility is operated by Japanese upstream firm Inpex. Repairs at the affected train could take up to a month before it returns to full production, although the train is expected to restart by this weekend, according to market participants. Attempts to restart train two could take place by 26 July. Some delays to deliveries from the facility are expected, although there are also unconfirmed reports that up to two cargoes may have already been cancelled at the time of writing. The overall impact on the market is likely to be limited for now, with continuing weak spot demand from northeast Asian importers. Some term buyers previously requested for their deliveries to be deferred, traders said, although it is unclear just how many requests for deferment were received. But other participants have pointed out that the winter restocking season could soon start and any further impediments to train two's restart could lift prices. Recent temperatures in Japan have been higher than expected, with at least a 70pc probability of above-normal temperatures over the vast majority of the country until 23 August, according to the latest forecast issued by the Japan Meteorological Agency on 25 July. At least one Japanese utility may be considering spot purchases for August, owing to higher-than-expected power consumption because of warmer temperatures. But at least two other Japanese firms could be looking to sell a September and an October cargo each, traders said, which could indicate that the spot market is still sufficiently well-supplied to cope with additional demand from Japanese utilities. The 174,000m³ Grace Freesia departed from Ichthys on 25 July after loading an LNG cargo, according to ship tracking data from Kpler. The export terminal sold a spot cargo for loading over 2-6 June at around high-$9s/mn Btu through a tender that closed on 10 May, but further details are unclear. The US' 17.3mn t/yr Freeport export terminal also faced issues restarting since it was first taken off line on 7 July as a precautionary measure against Hurricane Beryl. The terminal loaded its first cargo on 21 July . All three trains are likely to be back on line as of 26 July, although production at the facility should still be closely monitored, traders said. By Naomi Ong Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Australia’s Empire Energy signs deal to sell gas to NT
Australia’s Empire Energy signs deal to sell gas to NT
Adelaide, 26 July (Argus) — Australian independent Empire Energy has signed an agreement to supply the Northern Territory (NT) with gas from its Carpentaria project in the onshore Beetaloo subbasin. Empire will supply NT with up to 25 TJ/d (668,000 m³/d) of gas over 10 years, starting from mid-2025. This equates to an estimated total supply of 75PJ (2bn m3) of gas. The deal includes scope for an additional 10 TJ/d for up to 10 years if production level at the Carpentaria plant exceeds 100 TJ/d. The firm bought domestic utility AGL Energy's dormant 42 TJ/d Rosalind Park gas plant late last yearwith plans to reassemble the facility on site at Carpentaria, subject to a final investment decision on the project. Gas will be delivered to the NT government-owned Power and Water (PWC) via the McArthur River gas pipeline on an ex-field take-or-pay basis, Empire said on 26 July. PWC in April signed an agreement to buy 8.6PJ of gas from Australian independent Central Petroleum , to supply gas-fired power generation and private-sector customers. Low production at Italian energy firm Eni's Blacktip field, offshore the NT, has led PWC to court new supply while providing a new outlet for prospective producers operating within Beetaloo. The largest Beetaloo acreage holder, Tamboran Resources, has revealed ambitious plans for a 6.6mn t/yr LNG plant to be located near Darwin Harbour's two existing LNG projects, using the basin's shale gas resources as feedstock. By Tom Major Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
BayWa suspends 2024 profit forecast over restructuring
BayWa suspends 2024 profit forecast over restructuring
London, 25 July (Argus) — German agricultural group BayWa on Wednesday suspended its full-year profit forecast due on 8 August, citing ongoing restructuring. It posted a preliminary revenue of €10.7bn ($11.6bn) for the first half of the year, down by 15pc from €12.6bn a year ago. BayWa's first-half 2024 preliminary earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation stood at €149.5mn, less than half of the €322.1mn earned in the same period last year. BayWa said it continues to be in constructive talks with its financing partners, adding that it also has postponed publication of the final half-yearly results to 27 September, citing impairment reviews. The company commissioned a restructuring report on 12 July in response to a "strained financing situation". The Munich-headquartered BayWa Group operates in the fields of energy, agriculture — including fertilizers — and building materials. By Suzie Skipper Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
![](/_next/image?url=%2F-%2Fmedia%2Fproject%2Fargusmedia%2Fmainsite%2Fimages%2F14-generic-hero-banners%2Fherobanner_1600x530_generic-c.jpg%3Fh%3D530%26iar%3D0%26w%3D1600%26rev%3D-1%26hash%3DFC2BEDE406483FEF5FDB9549159BAC11&w=3840&q=75)
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more