Chinese steel investment needs to avoid lock in: CBI

Spanish Market: Hydrogen, Metals
15/10/24

Chinese investment in steel assets needs to be aligned with a Paris-compatible scenario to avoid locking in emissions and stranded assets, according to a report by non-profit Climate Bonds Initiative (CBI).

Almost 80pc or 730.8mn t/yr of China's existing coal-based blast furnace capacity will need to be retired or require reinvestment by 2030, CBI said in its report released last week. Steel asset lifetimes often exceed 40 years, so "investment decisions made today can lock in billions of tons of emissions and potentially billions of dollars in stranded assets", CBI added.

Steel production currently accounts for around 8pc of global CO2 emissions, and almost 50pc of global steel output is from China, CBI said. China's steel sector is estimated to require at least 1.6 trillion yuan ($226bn) in fixed asset investment for decarbonisation by 2050, according to a joint report by CBI and US-based Rocky Mountain Institute (RMI) earlier this year. Of the Yn1.6 trillion, 33pc should go to energy efficiency, 23pc for electric arc furnaces, 18pc for direct iron reduction (DRI), 14pc for carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS), 7pc for blast furnace hydrogen injection, and 5pc for pellet manufacturing.

Green bonds

Steel companies can obtain financing through labelled green bonds from various categories at the project level, including energy efficiency, heat recycling, waste and resource recycle, green hydrogen, biomass, and CCUS.

A total of Yn4.46 trillion of labelled green bonds had originated from China in domestic and overseas markets as of the end of 2023, according to CBI. But Chinese steel firms had only issued 23 green bonds totalling Yn3.5bn and six sustainability-linked bonds totalling Yn1.6bn by the end of last year, representing 0.1pc of the total Chinese labelled bond market. This Yn5.1bn falls very short of the estimated Yn1.6 trillion needed to decarbonise the Chinese steel sector.

CBI asserts that the labelled bond and loan market can supply the required capital, but issuers operating in the steel sector must be encouraged to price deals with the recommended transparency and credibility.

Recommendations

Several Chinese provinces have already issued provincial-level transition finance guidance, including major steel-producing Hebei province this year. But China's national-level transition finance guidance remains under development.

CBI thus recommends that the national transition taxonomy further align provincial guidelines and "enhance interoperability" between Chinese and international transition taxonomies, incentivise low-carbon production methods, customise financing for small-to-medium companies, and enhance entity-level transition plans.

CBI also suggests that banks incentivise companies to enhance the quality of their information disclosure and integrate such incentives into their transition frameworks. The non-profit also urged steel companies to issue credible transition plans, which should include Paris-aligned emission-reduction targets and clear capital expenditure plans.

Lastly, CBI notes that policies should support hydrogen infrastructure and supply chain development to accelerate green hydrogen deployment for high-emitting sectors. This is especially as current financing to decarbonise heavy industrial sectors have mainly been for mature technologies, such as raising energy efficiency. But green hydrogen can reduce over 90pc of steel production emissions, and steady development in hydrogen infrastructure and supply chain will cut costs and accelerate the steel transition.

CBI also flagged public sector steel procurement as an avenue through which the country can boost demand for green steel, especially since Chinese public authorities buy about 350mn t/yr of steel, which causes around 689mn t/yr of CO2 emissions. Green public procurement (GPP) policies in China would also have a global impact, with steel public procurement demand in China three times that of India's total steel demand of 100mn t/yr. CDI suggests that the Chinese government accelerate adopting national-level standards to ensure consistent embodied emissions reporting, as GPP policies will only be effective when implemented with standardised methodologies.

By Tng Yong Li

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

13/05/25

UK TRA proposes 40pc cap on other countries' HDG

London, 13 May (Argus) — The UK Trade Remedies Authority (TRA) has recommended the imposition of a 40pc cap on the other countries' quotas for hot-dip galvanised (HDG) and plate in its statement of final determination published today. It proposes that the caps come into effect on 1 October to enable material already on the water to clear and avoid supply restrictions. "This would address the concern about crowding out, whilst maintaining a similar volume of imports to come from existing supply countries," the TRA said. The other countries' quota for HDG is 88,075t for July-September, meaning anyone selling into it — the quota is dominated by Vietnam and South Korea — has access to 35,230t before duties become payable. The TRA said there should be no cap on organic coated material, despite requests to the contrary from UK Steel. Going forward, Turkey will not be in scope of the safeguard on HDG as its share during the investigation period was just 0.1pc. The TRA said unused quota should no longer be rolled forward to the next quota, and that countries with their own individual quota should have no access to the residual other countries' quota in the final quarter of the quota year, April-June. These two changes are largely in line with those made by the EU in its recent safeguard review. Vietnam will also come into the residual quota for hot-rolled coil, which is 24,295t/quarter, as its volumes have exceeded the 3pc limit specified by the WTO for developing economy status, reaching 4.3pc in the TRA's investigation period. Vietnam had been a favoured origin for traders and buyers, given its previous exemption from the measures. Egypt remains exempt and will likely be subject to increased interest going forward. Some large buyers have been visiting the country in recent months to establish supply lines. The TRA's recommendation "falls short of what is required, given the scale of the challenge the UK industry is faced with", UK Steel said. By Colin Richardson Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Mexico industrial production contracts in March

13/05/25

Mexico industrial production contracts in March

Mexico City, 13 May (Argus) — Mexico's industrial production contracted by 0.9pc in March from the previous month, as declines in mining and manufacturing were only partly offset by continued growth in construction. The drop was not enough to undo the 2.2pc increase in February — the sharpest monthly expansion in four years — as manufacturers ramped up output ahead of incoming US tariffs. The March industrial production index (IMAI), published by statistics agency Inegi, was higher than Mexican bank Banorte's forecast of a 1.4pc decline. Banorte noted signs of volatility affecting manufacturing and other sectors because of a complex trade outlook. Manufacturing contracted 1.1pc in March after expanding 2.9pc in February. The impact varied across subsectors, with metal goods down 5.5pc and transportation, including auto production, down 1.1pc. Volatility may ease in the coming months as US tariff policies become clearer and Mexican officials push to preserve the country's trade edge under US-Mexico-Canada (USMCA) free trade agreement rules, Banorte said. Construction expanded 0.8pc in March, following increases of 3.4pc in February and 0.5pc in January, driven by higher public investment tied to President Claudia Sheinbaum's economic plan, "Plan Mexico." Analysts see the plan as a catalyst for continued growth in construction this year, with measures including greater domestic content in public purchases, public-private participation in infrastructure projects and a target of $100bn in private infrastructure investment for 2025. These effects could be amplified by aggressive interest rate cuts from the central bank. Mining contracted by 2.7pc in March, returning to negative territory after a slight 0.1pc uptick in February. Oil and gas output also contracted 2.7pc after rising 1.0pc the month before, while non-oil mining contracted 4.3pc in March after a 0.6pc increase in February. By James Young Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

US inflation eases to 2.3pc in April

13/05/25

US inflation eases to 2.3pc in April

Houston, 13 May (Argus) — US inflation slowed in April, pulled lower by falling gasoline prices, while core inflation continued to show signs of mounting inflation pressures, as the new US administration's tariff policies have scrambled corporate and consumer investment and spending patterns. The consumer price index (CPI) slowed to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 2.3pc in April, down from 2.4pc in March and off from 2.8pc in February and the lowest rate since February 2021, the Labor Department reported Tuesday. Analysts surveyed by Trading Economics had forecast a 2.4pc rate for April. Core inflation, which strips out volatile food and energy, rose at an 2.8pc annual rate, unchanged from the prior month. The deceleration in inflation came a month after President Donald Trump began to levy tariffs on imports from China and on steel, aluminum and automobiles, starting in February. Several tariff deadlines were pushed back, including a three-month pause enacted this week on much steeper tariffs for most countries. The tariffs have prompted companies and consumers to pull back on investments and some purchases while shaking up financial markets, and heightening concerns of a global recession. The energy index fell by an annual 3.7pc in April, down from 3.3pc in March. Gasoline fell by 11.8pc after a 9.8pc decline. Piped natural gas rose by an annual 15.7pc following a 9.4pc gain. Food rose by an annual 2.8pc, slowing from 3pc. Eggs slowed to an annual 49.3pc after an annual 60.4pc, as avian flu has slashed supply. Shelter rose by an annual 4pc in March, matching the prior gain. Services less energy services rose by 3.6pc, slowing from 3.7pc in March. New vehicle prices edged up by an annual 0.3pc. CPI rose by a monthly 0.2pc in April after falling by 0.1pc in March. Core inflation rose by 0.2pc for the month following a 0.1pc gain in March. By Bob Willis Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

France mulls 1.5pc renewable H2 target for transport

13/05/25

France mulls 1.5pc renewable H2 target for transport

Paris, 13 May (Argus) — France has opened a consultation on a proposed 1.5pc renewable hydrogen quota for the transport sector by 2030, and hefty penalties to back this up. The country's ecological transition ministry has proposed a mechanism for reducing emissions in the transport sector called IRICC. This would replace the existing Tiruert system and would, among other measures, introduce specific quotas for use of renewable and low-carbon hydrogen. The proposed regulations set specific quotas for greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reductions that fuel suppliers would have to meet across different transport sectors in 2026-35. In line with requirements of the EU's renewable energy directive (REDIII), it also sets specific sub-quotas for renewable fuels of non-biological origin (RFNBOs), which are effectively renewable hydrogen or derivatives. These would start at 0.1pc in 2026 and rise steadily to 1.5pc by 2030 and to 2pc by 2035. This does not factor in double-counting, which the EU rules allow, meaning the quotas should reflect the actual share of RFNBO supply delivered to the transport sector. France's target exceeds the minimum 1pc requirement under EU rules, which effectively constitute a minimum share of only 0.5pc when factoring in the possibility for double-counting. Some EU members have set more ambitious targets. Finland is aiming for a 4pc quota by 2030 . But others, like Denmark, are planning a less ambitious implementation of EU rules, which has drawn the ire of domestic hydrogen industry participants . France's proposed quota is not set in stone as it is seeking feedback on whether a 0.8pc quota would be preferable. The consultation text does not specify if Paris would allow renewable hydrogen used to make transport fuels in refineries to be counted towards the targets with or without a so-called correction factor. The document foresees specific targets for use of synthetic fuels "produced with low-carbon electricity" in the aviation and maritime sectors. For aviation these would be 1.2pc for 2030, 2pc for 2032 and 5pc for 2035 — broadly in line with mandates from the EU's ReFuelEU Aviation legislation. Crucially, these mandates can be fulfilled with renewable supply and with aviation fuels made with nuclear power. Unlike for other EU targets, the ReFuelEU Aviation rules provide this option, leaving France in a promising position to become a major producer of synthetic aviation fuels thanks to its large nuclear fleet. The EU has not yet set binding targets for synthetic fuels in the maritime sector, but the French proposal foresees quotas of 1.2pc for 2030 and 2pc for 2034. The new mechanism will arguably allow for trading of GHG emissions reduction and fuel supply credits, similar to Tiruert, although the consultation document does not detail this specifically. Hefty penalties Hefty penalties for non-compliance could ensure that obliged parties meet their quotas. The ministry is proposing a penalty of €80 ($89) for each GJ that fuel suppliers fall short of their RFNBO quotas. This would equate to around €9.60/kg, based on hydrogen's lower heating value of 120 MJ/kg. It is broadly in line with penalties set by the Czech Republic , but considerably higher than those in Finland. Crucially, the penalties would be in addition to potential fines for falling short of the larger GHG emissions reduction targets. Companies could additionally incur penalties of €700/tonne of CO2 they fail to avoid short of their requirements. Stakeholders can respond to the consultation until 10 June. By Stefan Krumpelmann and Pamela Machado Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

ISTA blasts 'ludicrous' Tata Steel UK assertion to TRA

13/05/25

ISTA blasts 'ludicrous' Tata Steel UK assertion to TRA

London, 13 May (Argus) — Tata Steel UK's claim to the Trade Remedies Authority (TRA) that 2m-wide hot-rolled coil (HRC) could be bought for slitting is "ludicrous", according to the International Steel Trade Association (ISTA). In a submission to the TRA as part of its safeguard review, Tata said that if 2m-wide material, which it does not produce, is removed from the safeguard, it would be bought and slit, meaning it is no different from the material produced by Tata . But ISTA said 2m-wide HRC is a "significant part" of the yellow goods market and is used by companies such as JCB, Caterpillar and Liebherr for earth-moving, construction and agricultural equipment. It is also used in pipe and tube production and does not constitute a small proportion of the overall market, as suggested by Tata, ISTA said. The material must be imported as it is not manufactured in the UK and carries a premium over speed-stock widths produced by Tata. "For Tata Steel, who import volumes of this width themselves, to suggest that wider coil is ‘often imported only to be slit to narrower cuts' is ludicrous," ISTA said, arguing that there are "almost no" slitting lines in the UK that are capable of slitting 2m-wide material. The lines that do exist typically slit hot-dip galvanised (HDG) rather than HRC, Argus understands. Importers have also questioned the economic rationale of Tata's assertion that if higher-yield HDG is removed from the safeguard, importers would buy it and use it to compete with more commoditised grades produced by Tata. Higher-yield material carries a premium, and it would make no economic sense to pay it and then compete in the commodity market, trading firms told Argus . The TRA, which is expected to announce its provisional findings this week, is widely anticipated to propose caps on the quota for other countries' HDG. Importers told Argus that they were surprised by the aggressive tone of Tata's rebuttal to claims fielded by importers about material that it does not produce being excluded from the safeguard. By Colin Richardson Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more