UK HRC quota recommendation 'unworkable': Stemcor
The UK Trade Remedies Authority's recommendation to change hot-rolled coil (HRC) import quotas is "unworkable", according to steel trader Stemcor.
In a letter to the TRA, Stemcor questioned the "fairness" of a global non-country specific quota for category 1B, while keeping a "very restrictive" and "unworkable" country specific quota for 1A — the TRA has recommended splitting the current HRC quota into two, adding a larger global quota for downstream processing under 1B.
The TRA's recommendation is highly aligned with Tata Steel's requests, to the chagrin of other importers, including service centres.
"We strongly believe it is incorrect and inequitable to use historical, out-of-date statistics for the purposes of calculating a TRQ on 1A when giving no restriction whatsoever on 1B," Stemcor told the TRA. It also said it is "concerned" there is no provision in the recommendation restricting domestic producers from using 1A. This leaves the quota "open to abuse", the trader suggested. Traders and importers have said Tata Steel should not have access to 1A, given the quota of around 1.9mn t granted for 1B, which will largely be utilised by Tata Steel, although a few other companies can access it too. Under its own proposal, Tata's distribution business would still be importing HRC under 1A.
Tata said 1B should be policed to prevent it being abused by companies who do not use it for "downstream processing". In its filing to the TRA, Tata said "downstream processing" involves the transformation of HRC into cold-rolled, metallic coated sheet, organic coated sheet, tin mill, gas pipes, hollow sections, large welded tubes and other welded pipes. "TSUK notes that there is a limited number of UK companies that have the capabilities to carry out downstream processing as defined above. TSUK respectfully suggest that this factor is taken into account when assessing applications for authorisation from other UK companies," it said.
The International Steel Trade Association (ISTA) has argued that other products manufactured from imported HRC, such as cold-formed sections and corrugated steels, should also be given access to 1B. Traders also question whether one company should be able to define "downstream processing".
As with its member Stemcor, ISTA said the 1A quota should be global, in line with 1B — much of the existing quota is comprised of European material, which is costlier than material from elsewhere that will be freely accessible to Tata under a global 1B quota.
Related news posts
Mine developer signs new deal for potential refinery
Mine developer signs new deal for potential refinery
Houston, 22 August (Argus) — Canada-based mine developer Fortune Minerals entered into a new option agreement with JFSL Field Services to purchase a brownfield industrial site to build a refinery that would turn out cobalt, bismuth and copper products. Fortune can acquire the property in Alberta's Lamont County by paying C$6mn ($4.4mn) before November 2025, the company said this week. It must make monthly payments of C$100,000 that will go toward the purchase price, as a condition of the deal. Fortune has paid JFSL a little more than C$1.4mn for the site so far, and that total will be deducted from the overall purchase price as well. The two had entered into a previous option agreement that expired in July after being extended more than once. JFSL will be allowed to market the site to other prospective buyers during the option period, but Fortune will have a 90-day right of first refusal to match any offer. Additionally, JFSL has the right to continue using the property and its existing facilities for 18 months following a sale to Fortune. Fortune touts that the 77-acre property, which previously contained a steel fabrication plant, is near rail lines, reagents key to the potential refinery's function and skilled labor from the existing petrochemicals industry in the area. Fortune expects to refine concentrates from its NICO critical minerals project in the Northwest Territories into 8,780 metric tonnes/yr of cobalt sulphate, 1,700 t/yr of bismuth ingots and 300 t/yr of copper in cement precipitate. Fortune also has a collaboration in place to potentially extract cobalt and bismuth from waste streams from mining conglomerate Rio Tinto's smelter in Utah that pulls ore from its Kennecott copper mine. Development of the mine, which is anticipated to utilize open-pit and underground mining methods, has yet to begin with Fortune awaiting a final project construction decision. Fortune received federal funding from both the Canadian and US governments to complete a new feasibility study and other work that is needed before that determination can be made. That process is expected to take 20 months. Fortune also still needs to line up construction financing for the mine and refinery, which are estimated to cost C$770mn. It predicts establishing the mine would take two years, while the refinery would take 18 months. By Alex Nicoll Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
UK HRC quota recommendation reflects Tata wishes
UK HRC quota recommendation reflects Tata wishes
London, 22 August (Argus) — The UK Trade Remedies Authority (TRA) has taken on the vast majority of Tata Steel UK's suggestions in its recommendation to change import quotas for hot-rolled coil (HRC). The company requested the HRC quota be split into 1A and 1B, the latter to be used for "downstream processing". The TRA last month proposed splitting the quota along these lines. Tata said quota 1A volumes should be unchanged from current volumes, a recommendation taken on by the TRA. Tata also proposed a licensing regime be imposed on 1B, to ensure material imported into that quota is destined for "downstream processing". The 1B quota should be increased, with the 'other countries' quota rising to 165,000 t/quarter, from 22,000-23,000 t/quarter at present, Tata requested. Quota 1B should be about 1.7mn t, the company suggested, while the TRA recommended closer to 1.9mn t. In a submission to the TRA, Tata said it would import about 750,000 t/yr from the EU, 50,000 t/yr from Turkey and 750,000 t/yr from 'other countries'. Most EU material will come from Tata Steel Netherlands in IJmuiden, while the 'other countries' material would predominantly come from its parent company in India. Tata suggested the country-specific split be removed for 1B, with the creation of a global quota, which the TRA also took on. It said "downstream processing" involves the transformation of HRC into either cold-rolled coil, metallic coated sheet, organic coated sheet, tin mill products, gas pipes, hollow sections or large welded tubes and other welded pipes. "TSUK notes that there is a limited number of UK companies that have the capabilities to carry out downstream processing," it said in its filing. Top Tubes and Marcegaglia could use the 1B quota, as well as Tata, according to market sources. Liberty's Tredegar plant could also theoretically use the quota, if it restarts production. Tata said decoiling, cutting and slitting do not constitute "downstream processing" and that 1B should not be used for these purposes. Sources have noted Tata offering hot-rolled sheet produced from Indian HRC into the market. Under the plan suggested by Tata, and recommended by the TRA, such volumes would need to be imported under the 1A quota. By Colin Richardson Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Sibanye scraps supply deal at Sandouville Ni refinery
Sibanye scraps supply deal at Sandouville Ni refinery
London, 22 August (Argus) — South African multi-metals mining group Sibanye-Stillwater announced yesterday that it is scrapping a key supply agreement for its Sandouville nickel refinery in France as it repurposes the plant to produce precursor cathode active material (pCAM) for the European battery market. The termination will be completed on or before 31 December, the group said. Sibanye-Stillwater expects to incur costs of $37mn from the termination, with refining from inventory and sales expected to continue until the first quarter of 2025. The refinery, acquired from Eramet in 2022, will shift from producing nickel sulphate to producing pCAM after a scoping study yielded positive results. A final decision on pCAM production depends on a feasibility study now in progress. The pivot, called the GalliCam project, aims to use mixed hydroxide precipitate (MHP) instead of the nickel matte now in use. Sibanye intends to use MHP in a chloride medium, which it said would lead to fewer production steps, lower energy consumption, reduced carbon emissions, and fewer waste products. It filed a patent application for this chloride-MHP process in July. A small-scale pCAM precipitation pilot is under way at Sandouville, the group said, with testing due to begin from the end of the third quarter. By Raghav Jain Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Taiwan’s imported scrap prices hit 21-month low
Taiwan’s imported scrap prices hit 21-month low
Singapore, 22 August (Argus) — Taiwan's imported containerised scrap prices fell to a 21-month low on 21 August, driven by sluggish domestic steel demand and a surge in cheaper billet offers from China. The daily containerised HMS 1/2 80:20 cfr Taiwan imported scrap price fell by 4pc on the day to $325/t on 21 August. The price, which has been declining steadily since the second quarter of 2024, was down by 5.8pc from $345/t on 1 August, Argus data show. The price was last lower in November 2022 at $323/t, the data show. Taiwan's imported scrap market has been under pressure since the start of April owing to a seasonal slowdown, with steel mills entering the energy conservation period, which typically lasts from May through September or October, depending on local authority regulations. During this period, electricity prices are relatively raised, with industrial users facing hikes of up to 15-25pc, depending on their consumption levels. To manage the rising costs, many steel mills reduce their shift work, cut production during peak energy demand, or shift operations to off-peak hours, leading to a drop in steel output. Trade sources estimate that the lower output could be in the range of 10-30pc island-wide. But prices failed to rise despite these operational adjustments, as steel demand was affected by adverse weather conditions disrupting construction activities, particularly in July. Market sources told Argus that prominent steelmakers have sought to lower local rebar prices to entice buyers' interest, but downstream steel buyers remain passive and convinced of even lower prices in the near term. The drop in scrap prices was also exacerbated by an influx of cheap billet offers from China, as well as other regions like Russia, South Korea, Indonesia, and Japan. This weighed heavily on scrap procurement efforts, benefitting steel re-rollers on the island. Market sources told Argus that the price of vanadium-added billets, which stood at approximately $515-525/t over May-June, fell to around $475-485/t by mid-August. They added that factoring in a $180-200/t operating cost to manufacture billet from scrap, scrap buyers and mills estimate scrap imports should be below $300/t to remain competitive. But some steel mills remain cautiously optimistic despite such challenges and pointed to some supportive factors that prevented scrap prices from hitting rock bottom. "The global economy is steadily recovering … Taiwan's car sales are steady, and the demand for factories, offices, and residential construction is rising, leading to an increase in the demand for steel related to cars, home appliances, and constructions," Taiwan's largest state-owned steel manufacturer noted in a preliminary report released in late July. Scrap suppliers to Taiwan also maintain a positive outlook, citing sustained demand for housing despite the government's cooling measures, such as lowering the loan-to-value ratio for second-home purchases from 70pc to 60pc. A scrap buyer said that interest rates for housing have stayed relatively low, making financing for real estate more accessible. But there are concerns that potential rate hikes could slow the market, especially for buyers heavily reliant on mortgages. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
![](/_next/image?url=%2F-%2Fmedia%2Fproject%2Fargusmedia%2Fmainsite%2Fimages%2F14-generic-hero-banners%2Fherobanner_1600x530_generic-c.jpg%3Fh%3D530%26iar%3D0%26w%3D1600%26rev%3D-1%26hash%3DFC2BEDE406483FEF5FDB9549159BAC11&w=3840&q=75)
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more