Scottish court rules Rosebank, Jackdaw consent unlawful

: Crude oil, Emissions, Natural gas
25/01/30

Scotland's supreme civil court has ruled that approval for the UK's North Sea Rosebank and Jackdaw oil and gas fields was unlawful, and has quashed consent for their development.

The consent granted for the fields was unlawful because it did not take into account the scope 3 emissions — those that would be caused by burning the fields' oil and gas — the Scottish Court of Sessions ruled today. It ruled that the UK government can take a new decision on the fields, "this time taking into account downstream emissions."

Norwegian state-controlled Equinor has an 80pc stake in Rosebank and London-listed Ithaca holds the remaining 20pc. Shell is developing Jackdaw. The companies would have to submit new environmental impact assessments to the UK government for approval, taking into account scope 3 emissions. Scope 3 emissions typically make up between 85pc and 95pc of an oil and gas company's total emissions.

Environmental groups Greenpeace and Uplift first separately applied for a judicial review of the government's decision on Rosebank in December 2023, although the cases were heard together. Greenpeace in July 2022 separately filed a legal challenge against the permitting of the Jackdaw field.

All parties to the case agreed that the approvals had been unlawful, but the court heard differing opinions on how to resolve this. A judicial review in the UK is a challenge to the way a decision has been made by a public body, focusing on the procedures followed rather than the conclusion reached.

The developers may continue with Rosebank and Jackdaw, but cannot extract any oil or gas from the fields, today's ruling stated.

Equinor welcomed the ruling, saying it allows it to "continue with progressing the Rosebank project while we await new consents". The company said it would "work closely" with the UK government and submit a "downstream end-user combustion emissions… assessment in full compliance with the government's new environmental guidance" when it is ready.

"Today's ruling rightly allows work to progress on this nationally important energy project while new consents are sought," Shell said in reference to Jackdaw.

Judge Lord Ericht said today that "the private interest of members of the public in climate change outweigh the private interest of the developers".

Environmental campaigners have had success in courts lately, largely underpinned by a landmark judgment made by the UK Supreme Court in June 2024. The court ruled that Surrey County Council's decision to permit an oil development was "unlawful because the end use atmospheric emissions from burning the extracted oil were not assessed as part of the environmental impact assessment".

The UK's Labour government, which took power just days after that ruling, said the outcome meant "end use emissions from the burning of extracted hydrocarbons need to be assessed".

The government said in August that it would not challenge judicial reviews brought against development consent granted to Jackdaw and Rosebank. The hearing took place in mid-November. The UK government is expecting to introduce new environmental guidance for oil and gas firms in the spring. It has halted all assessments of environmental statements related to oil and gas extraction and storage activities until this is in place.

The then-Conservative UK government greenlit Rosebank in September 2023 and Jackdaw in June 2022.

By Georgia Gratton

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

25/03/05

Indonesia plans to build new 500,000 b/d oil refinery

Singapore, 5 March (Argus) — Indonesia plans to build an oil refinery with a planned capacity of approximately 500,000 b/d, as part of the country's push to develop its downstream sectors to ensure energy security. The refinery will be able to process domestic and imported crude oil, and will produce up to about 532,000 b/d of various oil products, according to the ministry of energy and mineral resources (ESDM). The construction of the refinery will require investments of up to $12.5bn, and it will help to reduce Indonesia's dependence on imports, said the ESDM. No details on timeline or location were provided. It is unclear how the new refinery fits with Indonesia's existing downstream expansion plans, many of which have stalled. The country has not built a new refinery since 1994, leaving it reliant on imports to meet demand for oil products, notably gasoline. Several new projects have been touted in recent years, including a joint venture between state-owned Pertamina and Russian firm Rosneft for a 300,000 b/d refinery and petrochemical plant at Tuban in east Java, but have yet to reach a final investment decision. The country's president Prabowo Subianto has set a target for reviving Indonesia's oil output to 900,000-1mn b/d by 2028-29. "We still have a lot of oil," said energy minister Bahlil Lahadalia last month, encouraging the use of enhanced oil recovery and urging exploration wells to be upgraded to production wells. The country's oil production currently stands at around 600,000 b/d , with state-owned refiner Pertamina accounting for 400,000 b/d of this, while the country's consumption amounts to more than 1.5mn b/d. Developing DME Another downstream initiative that the ESDM is planning is the acceleration of the development of dimethyl ether (DME) through coal gasification, to use it as a substitute for LPG and reduce imports. The development of the DME industry will "no longer depend on foreign investors," said Bahlil, adding that it will instead rely on domestic resources and capital, "which will be implemented through government policies." Indonesia already has the raw materials as well as the offtakers, while the technology, money and capital expenditure can all come from the government and domestic private sector, said Bahlil, so Indonesia does not have to be "dependent on other parties." Indonesia has agreed to provide $40bn worth of funding to 21 first-phase downstream projects. By Prethika Nair Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Trump aide signals possible retreat on tariffs

25/03/04

Trump aide signals possible retreat on tariffs

Washington, 4 March (Argus) — President Donald Trump's top trade adviser on Tuesday signaled a possible hasty retreat on Canada and Mexico tariffs that roiled financial and energy markets and drew threats of retaliation from the US' neighbors. The US on Tuesday imposed a 10pc tax on Canadian energy imports, a 25pc tariff on non-energy imports from Canada and a 25pc tariff on all imports from Mexico. The moves drew strong condemnation from the other governments and industry groups throughout North America. The US administration has been in talks with the governments of Canada and Mexico all day and Trump "is going to work something out with them," US commerce secretary Howard Lutnick said in a televised interview late afternoon on Tuesday. "It's not going to be a pause, none of that pause stuff, but I think he's going to figure out, you do more, and I'll meet you in the middle some way and we're going to probably be announcing that tomorrow." Lutnick suggested that Trump could possibly "give relief" to products covered by the US-Mexico-Canada (USMCA) free trade agreement negotiated in his first term. "If you haven't lived under those rules, well then you got to pay the tariff," Lutnick said. Nearly all trade between the three countries is covered by the USMCA, so a return to the terms of that agreement would merely mean lifting the tariffs Trump imposed on Tuesday. Lutnick's remarks may be an attempt to mitigate the negative market reaction to Trump's tariffs. The S&P 500 index fell on Tuesday to the lowest point since Trump won the election to his second term in November. US refining and petrochemical industry group AFPM has urged the Trump administration to find a resolution quickly to prevent what would be a continent-wide trade war. Ottawa and Mexico City vowed a strong response to Trump's tariffs. "This is a very dumb thing to do," Canadian prime minister Justin Trudeau said on Tuesday. Trudeau retaliated with a 25pc tariff on $30bn of US imports, followed by another $125bn of imports in 21 days. The largest Canadian provinces, Ontario and Quebec, separately announced possible retaliatory measures in the form of taxes or curbs on electricity exports to the US. Mexican president Claudia Sheinbaum called the US' tariff on all Mexican goods unjustified but is withholding details of her government's planned counter-tariffs and other measures until Sunday. Trump, Lutnick and other US Cabinet members gave confusing signals on the level of tariffs ahead of their imposition, with Lutnick suggesting on 2 March that the rate may be lower than 25pc. The decision-making in the second Trump administration is even more centralized than during his first term, with all key decisions made by the president, who frequently chooses to overrule public remarks by his advisers and announce his intentions via his social media platform. Trump is scheduled to address a joint session of Congress on Tuesday evening. By Haik Gugarats Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Mexican peso dips, recovers on tariff hopes

25/03/04

Mexican peso dips, recovers on tariff hopes

Houston, 4 March (Argus) — The Mexican peso weakened on the US decision to go ahead with the 25pc tariff on all imports from Mexico and Canada Monday, but it recovered some losses today, suggesting the market is hopeful the tariffs may be short-lived. The Mexican peso lost 1.3pc to close at Ps20.71 to the US dollar Monday afternoon, according to data from Mexico's central bank. The declines came as US president Donald Trump late Monday reaffirmed that he intended to impose 25pc tariff on all products coming from Mexico, effective early 4 March. The peso on Tuesday continued its slide to the dollar, reaching Ps 21/$1 briefly in the intraday market before paring its losses and ending the day stronger at Ps 20.74/1$, according to Mexican bank Banco Base and Mexico's central bank data. Sentiment in the market is that the US administration will lift the tariffs sooner rather than later because of deep implications for the US economy. "The exchange rate and volatility have not skyrocketed, as the market speculates that the US government could withdraw the tariffs soon and that their imposition is mainly intended to give credibility to Donald Trump's threats," said Gabriela Siller, head of the financial analysis department at Banco Base, on her X account. The tariff will especially affect Mexican agricultural exports such as tomatoes, avocados or some vegetables, as well as the automobile industry, which heavily relies on Mexico to build cars that are sold in the US. In the energy sector, tariffs could partially disrupt Pemex's crude exports to the US, which would need to be diverted to other countries, especially to Asia, to avoid the 25pc tariff. Pemex primarily sells crude under evergreen or long-term contracts, allowing it to set prices and volumes buyers must accept. These agreements vary in duration, with some being indefinite and others requiring a minimum purchase period. The 25pc tariff imposed by Trump's administration could simply be added to Pemex's benchmark price and leave US buyers to decide whether to accept it. If they decline, Pemex could offer its crude at a discount to other buyers. Last week, Pemex management said it is prepared to change its commercial strategy in case the tariffs enter into effect. Pemex exported about 505,000 b/d of crude to the US last year, or 60pc of Mexico's crude exports in 2024, vessel tracking data show. The state owned company is likely to also be affected through its exports of high-sulphur fuel oil (HSFO) to US Gulf coast refiners, which are also optimized to convert HSFO — a low-value byproduct — into higher-value fuels like gasoline and diesel. The state-owned company exported around 130,000 b/d of HSFO to the US in 2024, down from 163,000 b/d in 2023, according to Vortexa. By Édgar Sígler Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Canada must build pipelines beyond the US: Producers

25/03/04

Canada must build pipelines beyond the US: Producers

Calgary, 4 March (Argus) — US tariffs that went into effect today underline Canada's need to build energy infrastructure that limits its dependence on its southern neighbor and improve access to other markets, Canadian oil and gas producer groups said today. "A bold and necessary action that the Canadian government should take to respond is to build retaliatory pipelines to diversify our economy to other markets beyond the United States," the Explorers and Producers Association of Canada (EPAC) said following the US' imposition of a 10pc tariff on Canadian energy. The Canadian oil and gas industry has long criticized federal energy policy for inhibiting development and scaring off investors amid concerns for getting its production to markets. This includes what it called burdensome regulations and a ban on oil tanker traffic on much of its Pacific coast. The government under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau effectively killed Enbridge's 525,000 b/d Northern Gateway pipeline project and TC Energy's 1.1mn b/d Energy East project, which would have allowed Canadian oil producers to bypass the US. Regulations need to change to allow for such project again, industry groups say. "Canada urgently needs a policy overhaul to create a streamlined and durable regulatory framework," said Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers (CAPP) president Lisa Baiton. Long-term stability for Canadian producers will come from diversifying exports into Asia and Europe. "We are at a significant moment in Canada's history — we need to seize this moment," said Baiton. Canada sends about 80pc of its 5mn b/d of crude production to the US through a combination of onshore pipelines, crude by rail and waterborne cargoes. Canada accounts for 60pc of all US crude imports, with refiners in the US midcontinent having few alternative supplies. EPAC, which represents 100 producer and associate members who produce 40pc of Canada's crude and 65pc of the country's natural gas, encouraged the Canadian government to continue to work on border security concerns that the US had raised and take a measured approach in its response. Heavy sour WCS priced at Hardisty, Alberta, was assessed at a discount of $13.80/bl to the April Nymex WTI calendar month average on 3 March, wider by about 95¢/bl compared to the session prior. Indications Tuesday show WCS has continued to fall, but not to the depths seen on the eve of the previous trade threat on 3 February — before a deal was struck to delay the tariffs by 30-days — when it sank as low as a $15.75/bl discount. This suggests traders may have already priced in the trade action ahead of the latest threat. Some degree of price support could also be coming from upcoming turnaround season in Alberta's oil sands region. By Brett Holmes Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

US tariffs could crash auto industry: Ontario

25/03/04

US tariffs could crash auto industry: Ontario

Calgary, 4 March (Argus) — The tightly-intertwined US and Canadian auto manufacturing industry could grind to a halt in as little as 10 days due to US tariffs, according to Ontario premier Doug Ford. Raw materials and partially assembled vehicle components can cross the US-Canadian border between manufacturing plants as many as eight times before becoming a finished vehicle, Ford said today. But the 25pc tariffs the US imposed on most Canadian and Mexican goods effective today will add costs and disrupt supply chains. Canada and the US could have combined efforts to make the two countries the safest and secure, Ford said, but "... unfortunately, one man, president Trump has chosen chaos instead." Ontario, Canada's largest province by population and a major vehicle manufacturing hub, may also cut nickel exports to the US, Ford said, and may put a 25pc surcharge onto electricity flows into New York, Minnesota and Michigan if the tariffs persist. Canada supplied about 46pc of US nickel from 2019-2022 according to the US Geological Survey, and nearly 36TWh of electric power to the US. Ontario is also banning US companies from government contracts, including cancelling a $100mn contract with Elon Musk's Starlink internet services. Ford also directed the Liquor Control Board of Ontario (LCBO) to remove US products from its store shelves, meaning other retailers, bars and restaurants will also be unable to restock American goods. The LCBO is the largest purchaser of alcohol in the world, according to Ford, selling nearly C$1bn in products, including 3,600 products from 35 US states. Ontario's action comes after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced Canada's retaliation of 25pc tariffs on $30bn of US imports, followed by another $125bn of imports in 21 days' time. Canadian energy exports to the US are subject to a lower 10pc tariff. Alberta premier Danielle Smith called the US tariffs "both foolish and a failure in every regard." She called on her Canadian peers to fast-track the construction of dozens of resource projects to help relieve the country's dependence on the US for sales. By Brett Holmes Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more