Viewpoint: EU biofuel plans to drive feedstock changes
Higher biofuels blending mandates under new European renewables legislation will offer a boon to biodiesel spot prices in 2021 after a year of poor margins caused by lockdown-related falls in road fuel demand.
And provisions in the Renewable Energy Directive (RED II), scheduled to come into effect in June, will drive feedstock diversification, providing additional support to waste-based and advanced biodiesel while capping the use of food and feed crop-based biofuels.
While uncertainty persists around road fuels use in the early months of 2021, and most national renewables targets in Europe are yet to be written into law, an ongoing revision of RED II will align it with more ambitious climate targets under the EU Green Deal.
RED II already sees the mandated renewable share of transport fuels rise to 14pc by 2030, from 10pc in 2020.
Any revision of RED II could spur revised biofuels sustainability criteria on top of simple increases to the current EU-wide target share for renewables in transport fuels. EU leaders have reached political agreement on net GHG reductions of 55pc by 2030, up from 40pc. This would require the EU setting a 24pc share of renewables in transport, alongside an overall renewable share of 38-40pc in gross final energy consumption, and will translate to higher mandates in EU countries in 2021.
In 2020, a 10pc renewables share of road transport fuels under RED and a 6pc greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction under the Fuel Quality Directive (FQD) should have driven significantly higher EU demand for biodiesel, only for producers to struggle with negative margins as early as the second quarter when governments across the bloc imposed movement restrictions. Globally, biofuels output contracted in 2020 for the first time in 20 years, with the IEA assessing a 13.5pc year-on-year decline in European biodiesel and HVO production to 12mn t. Under more normal circumstances, European output should increase to 14mn t in 2021, the IEA said, as demand from road fuel suppliers reacts to existing legislation.
But there are other qualifying factors away from uncertainties about the speed of road fuels uptake and the final look of legislation that will determine how higher targets translate to increased demand.
Biodiesel values in countries such as Germany will, to an extent, be pressured by upstream emission reduction (UER) projects, for which further approvals would generate alternative means of meeting mandates and prompt fuel suppliers to ask for a lower amount of biodiesel in their 2021 supply contracts.
More generally, the feedstock used to produce biofuels blended into road fuels will become more important.
In October, the European Parliament voted for EU legislation aimed at preventing imports of products linked to deforestation, including palm oil, soy, and maize. RED II already sets a 7pc limit on food and feed crop-based biofuels and the EU has agreed to a gradual phase out of biofuels with a high risk of indirect land use change (Iluc) by 2030, which in practise will take huge swathes of product from palm oil and soybean oil off the market.
Duties on imports of such biofuels from Indonesia and Argentina will compound the trend.
And recent regulatory moves by some countries suggesting the EU bloc could meet its target to phase out palm oil and soybean oil from the slate ahead of schedule. This will support EU demand for biodiesel made from rapeseed oil or from sunflower oil and encourage a greater divergence in pricing based on feedstock.
Waste oils could fill any shortfall. A 1.7pc cap is maintained for biodiesel produced from used cooking oil (UCO) and tallow categories 1 and 2 through the decade. RED II introduces sub-targets for advanced biofuels — produced from feedstocks listed in Annex IX part A — at 0.2pc in 2022, 1pc in 2025 and 3.5pc in 2030.
In the early stages of the 2021-30 period, much of this will be met by products for which there is existing capacity. Ucome prices will be supported by stronger demand and by tighter UCO availability, with the feedstock likely to be a key resource for road fuels, aviation and maritime as mandates for sustainable aviation fuel (SAF), or biojet, come into effect and discussions gain momentum on mandates for the maritime industry.
Related news posts
Australia's Qantas records higher fuel costs in 2023-24
Australia's Qantas records higher fuel costs in 2023-24
Singapore, 30 August (Argus) — Australian airline Qantas Airways recorded a higher fuel bill in the 2023-24 fiscal year to 30 June, as more flights, sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) expenses and carbon offset programmes weighed on costs. Qantas saw its fuel costs rise by 17pc from a year earlier to A$5.32bn ($3.62bn) in 2023-24, according to the company's full-year financial results released on 29 August. The airline group's passenger carrying capacity was up by 21pc on the previous year, with growth in domestic and international capaicty. This saw the group's overall fuel consumption grow to 29mn bl (79,000 b/d), or 18pc up on the previous year. Qantas expects fuel costs in the first half of 2024-25 to remain stable from a year earlier at about A$2.7bn, including hedging and gross carbon costs, with the group forecasting to consume 15.6mn bl of fuel, including SAF. Qantas forecasts domestic group capacity to rise to 104pc of pre-Covid 19 pandemic capacity in the first half of 2024-25. Its international capacity guidance, excluding Jetstar Asia, is expected to rise by about 16pc from the previous year to achieve 102pc of pre-Covid levels in the first half. The group's passenger carrying capacity, measured by available seat kilometres (ASKs), was up on a year earlier by 21pc to 141mn ASK by 2023-24, although this was still about 93pc of pre-Covid levels. Qantas has agreements to offtake SAF, renewing its agreement to buy SAF for flights out of London Heathrow and doubling the size of its corporate customer SAF programme in 2023-24. But the group saw its 2023-24 profit fall, with underlying profit before tax down by 16pc on the previous year to A$2.08bn. By Cara Wong Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
India lifts curbs on use of sugarcane juice for ethanol
India lifts curbs on use of sugarcane juice for ethanol
Mumbai, 30 August (Argus) — The Indian government is allowing sugar mills and distilleries to use sugarcane juice and sugar syrup to produce ethanol during the November 2024-October 2025 supply year. The government in December last year halted the use of sugarcane juice and sugar syrup for ethanol production in the 2023-24 supply year, as insufficient rainfall in key growing regions led to a surge in domestic sugar prices and a shortage of the sweetener. Sugar mills and distilleries can also produce ethanol from B-heavy and C-heavy molasses. The food ministry's order added that it will, in co-ordination with the oil ministry, periodically review the diversion of sugar to ethanol production in relation to the production of sugar in the country to ensure the availability of sugar for domestic consumption throughout the year. The government also allowed the Food Corporation of India to sell rice to distilleries for ethanol production during August-October but capped the limit at 2.3mn t of rice. India had suspended supplies of excess rice to distilleries for ethanol production in July 2023 because of food availability and concerns about rising prices. Distilleries will be allowed to load rice during August-October subject to allocation of ethanol to the distilleries by oil marketing companies, the government order said. Of the total ethanol used for blending in gasoline in India, around 61pc comes from B-heavy molasses, 20pc from sugar syrup, 11pc from surplus rice, 6pc from damaged food grains and maize and 2pc from C-heavy molasses. India has a set a goal to increase ethanol blending in gasoline to 20pc by 2025, as part of efforts to reduce its dependence on crude imports. Ethanol blending in gasoline was 13.3pc during November 2023-July 2024 and 15.8pc during July 2024, oil ministry data show. Oil marketing companies buy ethanol from ethanol producers like sugar mills and distilleries to blend with gasoline. By Roshni Devi Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Sweden to up biofuel mandates again after slashing them
Sweden to up biofuel mandates again after slashing them
London, 28 August (Argus) — Sweden's government announced that the country will raise its greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction obligations to 10pc for gasoline and diesel from 6pc, with changes due to come into effect on 1 July next year according to Swedish bioenergy association Svebio. The country announced in May last year that it was planning to lower GHG reduction mandates for 2024-2026 to 6pc for both diesel and gasoline, from 30.5pc for diesel and 7.8pc for gasoline in 2023. The government at the time said this was because higher GHG reduction targets in Sweden, compared with the rest of the EU, were pushing diesel prices up at the pump. The biofuels industry in Sweden welcomed the new 10pc mandate, as it will support domestic demand for its fuels. The drop in Sweden's mandates to 6pc had a significant effect on domestic biofuels usage and wider biofuel prices in Europe, particularly hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO). Because fatty acid methyl ester (Fame) biodiesel has a 7pc physical blend wall into diesel under the EU Fuel Quality Directive, Sweden relied on drop-in HVO to meet its high diesel mandates. As a result of the 2024 mandate cuts, HVO deliveries were down by 95pc on the year in June and total biofuels deliveries were down by 79pc in the same period, according to data from government data provider Statistics Sweden . Lower mandates in Sweden cut domestic HVO demand, redirecting supplies to the wider European market, pushing values down as a result. Prices for HVO Class II fob ARA range, made from used cooking oil, were down by $715.42/t year on year, or 31.5pc, on 27 August. Tomas Ekbom, programme director at Svebio, told Argus that Sweden's government understood it could not rely mainly on the electrification of the transport sector to meet targets and that biofuels had a larger role to play. He added that the government likely also considered that it would be too costly to pay for credits if, in the end, EU targets were missed. Sweden's government estimates that the country will meet its Effort Sharing Regulation commitments for 2030 — a binding emissions reduction target for domestic transport (excluding aviation), buildings, agriculture, small industry and waste of 50pc compared with 2005 levels — by implementing this new 10pc reduction obligation, as well as a new climate action plan. But the parliament previously abolished GHG reduction levels for 2027-2030, taking a wait and see approach. And ministers did not include any plans to scale up the mandated levels from 10pc. The re-cast Renewable Energy Directive requires a 14.5pc GHG reduction target, or 29pc share of renewables by energy content, for transport fuels by 2030. Sweden's new obligation will allow fuel suppliers to credit electricity from public charging stations towards meeting their emissions reduction obligations, but how this will work in practice remains unclear. Last year, battery electric vehicles were 5.75pc of Sweden's total passenger car fleet and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles were 5.37pc of the fleet, based on data from the EU's alternative fuels observatory. Sweden will also include a proposal in its 2025 budget to reduce fuel taxes to reduce impact on fuel prices at the pump. The gasoline tax will be reduced by 0.75 krona/litre ($0.07) next year while the diesel tax will be increased by 0.11 krona/litre ($0.01) — the EU minimum. By Simone Burgin Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
IMO 2040 CO2 goals unmet under base case: ABS
IMO 2040 CO2 goals unmet under base case: ABS
New York, 27 August (Argus) — The shipping industry will not meet the International Maritime Organization (IMO) goal for reducing CO2 emissions by 2040 without hastening the expected pace of vessel replacements, a study by vessel classification organization American Bureau of Shipping (ABS) concluded. IMO calls for the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions by at least 20pc by 2030, by at least 70pc by 2040, and to net zero by 2050, compared with 2008 base levels. Under a base case scenario, a 20pc reduction in CO2-equivalent emissions by 2030 is achievable on a full lifecycle basis, but a 70pc percent reduction by 2040 is not, ABS said. Under the best case scenario examined by ABS, achieving IMO's 70pc target would require a significantly faster renewal of the vessel fleet to replace oil-fueled vessels or a higher degree of vessel retrofitting. The three biggest categories of bunker consuming vessels — tankers, dry bulk carriers and container ships — are expected to follow a similar trajectory for marine fuel demand under the base case scenario, with conventional marine fuel accounting for more than 60pc of demand through 2035, ABS said. Conventional fuel demand would decline to 38-44pc of marine fuel demand in the first half of the 2040s in the base case, ABS predicted. Methanol in that period would grow to about 35pc of marine fuel demand for tankers and container ships and about 22pc for dry bulk carriers. Ammonia and hydrogen demand would grow to about 13pc of tankers' marine fuel demand, 18pc of dry bulk carriers' demand and about 14pc of container ships' demand. LNG across the three vessel categories is expected at 4-6pc of bunkering demand in the early 2040s, with biodiesel at 5-9pc of demand. By Stefka Wechsler Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
![Generic Hero Banner](/_next/image?url=%2F-%2Fmedia%2Fproject%2Fargusmedia%2Fmainsite%2Fimages%2F14-generic-hero-banners%2Fherobanner_1600x530_generic-c.jpg%3Fh%3D530%26iar%3D0%26w%3D1600%26rev%3D8ec86dce0f724687bd325a9a917cffae%26hash%3D9FD39B08C9D84A160C91A3649C40A186&w=3840&q=75)
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more