Calif expands checks on renewable fuel projects
Northern California refiners converting traditional fuel processing units to make renewables will still need to follow the same rules as with older processes, as regulators take a closer look at lower-carbon fuel production.
The Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD) plans to update its rules to make renewable fuel facilities subject to the same fees, emissions restrictions and performance standards currently applicable to petroleum refineries, it said in a request for comment published 21 September.
The changes come amid increasing attention to the environmental and community impacts associated with lower carbon fuel projects underway in the region. BAAQMD recently opened a probe into whether Phillips 66 violated permitting procedures involved in the ongoing conversion of its Rodeo facility in the120,000 b/d San Francisco refining complex. The regulator is performing inspections, information-gathering, and engineering reviews at the Rodeo site after environmental advocacy group the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) asked it to look into whether Phillips 66 failed to apply for a permit for a hydrotreater conversion earlier this year.
Since Phillips 66 already has an active permitting process underway for a full conversion of the Rodeo facility expected in 2024, a potential breach of protocol of the kind alleged by NRDC would "transcend from odd to shocking," Ann Alexander, an attorney at the NRDC, told Argus.
The group already raised concerns in a letter sent to county regulator earlier this year about more than 11 potential consequences of the Rodeo conversion and expanded biofuel production, ranging from the deforestation impacts of farming for soybean feedstocks to emissions caused by the use of hydrogen units in renewable fuel refining.
Phillips 66 told Argus that it followed "all carefully reviewed applicable regulations and obtained all required approvals to produce renewable diesel from an existing hydrotreater unit as part of a standalone flexibility project." The company said that the Rodeo Renewed project does not require increased hydrogen generation, as the NRDC has suggested.
Tough market rules stay tough
But the regulatory probe and the forthcoming amendments to emissions standards may nonetheless speak to some of the challenges inherent in setting timelines for ambitious renewable fuel conversions in California.
Besides regional oversight enforced by groups like the BAAQMD, conversions are subject to additional permitting from programs overseen by the California Environmental Protection Agency, extensive environmental analyses, input solicitations from homes and businesses in fenceline communities, and review by the state's Division of Occupational Safety and Health, among other processes.
"Since this is new ground, it needs close scrutiny," Alexander said. "Hearing the proposed timelines coming from the oil companies on these projects, it's hard to see how they would work."
Further expansion of regulatory programs, as envisaged by BAAQMD, may give refiners cause for concern as they eye conversions intended to onramp them into burgeoning markets for renewable fuels and credits traded as part of California's Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) program. Alongside Phillips 66's effort at Rodeo, Marathon Petroleum is working to convert its 166,000 b/d Martinez refinery in the Bay area toward renewable diesel production. And more conversions figure to be forthcoming as demand for traditional fuels recedes in coming decades.
California-based Chevron, for example, which operates the 269,000 b/d El Segundo refinery near Los Angeles and the 250,000 b/d Richmond refinery in the Bay area, recently announced plans to spend $3bn on renewable diesel and sustainable aviation fuel production by 2028 as part of a $10bn energy transition spending program.
While the company has not announced conversion plans for its petroleum refineries in California, it has prioritized sustainable investments in its "home market," which couples close regulation with a lucrative carbon credit trading system. Chevron began processing of 2,000 b/d of renewable feedstocks for sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) production at El Segundo this month and has set a goal to convert a diesel hydrotreater at the facility for renewable diesel production by 2022.
BAAQMD has requested public comments on the draft amendments to be submitted by 11 October, ahead of a board of directors special meeting on 20 October.
Related news posts
Italy’s NECP eyes 11pc of power demand from nuclear
Italy’s NECP eyes 11pc of power demand from nuclear
London, 2 July (Argus) — Italy aims to generate at least 11pc of its power demand from nuclear energy by 2050 and could double that amount if necessary as part of efforts to meet its climate goals. In its new national energy and climate plan (NECP) sent to Brussels yesterday, Rome said its "conservative" scenario envisioned installing 8GW of nuclear power capacity using mainly small modular reactors but also fusion plants. Italy could build as much as 16GW of nuclear capacity depending on developments across the energy system, according to the document. The ‘with-nuclear' option would provide savings of around €17bn ($18.3bn) compared with not using it. It would also mean less gas consumption tied to carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology. Italy banned nuclear power in a referendum in 1987 after the Chernobyl disaster, but the current right-wing government of Giorgia Meloni has voiced its support for the technology. Last year it set up the national platform for sustainable nuclear power to map out a timeline for a possible return to nuclear power. In confirmation of targets set last year , Rome said it aimed to install a total of 131GW of renewable energy capacity by 2030, compared to 58GW in 2021, with a view to meeting 63pc of power demand and 39.4pc of total energy consumption. Most of the new capacity will be solar photovoltaic (PV), with 79GW expected to be installed driven by new subsidies and easier permitting. Wind capacity is expected to contribute 28GW, with offshore wind providing just 2.1GW. The plan envisages the development of contracts for difference (CfDs) through auctions for larger plants, as well as a framework to boost power-purchasing agreements (PPAs). Italy's NECP also maps out the development of electricity grids and cross-border interconnections. "The long-term risk is that the tight renewables penetration targets and the CfD mechanism established by the EU to deliver incentives could lead to a negative impact on spot prices, currently driven in Italy by the price of natural gas and carbon allowances," Italian broker Equita said. The current final revision of Italy's NECP comes after a cross-sector and public consultation. It was submitted to the European Commission for approval on 1 July, a day after the deadline required by EU law. By Steven Jewkes and Timothy Santonastaso Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Countries draft trade deal to address climate change
Countries draft trade deal to address climate change
London, 2 July (Argus) — Trade ministers for Costa Rica, Iceland, New Zealand and Switzerland have finished negotiations on a trade deal focused on tackling climate change, pollution and loss of biodiversity. The deal — the agreement on climate change, trade and sustainability (ACCTS) — will include an "ambitious" list of environmental goods, with a definition and criteria for updates, the ministers said. The agreement will eliminate tariffs on more than 300 goods, including solar panels, wind turbines, electric vehicles and wood products. It will also outline conservation and sustainability commitments for the production of such items. The agreement will also "contribute a meaningful definition of fossil fuel subsidies to international efforts", the ministers said. On these, there will be "clear prohibitions and a limited set of exceptions to safeguard fundamental policy goals", the ministerial statement added. Pledges to phase out fossil fuel subsidies by various countries, including the G7 and G20 groups, are long-standing. But subsidies for fossil fuels remain widespread and totalled $7 trillion in 2022, according to the IMF. The legal review of the text must be completed before it is signed, ratified and implemented, the ministers said. Their ambition is for the ACCTS to be "a pathfinder agreement that will drive momentum" at the World Trade Organisation, they added. Norway participated in all 15 rounds of negotiations and hailed the "great progress" made. But the country needs more time to assess the agreement, Norwegian foreign minister Espen Barth Eide said. By Georgia Gratton Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Reformed Australia safeguard scheme faces uncertainties
Reformed Australia safeguard scheme faces uncertainties
Canberra, 2 July (Argus) — Australia's reformed safeguard mechanism triggered more decarbonisation efforts in its first year, but key uncertainties need to be clarified to unlock bigger investments, delegates heard at a Carbon Market Institute (CMI) symposium in Canberra on 1 July. Settings are clear until 2030 but uncertainties over a few major factors beyond that year have been causing hesitation and blocking investments, market experts said. The mechanism became a 'declining baseline-and-credit' emissions trading scheme (ETS) from 1 July 2023 after a reform by the Labor government , which set a emission reduction target of 43pc by 2030 from 2005 levels after taking office in mid-2022. Figures from the first year under the reformed scheme, between 1 July 2023-30 June 2024, will only be known after facilities surrender their units ahead of the 1 April 2025 compliance deadline . The Australian government still needs to define the design of the cost containment reserve , under which safeguard facilities may access Australian Carbon Credit Units (ACCUs) held by the Clean Energy Regulator (CER) at a fixed price that started at A$75 ($50) in the 2023-24 fiscal year to 30 June and will be increased with inflation plus 2pc/yr. "On a fundamental basis, [the reserve] shouldn't be required to be triggered before 2027-28, but we do need price signals to unlock a new wave of investments and capitalise a whole new suite of projects that are not already banked," climate solutions and brokerage firm Core Markets' chief executive Chris Halliwell told delegates on 1 July. Uncertainty over baseline decline rate Under the reformed mechanism, facilities that emit more than 100,000t of CO2 equivalent (CO2e) in a fiscal year face declining baselines and need to surrender ACCUs or upcoming safeguard mechanism credits if their onsite abatement activities were not enough to keep their emissions below thresholds. The rate of decline was set at 4.9pc/yr from 2021-22 to 2029-30 and will be set in five-year blocks from 2030-31 onwards, in line with future updates to Australia's Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) under the Paris Agreement, with later rates to be defined by 1 July 2027. The government disclosed an indicative decline rate of 3.285pc/yr in the safeguard rules from 2030-31 to 2049-50, said Australian carbon advisory company RepuTex's head of research Bret Harper. But that would mean "a less ambitious" rate than the existing one, even as Australia might set a much more ambitious emissions reduction target by 2035, Harper added. Uncertainty for trade-exposed facilities There is significant uncertainty and risk for so-called trade-exposed baseline adjusted facilities, which are typically smaller industrial participants that face a high risk of carbon leakage. Such facilities can apply for a discounted decline rate as low as 1pc/yr, but several of them do not know whether they will qualify, climate risk and energy transition consultancy Energetics' head of emissions quant David Kazmirowicz told delegates. He mentioned the example of one client, Victoria-based glass manufacturer Oceania Glass, which is the sole producer of float glass products in Australia. "All their competition comes from overseas and they are, putting it mildly, up in arms that there was a domestic policy mechanism triggered without an equivalent for overseas imports," he said. "This facility is looking at existential impacts where, I think, big players in the resource industry are potentially not." Australia has been looking at the possibility of introducing a carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM), with a second consultation paper to be published in the "near future", said Australian National University professor Frank Jotzo, who has been leading the carbon leakage review. The first round of consultation showed strong "support for the principle of a CBAM", he added. By Juan Weik Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Australia’s safeguard credit selling interest unclear
Australia’s safeguard credit selling interest unclear
Canberra, 2 July (Argus) — There is buying interest in Australia's upcoming safeguard mechanism credits (SMCs), but selling interest has been scant so far, delegates heard at a Carbon Market Institute (CMI) symposium in Canberra on 1 July. The Clean Energy Regulator (CER) will start to issue SMCs from 2025 onwards to safeguard facilities that report scope 1 greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions below their annual baselines, effectively introducing emissions allowances into the Australian carbon market. Each SMC will represent 1t of CO2 equivalent (CO2e) below the baseline of a facility, which will have the option to either hold it for future use or sell it to facilities that exceeded their thresholds. Facilities that overstep their baselines are required to buy and surrender one Australian Carbon Credit Unit (ACCU) or SMC for each excess 1t of CO2e, and will be penalised if they fail to do so. This means companies in need of units will have interest in buying SMCs, but there are doubts about selling interest, market experts said. "We hear lots of our clients aiming to go out there and buy SMCs, but very few who are going to generate them are willing to sell because they see them as a mechanism for hedging future risk," said sustainability advisory firm Anthesis' climate resilience and decarbonisation lead, Thomas Hodgson. Facilities will be allowed to hold an unlimited number of SMCs until 2030. They will be able to use the credits for safeguard compliance at any point up to that year — irrespective of when the SMCs are issued — but the Australian government has pledged to review post-2030 banking arrangements in the scheduled review of the safeguard mechanism in 2026-27, according to CMI. Climate risk and energy transition consultancy Energetics has been working with 10 clients that account for a combined 15mn t/yr of CO2e in Australia. But most of them were not currently looking at the opportunity of receiving SMCs in the near future, Energetics' head of emissions quant David Kazmirowicz said, highlighting a potentially limited credit issuance. Actual SMC transactions are only expected to pick up once the CER issues the first units in early 2025, when there will be more visibility on issuance volumes as well as selling and buying appetite. These below-baseline credits will be "a certificate to watch", said the regulator's principal economist Georgina Prasad. There will be advantages in banking SMCs for future liability, but several facilities likely to receive the credits are not expected to have any liability in the next several years, according to Australian carbon advisory company RepuTex's head of research Bret Harper. "So this is probably a prime opportunity for them to test the market and see if they can monetise those credits," he pointed out. SMCs are expected to trade at a discount to ACCUs as their use will be restricted to safeguard facilities, excluding them from voluntary and non-federal compliance demand, according to market participants. Safeguard volumes accounted for 75pc of all the nearly 1.2mn ACCU cancellations in the first quarter of 2024, according to latest CER data. Generic ACCU prices have ranged between A$33.75-34.60 ($22.50-23.05) in recent weeks. By Juan Weik Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more