President Joe Biden's repeated claim that oil companies are sitting on 9,000 federal drilling permits overstated the backlog of unused permits, according to new data.
Oil and gas operators only had 6,650 approved but unused drilling permits on federal and tribal lands as of 31 January, according to the US Bureau of Land Management's (BLM) latest data. The government's tally of unused drilling permits was overstated, an error caused by a "reporting discrepancy" arising from a transition to a new database in 2020, BLM said today.
The 9,000 tally became a core talking point for the White House last summer, as administration officials attempted to blame the oil industry for a spike in gasoline and oil prices at the time. Biden argued the industry was intentionally holding back on new production as a way to inflate their own profits.
"They have 9,000 permits to drill," Biden said last June. "Why aren't they drilling? Because they make more money not producing more oil."
The White House said its criticisms of the oil and gas sector are still valid, even if there are fewer unused federal drilling permits than it stated before.
"The record profits oil companies made in 2022 and the thousands of approved but unused drilling permits they are sitting on shows that there is nothing getting in the way of increasing oil production except Big Oil's own decision to funnel their profits into the pockets of shareholders and executives," an administration official said.
The permitting data discrepancy could provide Republican critics a new line of attack against the Biden administration's energy policies. Republicans on the US House of Representatives' Natural Resources Committee plan to vote on a bill tomorrow that would significantly expedite oil and gas permitting on federal land.
The vast majority of BLM's unused drilling permits are in a handful of western states. Oil and gas companies held 3,395 unused drilling permits, called APDs, to drill in New Mexico and 2,026 in Wyoming as of 31 January, accounting for 81pc of the total. The permit numbers may change because of "ongoing data cleanup efforts," the latest permitting report said.
BLM did not respond to questions about when it first identified the discrepancy in the permitting data. The agency last year was publishing monthly reports on the number of APDs through 30 September but then stopped issuing new reports. The latest monthly permitting data cover only December and January.
Oil industry officials say they are justified in maintaining a stockpile of thousands of unused drilling permits on federal land. The risks of litigation and the uncertainty of when they will receive all required permits means oil producers need to build up a large backlog of permits before they make a commitment to begin to drill, they say.
"You can't afford to start your project, drill one or two wells, and then have to wait for two more permits," Western Energy Alliance president Kathleen Sgamma said at a congressional hearing on 8 February. "In order to stay ahead of your rig, you need an inventory of permits."