Washington, 21 May (Argus) — Powder River basin (PRB) coal fell to its lowest first-quarter production levels since 2003, as many annual contracts expired without renewals so buyers could burn down high inventories.
PRB coal production shrank by 9.4pc in the first quarter, down to 99.13mn short tons (90mn metric tonnes) from 109.4mn st in the year-ago quarter, according to Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) data.
Production was lower in the second quarter of 2012 at 91mn st, but the second quarter is traditionally the slowest for PRB. The last time first-quarter production was lower was in 2003, according to Energy Ventures Analysis (EVA).
Spot prices for PRB coal crashed in the spring of 2012 after a mild winter increased utility stockpiles and competing natural gas prices at $2/mmBtu reduced demand for coal. From 2011 to 2012, PRB production fell by 9.3pc. The basin produced 419mn st of coal, compared with 462.2mn st in 2011.
With utility stockpiles still high – at about 80mn st in April, according to EVA – producers hope a hot summer burn will bring them down to 65mn st by September, bringing buyers back into the market and increasing production.
Though producers have not idled any mines in the PRB, they have cut production of lower-heat coal and idled equipment and mine sections with higher strip ratios.
Peabody Energy's North Antelope Rochelle mine held the lead in production, mining 26.38mn st to surpass Arch Coal's Black Thunder mine in the quarter, though that number is still down by 3.6pc from the first quarter of 2012. Black Thunder produced 24.3mn st in the first quarter this year, slightly higher than the first quarter of last year when it produced 24.2mn st.
North Antelope Rochelle produced the most tonnage in the PRB for all four quarters of 2012 – turning out 107.64mn st for the year, 14mn st more than Black Thunder.
Last spring, Arch idled two draglines representing about 15mn st of capacity each, saying in its first-quarter earnings call that it did not plan to redeploy the equipment until the market makes “a much stronger and sustained recovery.” Restarting either of the draglines for incremental tonnage would be inefficient, making it harder for the company to make a smaller supply response as quickly as some of its competitors in the basin might.
Cloud Peak Energy has not idled any major pieces of equipment and believes it could easily and efficiently reach full capacity should the market rebound, according to comments the company made at the Brean Capital Global Resources & Infrastructure Conference.
Cloud Peak's Cordero and Antelope mines produced 9.2mn st and 8.1mn st in the quarter, respectively. Cordero's production represented a 7.8pc decrease from last year's first-quarter total of 10mn st and 10.2mn st in 2011. Antelope production decreased 7.7pc from 8.7mn st in first-quarter 2011 to its lowest level since the first quarter of 2009.
Alpha Natural Resources' Eagle Butte mine production dropped by 14pc to 4.9mn st, and its Belle Ayr mine fell by 17pc to 5.1mn st.
Send comments to feedback@argusmedia.com
js/ee 3.0
If you would like to review other ArgusMedia.com content options, request more information about Argus' energy news, data and analysis services.
Copyright © 2013 Argus Media Ltd - www.ArgusMedia.com - All rights reserved.