German biofuel ticket market to get a boost
Germany's biofuel quota ticket prices are poised to receive a boost from 2018 onward, as market participants increasingly see benefits in holding onto tickets in anticipation of higher biofuels blending costs.
Germany's so-called tickets are tradeable greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction certificates that road fuel blenders receive for each tonne of CO2 equivalent (CO2e) saved when incorporating more biofuels into gasoline and diesel than needed to meet GHG savings targets. Suppliers of biogas, LPG and CNG selling into the retail fuel market also create tickets as their lower-carbon fossil fuels displace higher-emitting road fuels.
Road-fuels blenders that have missed their mandated GHG saving target can buy tickets to meet obligations and avoid a €470/t CO2e fine imposed by the German government. Compliance for each year is due on 15 April the following year, to give participants time to calculate their mass balance and trade tickets.
Market participants anticipate that a risk premium will likely start to be factored into ticket prices, as biofuel blending quotas rise to 2020 under European renewables transport targets. While domestic tickets for 2018 mandate compliance have so far been pricing well below 2017 values, premiums over Europe's mainstay biofuels already suggest ticket demand is outstripping supply.
Argus began assessing the ticket price in May this year. Tickets last traded at €160/t CO2e in the week to 10 August and the ticket price was assessed at €155-163/t CO2e that week on the basis of Argus' market survey.
But blending costs based on spot prices for the Fame 0 are currently around €108/t CO2e, while those for used cooking oil methyl ester (Ucome) biodiesel at €105/t CO2e and fuel ethanol at €24/t CO2e, a participant said.
This puts the Argus ticket price at a premium of around €52/t CO2e to the more expensive Fame 0 blend cost.
The shift to winter biofuels plays a role in the higher premium. Colder temperatures limit the amount of Ucome that can be blended into the road fuels, forcing suppliers to incorporate non-waste biofuels with typically lower GHG savings credentials that often result in a higher biofuels blending cost.
But this time around markets expect the ticket premium to biofuels blending cost to stay, leading to potentially higher ticket prices in early 2019 after mass balancing for this year's compliance draws out more buyers to meet shorts in biofuels blending. The rate of the government fine will eventually set a cap on ticket prices.
Current weaker ticket values have been attributed to narrowing differentials between oil product and biofuels prices, as values in the oil markets strengthened and associated fossil fuel costs through the supply chain increased.
"As long as the more economical option of CO2 reduction is physical blending, there is no need to search elsewhere for a transfer of reduction obligation," Total Germany new energies Advisor Ralf Stoeckel told Argus.
The prices of physical biofuels in Europe in recent months have generally been low enough for suppliers to focus on blending maximum volumes into the transport fuel mix.
Another potential driver of gains for both tickets and biodiesel prices is the anticipated low crude rapeseed oil (RSO) yields this year, which will likely lead to higher prices of biodiesel blend stock rapeseed methyl ester (RME).
RME accounts for the vast majority of European vegetable oil-based biodiesel production capacity. But the grade is now trading at an unseasonable spread over Fame 0, emphasising any upside risk of higher biofuels blending costs into 2019 and opposing weaker price indications from backwardated prices on the forward curve.
European RME has typically assumed an 80-90pc share of Fame with a -10°C cold filter plugging point (CFPP) (Fame -10) — a staple of German biofuels consumption in winter — with the remaining 10-20pc consisting of alternate biodiesel grades.
An increase in RME demand in the colder months will add to the shortages on the supply side that have already supported the grade, in turn driving further demand for German tickets into the next year.
Related news posts
Germany's Landwärme declares insolvency
Germany's Landwärme declares insolvency
London, 13 August (Argus) — German biomethane supplier Landwärme has today declared insolvency under the country's self-administration procedure and has initiated restructuring measures "to overcome the consequences of the ongoing decline in prices of German greenhouse gas (GHG) emission reduction quota". Self-administration proceedings are a proven legal framework in German restructuring law analogous to the US' Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings. They allow businesses to reorganise structures and financing while operations continue. Landwärme attributed the price decline of German GHG tickets to an influx of imported, falsely-labelled biodiesel since the start of last year, as well as other alleged fraud cases regarding upstream emission reduction (UER) projects. Fake UER projects have caused the biofuel industry around €4.5bn in damages, according to the company. Argus' Other GHG credits, GHG certificates which do not fall under caps for crop-based and Annex Part B biofuels, averaged €100/t CO2e in July, down from around €400/t CO2e in January 2023. Landwärme is also looking to bring a "financially strong partner on board" to regain the necessary stability, it said, and intends to complete the restructuring as quickly as possible. "This procedure could have been avoided if politicians and authorities had been more consistent in prosecuting and combating the alleged fraud cases in biodiesel and UER projects", managing director Zoltan Elek said. By Sophie Barthel Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Repsol, Honeywell explore biofuel production pathways
Repsol, Honeywell explore biofuel production pathways
London, 13 August (Argus) — Spanish integrated energy firm Repsol and US engineering company Honeywell have agreed to work together to develop new production pathways for biofuels and sustainable polymers. The companies plan to scale up and commercialise Honeywell technologies at Repsol refineries to produce sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) and hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) from waste feedstocks. Renewables are a key element of Repsol's strategy. The company is targeting renewable fuel production capacity of 1.5mn-1.7mn t/yr in 2027, up from 1mn t/yr in 2023. Repsol is also considering using Honeywell technology for turning waste plastics into recycled polymers, which are a feedstock for new plastics. The firm recently announced an agreement to supply the airline group IAG with over 28,000t of SAF over the next six months. By Simone Burgin Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
California narrows LCFS goals to tougher targets
California narrows LCFS goals to tougher targets
Houston, 13 August (Argus) — California will pursue transportation fuel carbon reduction targets in 2025 nearly twice as tough as originally proposed under final Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) rulemaking language released late Monday. The California Air Resources Board (CARB) will consider a one-time tightening of annual targets for gasoline and diesel by 9pc in 2025, compared with the usual 1.25pc annual reduction and a 5pc stepdown first proposed in December 2023. Final rulemaking language introduced a new 20pc/yr cap on a company's credit generation from soybean- and canola-oil-based biodiesel or renewable diesel to begin in 2028. The updated rule also dropped proposals to require carbon reductions from jet fuel in addition to gasoline and diesel, a controversial proposal aligned with governor Gavin Newsom's (D) ambitions for lower-carbon air travel but which participants warned would not achieve its targets. The new proposal immediately jolted a lethargic credit market that earlier this year slumped to the lowest spot price in nearly a decade under the weight of growing credit supplies. Current quarter trade raced higher by $12.50 — 26pc — in rare after-hours activity less than two hours after CARB staff published the latest documents. Public comment on the proposals will continue to 27 August ahead of a planned 8 November public hearing and potential board vote. The program changes could be in place by the end of the first quarter of 2025, according to staff. LCFS programs require yearly reductions to transportation fuel carbon intensity. Higher-carbon fuels that exceed these annual limits incur deficits that suppliers must offset with credits generated from the distribution to the market of approved, lower-carbon alternatives. Surging use of renewable diesel and outsized credit generation from renewable natural gas have overwhelmed deficit generation to create a glut of credits available for future compliance. LCFS credits do not expire, and 26.1mn metric tonnes of credits — higher by 16pc than all the new deficits generated in 2023 — were available for future compliance by the end of March. Credits fell in May to trade at $40/t, the lowest level for current quarter credits since June 2015. California late last year formally proposed tougher annual targets, off-ramps for certain fuels and other changes to North America's largest and oldest LCFS program. Staff had initially targeted March to put ideas including a one-time, 5pc reduction to targets in 2025 and automatic mechanisms to match targets to credit and deficit generation before the board for formal approval, but they delayed that meeting after receiving hundreds of distinct comments on the original proposal. Staff shifted the 2025 target to at least 7pc after an April workshop discussion and another record-breaking quarter of increases in credits available for future compliance. The 9pc recommendation followed the continued growth of credit supplies in recent quarters. Previous modeling estimated that such a target could draw down the credit bank by 8.2mn t in its first year. Uncertainty over how fuel suppliers and consumers would respond to that target led staff to leave in place the proposed 30pc target by 2030. An outright cap on credits generated from soybean- or canola-oil derived biomass-based diesels replaced initially proposed lighter "guard rails" on crop-based credit generation. The change would send a stronger market signal preferring waste-based feedstocks for diesel fuels that California expects to replace with zero-emission alternatives. And staff dropped a proposed obligation on jet fuel used in intrastate flights, estimated to make up 10pc of California's jet fuel consumption. Participants had warned the measure would stoke more credit purchases than renewable jet fuel buying, due to the structure of the aviation fuel market . By Elliott Blackburn Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Bill would require US EIA to share more SAF data
Bill would require US EIA to share more SAF data
New York, 12 August (Argus) — A bipartisan bill would require the US Energy Information Administration (EIA) to report more granular data about sustainable aviation fuel (SAF), which supporters say would add transparency to an opaque market and help scale up production. The agency currently tracks SAF and offers periodic updates on the fuel's use, though not on any regular cadence like it does with conventional petroleum-based fuels and more established biofuels like ethanol, biodiesel, and renewable diesel. But the US Department of Energy and EIA would have to shift course and provide more frequent and technical SAF updates "as soon as practicable" if the bill, introduced late last week by representatives Mike Flood (R-Nebraska) and Troy Carter (D-Louisiana), ends up passing. According to bill text shared with Argus , EIA would have to report on SAF production across the country and in each state, imports, and the "type, origin, and volume of feedstock" used to make SAF. The bill defines SAF as liquid fuel that produces at least 50pc fewer lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions as conventional jet fuel and that is not produced from petroleum or palm oil derivatives, mirroring eligibility requirements set out in the Inflation Reduction Act for a SAF tax credit. The bill specifically requires that EIA's Petroleum Supply Monthly and Weekly Petroleum Status Report include the new SAF data along with "any other relevant report." Potentially applicable publications include EIA's monthly report estimating biofuel production capacity — which currently lumps SAF together with renewable diesel and lesser-used biofuels — and a monthly outlook that includes production, consumption, and import projections for various commodities. Various biofuels associations — including corn groups that are banking on rising SAF production to create new demand for ethanol — voiced their support. Geoff Cooper, president of the Renewable Fuels Association, said that "this legislation would ensure SAF producers and users have the information they need to make informed decisions and smart investments." While relatively little supply is available today, EIA said last month that SAF production capacity could hit nearly 30,000 b/d this year and increase again in 2025 if planned capacity additions are not delayed. Refiners like Phillips 66, Calumet, and Valero have set plans to convert more of their renewable diesel production to SAF over the next year. There are also other production pathways in various stages of development, such as using ethanol as feedstock or converting syngas from agricultural and forest wastes into liquid fuel. The bill, which has five Democratic and two Republican sponsors, is pending before the House Committee on Energy and Commerce. EIA declined to comment on any policy proposal. By Cole Martin Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more