Coal use up at some plants with high heat rates

Market: Coal, Electricity
01/10/21

Some of the least efficient US coal plants still have no firm retirement dates, and together are generating more power this year amid an uptick in electricity demand and natural gas prices.

About 50 utility-scale facilities that burn coal had a heat rate above 11,500 Btu/kWh in the first half of 2021, which is considered high, not just above average, according to the US Energy Information Administration (EIA).

Many of the plants, which consumed nearly 27mn short tons (25mn metric tonnes) of coal in January-July, are set to close between 2021-28, company announcements show. Only a handful have retirement dates beyond that.

And there are about 18 facilities with high heat rates that have no scheduled closing dates. In the first seven months of this year, those plants burned nearly 12mn st of coal, up from 10mn st a year earlier, according to EIA data.

Most US coal-fired power plants are running at a higher capacity this year, regardless of their efficiency, as a combination of factors including higher natural gas prices drive up coal generation.

Utility-scale facilities with high heat rates had a sharper percentage increase in coal generation than more efficient plants, dispatching about 37mn MWh from January-July, a 44pc increase from a year earlier, according to EIA data.

Coal power from plants with a heat rate below 10,500 Btu/kWh climbed by 26pc to 246mn MWh. Whether power generators have a high or low heat rate, most are burning more coal "because their gas-fired competitors have to pay more for the fuel than they used to," said Paul McArdle, an economist at EIA.

"It is probably a matter of a rising tide floating all boats," he said.

Natural gas prices have trended higher since late 2020, making coal-fired generation more competitive. The day-ahead Henry Hub price averaged $3.285/mmBtu in January-July, up from $1.756/mmBtu in the same period in 2020.

The higher natural gas prices and a rebound in total generation led to US coal power rising by 30pc in the first seven months of 2021 when compared with a year earlier. More than 80pc of utility-scale facilities had an increase in coal power during that period. That included 39 of the 50 plants with a heat rate above 11,500 Btu/kWh.

Of the 18 least efficient facilities with no set retirement dates, five burn lignite only. Because of its lower heating value, more lignite must be consumed to produce a given amount of power.

Six of the 18 plants used 3.8mn st of Powder River basin (PRB) coal from Wyoming mines in the first half of 2021. And three facilities burned 1.2mn st of coal from Pennsylvania, including the Logan and Chambers Cogeneration plants in New Jersey, the St. Nicholas Cogeneration plant in Pennsylvania and the Merrimack Power station in New Hampshire.

Neither Starwood Energy, which owns the Logan and Chambers facilities, nor Schuylkill Energy Resources, which owns the St. Nicholas plant, responded to a request for comment.

Black Hills Energy said the Wygen 1 plant, which burns PRB coal, has historically had a heat rate above 11,500 Btu/kWh because of its design. It has a small boiler with no re-heater and significant auxiliary loads because of environmental control equipment and an air-cooled condenser.

But the plant plays an important role in the company's long-term capacity needs and provides a reliable, low-cost source of base load generation, Black Hills said.

Other less-efficient plants that burn PRB coal include the Big Cajun 2, John P Madgett, Powerton, Sheldon and Wyodak facilities.

The Nebraska Power Public District tied the high heat rate at its 225MW Sheldon plant to a combination of using PRB coal and a cyclone boiler. No measures are available to reduce the heat rate except through routine maintenance, the utility said.

Cleco Power said suboptimal heat rates can occur at its 1,277MW Big Cajun 2 plant in Louisiana when coal units are dispatched at lower loads. The plant's two units are subject to dispatch directed by the Midcontinent Independent System Operator.

Cleco will retire one of the Big Cajun units in 2025. It has not made any final plans for the other unit.

"There are no specific capital improvements planned at this time to change the plant's efficiency, but Cleco utilizes prudent generation practices in operations to optimize efficiency at all load levels," the utility said.

The coal plants with the lowest heat rates in January-July included the Belews Creek, Elm Road, John Turk Jr. and Longview supercritical plant. West Virginia's Longview plant, which entered service in 2011, had the lowest at 8,900 Btu/kWh. The Turk, Elm Road and Belews Creek plants' heat rates ranged from about 9,200-9,400 Btu/kWh.

By Nick Georgiou

High heat rate coal plants with no known closure dates
	Coal consumed (st)		Heat rate
Plant	Jan-Jul 2020	Jan-Jul 2021	Jan-Jul 2021

Milton R Young	2,445,572	2,341,191	11,800
San Miguel	1,426,006	1,449,590	12,600
Coyote	1,138,063	1,201,510	11,700
Major Oak Power	1,125,864	1,137,584	11,700
Powerton	464,084	1,052,232	12,200
St Nicholas Cogen Project	803,085	799,053	15,600
Wyodak	831,726	771,605	12,700
Big Cajun 2	93,245	722,079	12,500
John P Madgett	538,578	651,238	11,500
North Valmy	232,225	361,343	11,500
Sheldon	190,748	328,873	11,800
Wygen 1	301,297	299,553	12,200
Sunnyside Cogen Associates	157,907	225,247	11,900
Logan Generating Plant	132,741	151,608	12,400
Chambers Cogeneration LP	140,143	131,470	13,100
Merrimack	24,017	108,401	11,500
TES Filer City Station	127,421	100,372	12,900
Spiritwood Station	50,118	70,279	27,800
— EIA

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News

02/05/25

Australia's Coalition eyes power, resource funding cuts

Sydney, 2 May (Argus) — Australia's federal Coalition opposition has announced it will cut key energy rebates and resource sector subsidies, if elected on 3 May, to reduce forecast future budget deficits. The Peter Dutton-led opposition will cut programs, including the Labor government's A$20bn ($12.8bn) Rewiring the Nation transmission plan, and the A$15bn National Reconstruction Fund aimed at underwriting green manufacturing using domestic minerals. It will also unwind electric vehicle tax concessions to save A$3.2bn, and cancel planned production tax credits for critical minerals processing and green hydrogen estimated to cost A$14.7bn. Combined savings measures will improve the budget's position by A$13.9bn over the four years to 2028-29, the Coalition said on 1 May, cutting debt by A$40bn during the same timeframe. The announcement comes as opinion polls show Australia's next federal government is likely to force one of the two major parties into minority, after a campaign where cost-of-living relief promises have trumped economic reform policy. The centre-left Labor party is more likely than the conservative Coalition to form government at the 3 May poll. It holds a thin majority of just three seats in parliament's main chamber, the House of Representatives, meaning a swing against it would force it to deal with minor parties such as the Greens and independent groupings. Promising a stable government, as Australia emerged from Covid-19, Labor had benefited from a resources boom as Russia's invasion of Ukraine led LNG and coal receipts to skyrocket and China's emergence from lockdowns revitalised its demand for iron ore, which jointly form the nation's main commodity exports. But as markets adjust to a period of protectionist trade policy and predictions of a slowdown in global growth abound, economists have criticised the major parties' reluctance to embrace major reform on areas such as taxation, while continuing to spend at elevated levels post-pandemic. Australia's resource and energy commodity exports are forecast to fall to A$387bn in the fiscal year to 30 June 2025 from A$415bn in 2023–24. The Office of the Chief Economist is predicting further falls over the next five years, reaching A$343bn in 2029-30, lowering expected government revenue from company tax and royalties. Gas The Coalition has pledged a domestic reservation scheme for the east coast, forcing 50-100PJ (1.34bn-2.68bn m³/yr) into the grid by penalising spot LNG cargoes. Australia's upstream lobby has opposed this, but rapidly declining reserves offshore Victoria state mean gas may need to be imported to the nation's south, depending on the success of electrification efforts and an uncertain timeline for coal-fired power retirements. Labor has resisted such further gas interventions , but it is unclear how it will reverse a trend of rising gas prices and diminishing domestic supply, despite releasing a future gas plan last year. The party is promising 82pc renewables nationally by 2030, meaning it will have to nearly double the 2025 year-to-date figure of 42pc. This could require 15GW of gas-fired capacity by 2050 to firm the grid. On environmental policy, narrowing polls mean Labor's likely partners in government could be the anti-fossil fuel Greens and climate-focused independents — just some of the present crossbench of 16 out of a parliament of 151. The crossbench may drive a climate trigger requirement in any changes to environmental assessments, which could rule out new or brownfield coal and gas projects. Coal has been conspicuously absent from policy debates, but Labor has criticised the Coalition's nuclear energy policy as expensive and unproven, while the Coalition has said Labor's renewables-led grid would be unstable and costly because of new transmission requirements. The impact of the US tariff shock that dominated opening days of the month-long election campaign remains unclear. Unlike Canada, Australia is yet to be directly targeted by US president Trump's rhetoric on trade balances and barriers. But the global unease that has set in could assist Labor's prime minister Anthony Albanese, as he presents an image of continuity in an uncertain world economy. Australia's main exposure to Trump tariffs is via China, its largest trading partner and destination for about 35pc of exports, including metal concentrates, ores, coal and LNG. A downturn in the world's largest manufacturer would spell difficult times ahead for Australia, as it grapples with balancing its budget in a normalising commodity market. By Tom Major Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Find out more

News

India extends directive to lift coal-fired generation

02/05/25

News

02/05/25

India extends directive to lift coal-fired generation

Singapore, 2 May (Argus) — India's power ministry has extended its directive requiring imported coal-fired utilities to boost generation by two months until 30 June, a move that could support demand for seaborne coal over the peak summer period. The directive covers imported coal-fired plants with a combined capacity of 17.5GW and was previously set to expire on 30 April. The decision could support India's coal imports, which have remained lacklustre so far in 2025. India imported 38.29mn t of thermal coal in January-March, down from 41.87mn t a year earlier, according to data from shipbroker Interocean. Imports may have remained under pressure in April, with India's seaborne thermal coal receipts estimated at 15.77mn t for the month, down from 15.84mn t a year earlier, according to trade analytics platform Kpler. India's coal-fired generation remained above the historical average in April in line with the uptick in power demand, although actual coal burn was down on the month and year. India's coal-fired generation — which meets most of its power requirements — stood at 113.48 TWh in April, down from 116.58 TWh a year earlier and 117.95 TWh a month earlier, according to data from the Central Electricity Authority (CEA). The extension of the order appears to be a pre-emptive measure by the authorities to ensure imported coal-fired utilities are well stocked to meet any uptick in power demand. The country is currently sitting on a surplus of domestic coal, with elevated inventory at its utilities. Delhi has been proactively directing utilities to boost output since mid-2022 to cater for seasonal surges in power demand. Combined coal inventories at Indian power plants stood at 56.69mn t as of 30 April, up from 47.92mn t a year earlier, but down from 58.11mn t as of 31 March, CEA data show. Inventories at state-controlled Coal India (CIL) also remained high, according to market participants. By Saurabh Chaturvedi Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

US factory activity contracts for 2nd month in April

01/05/25

News

01/05/25

US factory activity contracts for 2nd month in April

Houston, 1 May (Argus) — US manufacturing activity contracted in April for a second month, as output and new orders slowed on tariff policy uncertainty, while price gains accelerated. The Institute for Supply Management's manufacturing purchasing managers' index (PMI) fell to 48.7 in April, down from 49 in March and the lowest since last November. The threshold between contraction and expansion is 50. The two-month contraction in manufacturing activity follows a two-month expansion preceded by 26 consecutive months of contraction. ISM's services PMI, a separate report that tracks the biggest part of the economy, showed nine months of expansion through March. "Demand and production retreated and de-staffing continued, as panelists' companies responded to an unknown economic environment," ISM said Thursday. "Prices growth accelerated slightly due to tariffs, causing new-order placement backlogs, supplier delivery slowdowns and manufacturing inventory growth." The manufacturing data follows a report Wednesday that showed the US economy contracted at an annualized 0.3pc pace in the first quarter as businesses boosted imports and stocked up on goods ahead of US import tariffs. The ISM's new-orders index came in at 47.2, higher than 45.2 in March but showing contraction for a third month. The production index fell to 44, showing a deepening contraction from 48.3 in the prior month. Employment rose by 1.8 points to 46.5, showing a slowing contraction. New export orders contracted faster at 43.1 in April, while imports entered contraction at 47.1 after barely growing, at 50.1, the prior month. The prices index rose to 69.8, up from 69.4 the prior month and signaling quickening expansion. The inventories index fell by 2.6 points to 50.8, marking a second month of expansion after six months of contraction. By Bob Willis Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Indonesia's coal power phase-out hinges on funding

01/05/25

News

01/05/25

Indonesia's coal power phase-out hinges on funding

Manila, 1 May (Argus) — Indonesia's accelerated coal-fired power phase-out plan hinges on private-sector and international partners financial support, the country's energy ministry said, after issuing further guidance last month. Indonesian energy ministry ESDM published a ministerial regulation in early April outlining the criteria and processes for the early retirement of coal-fired power plants. But the plan will not be carried out if there is no clarity over funding for its energy transition efforts, in which case Jakarta will continue to prioritise domestic energy production, including through fossil-based sources, ESDM said this week. The Indonesian government will not use its state budget or funds from state-owned utility PLN to fund the early retirement of coal-fired plants, ESDM said. The new regulation details the evaluation processes for retiring coal-fired plants early, and emphasises the need for financial support from private-sector or international partners to achieve an accelerated phase out. Policy makers will evaluate the impact of a plant's retirement on the country's electricity grid, power supply and electricity tariffs, among other factors, when considering its phase out, ESDM said. It will also take into account aspects of the Just Energy Transition Partnership (JETP) climate financing pact signed with rich nations in 2022, such as the livelihood of employees affected by the phase-out, as well as a plant's capacity, age, utilisation, greenhouse gas emissions and economic value. The availability of foreign and domestic technological support will also be considered; according to ESDM. US president Donald Trump's decision to withdraw the US from the JETP raised concerns earlier this year on whether Indonesia could stick to its energy transition policies, but the country recently secured $60mn in JETP funding to develop a solar project . State-owned utility PLN will be tasked with studying the technical, legal, commercial and financial aspects of decommissioning plants that are put forward for early retirement, including funding sources. It will have to submit a report to the ministry no later than six months from the date a plant is identified for decommissioning, ESDM said. The share of renewables in Indonesia's power mix is expected to rise to around 21pc by 2030 and 41pc by 2040, according to think-tank Ember. By Antonio delos Reyes Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Brazil's energy transition spending drops in 2024

30/04/25

News

30/04/25

Brazil's energy transition spending drops in 2024

Sao Paulo, 30 April (Argus) — Brazil's mines and energy ministry's (MME) energy transition spending shrank by 83pc in 2024 from the prior year, while resources for fossil fuel incentives remained unchanged, according to the institute of socioeconomic studies Inesc. The MME's energy transition budget was R141,413 ($24,980) in 2024, down from R835,237 in the year prior. MME had only two energy transition-oriented projects under its umbrella last year: biofuels industry studies and renewable power incentives, which represented a combined 0.002pc of its total R7bn budget. Still, despite available resources, MME did not approve any projects for renewable power incentives. It also only used 50pc of its budget for biofuel studies, Inesc said. Even as supply from non-conventional power sources advances , most spending in Brazil's grid revamp — including enhancements to better integrate solar and wind generation — comes from charges paid by consumers through power tariffs, Inesc said. Diverging energy spending Brazil's federal government also cut its energy transition budget for 2025 by 17pc from last year and created a new energy transition program that also pushes for increased fossil fuel usage. The country's energy transition budget for 2025 is R3.64bn, down from R4.44bn in 2024. The new program — also under MME's umbrella — has a budget of around R10mn, with more than half of it destined to studies related to the oil and natural gas industry, Inesc said. A second MME program — which invests in studies in the oil, natural gas, products and biofuels sectors — has an approved budget of R53.1mn. The science and technology ministry is the only in Brazil that increased its energy transition spending for 2025, with R3.03bn approved, a near threefold hike from R800mn in 2024. Spending will focus on the domestic industry sector's energy transition, Inesc said. Despite hosting the UN Cop 30 summit in November, Brazil has constantly neglected to address the phase-out of fossil fuels, drawing the ire of climate activists . By Maria Frazatto Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more