Generic Hero BannerGeneric Hero Banner
Latest market news

German state in dilemma over gas storage holdings

  • Market: Natural gas
  • 12/01/23

The German government faces a dilemma over what to do with the gas that it bought unhedged and stored underground last summer, with far-reaching consequences for the wholesale gas market.

In a move that wound back years of market reform, German gas market area manager THE, on behalf of the government, bought and injected into storage about 50TWh of gas last summer. This was a last-resort measure under new legislation that introduced mandatory gas filling targets in the country, to increase security of supply in the wake of Russia's invasion of Ukraine. THE stored the gas at five sites, most of which were previously used by Russian state-controlled Gazprom (see table).

At the time, THE was allowed to buy gas only on the spot market. This meant the German state purchased gas when it was more expensive than ever before without offsetting sales of gas for delivery during the winter, which would have locked in a price for the gas and removed the risk of its value falling before it was eventually withdrawn.

Now, Germany and the wider region is more than halfway through a much calmer winter than was feared — thanks to mild weather, considerable gas demand reductions and ample LNG supply availability. Waning supply concerns have resulted in gas prices tumbling since late December, contrasting with the successive price spikes in the summer (see prices graph).

The recent price drop means any gas that THE withdraws now would be worth significantly less than what the market area manager paid to inject it. And this substantial trading loss will be passed on to German customers through a gas storage levy introduced for this purpose.

THE made a net loss of more than €9.3bn from carrying out the country's mandatory gas filling rules as of the end of last year. It may have spent about €7.8bn to buy 50TWh of gas, based on the average Argus Germany VTP everyday price of €155.09/MWh from 4 June-31 October and assuming flat deliveries to storage.

The government earned only $146mn through withdrawals in October-December, during which time combined gross withdrawals at the five sites filled by THE were 2.51TWh.

Based on the German everyday price on 1-12 January and forward contracts delivering over the rest of the first quarter as of the close of 11 January, if THE sold all the remaining gas on the spot market, it would earn €3.3bn. This would be a theoretical loss of more than €4.4bn, considering the estimated cost of purchasing the gas.

And this is before considering that by selling all of its stored gas in a market that does not need it — storage inventories across the region are high, consumption is well below normal for winter and supply from sources other than Russia is ample — THE would drive down the spot price much further (see stocks graph).

State as a long-term gas trader?

If the German government decides to postpone selling its stored gas, this might entrench its role as a significant player in the wholesale gas market.

Asked by Argus this week what it plans to do, THE avoided specifics but shed some light on its predicament. "Precautionary measures with a view to the 2023-24 winter appear sensible and necessary to a certain extent," so not all the gas procured by THE will be withdrawn, the market area manager said. THE will "react dynamically" to gas market developments in co-ordination with the state and regulator Bnetza and "adapt the withdrawal strategy if necessary", it said.

THE said it uses spot and forward products for sale using trading platforms Enmacc and EEX.

If the government holds on to a significant volume of gas in storage beyond the end of winter, this raises the question as to when it will be able to extricate itself from the wholesale market. Transmission system operators are not supposed to play an active role in gas trading given the conflict of interest between their trading position and their control over other firms' access to infrastructure, which is the reason for the EU's unbundling rules.

And by holding back on selling its stored gas, the state would be depriving itself of revenues in the short term. This might force THE to significantly raise its gas storage levy, which was set at €0.59/MWh for the first half of this year.

German storage sites at which THE holds gasTWh
FacilityStocks on 1 JunStocks on 1 NovStocks on 11 JanWorking gas capacity
Rehden0.8740.2839.4843.68
Katharina1.075.916.156.13
Wolfersburg0.473.924.074.12
Jemgum (Astora)2.788.097.858.13
Nuttermoor H30.482.522.582.52

Germany VTP gas price tumbles €/MWh

German gas stocks TWh

Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News
21/02/25

Republicans target US energy rules for disapproval

Republicans target US energy rules for disapproval

Washington, 21 February (Argus) — Republican leaders in the US House of Representatives hope to disapprove at least seven energy-related measures issued under former president Joe Biden using a filibuster-proof process created under the Congressional Review Act. House majority leader Steve Scalise (R-Louisiana) on Thursday released a list of 10 rules that his party has prioritized as "potential targets" for disapproval votes, which require only a simple majority to pass in each chamber. Republicans previously used the law in 2017 to successfully unwind more than a dozen rules, and they hope to do so again to repeal Biden-era rules they say will unnecessarily raise costs on businesses and consumers. A US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulation that implements a $900/t charge on oil and gas sector methane leaks is among the rules that Republicans want to disapprove. If those implementing rules are scrapped, it would provide a temporary reprieve from a 31 August deadline for operators having to pay billions of dollars in potential fees on methane emitted in 2024. Republicans hope to vote later this year to permanently end the methane charge, which was created by the Inflation Reduction Act. House Republicans also hope to disapprove an offshore oil and gas safety rule for drilling in deepwater "high pressure, high temperature" environments that Scalise's office says will increase "burdens on energy operations". Other rules that Republicans will target for disapproval are energy conservation for gas water heaters, energy efficiency labeling standards and air pollution restrictions on rubber tire manufactures. Two of the energy measures House Republicans say they plan to target might not qualify for disapproval under the Congressional Review Act, which can only be used on a "rule". The first is a waiver that would allow California to boost in-state sales of electric vehicles and plug-in hybrids, and that President Donald Trump's administration has tried to make eligible for repeal. The second is the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission's decision to release voluntary guidance for exchanges that allow trading of carbon offset futures. By Chris Knight Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Find out more
News

Freeze cuts Oklahoma oil and gas output


21/02/25
News
21/02/25

Freeze cuts Oklahoma oil and gas output

New York, 21 February (Argus) — Frigid weather in Oklahoma this week has shut in about a third of state oil and natural gas production, according to analysts and pipeline flow data. About 35-40pc of daily oil and gas output in Oklahoma have been lost to freeze-offs from 19-21 February, Energy Aspects analyst David Seduski told Argus . That amounts to cuts of about 150,000 b/d of crude and 2.5 Bcf/d (71mn m³/d) of gas over the period relative to average daily production in the state, US Energy Information Administration data show. The drop was observable in publicly available data for most interstate pipelines across the state, including Kinder Morgan's Natural Gas Pipeline Company, Howard Energy Partner's Midship Pipeline and Energy Transfer's Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line Company and Enable Gas Transmission pipelines, FactSet energy analyst Bailey McLaughlin said. Production will probably continue to be lost through the weekend as cold weather lingers in the state. Freeze-offs occur when temperatures drop low enough to prevent oil and gas production from reaching the wellhead by causing the water contained in the oil and gas stream to freeze. Freeze-offs in Oklahoma typically occur when temperatures fall below 22°F (-6°C), McLaughlin said. This is a higher threshold than the temperature required to curtail output in colder producing regions such as North Dakota, which has also lost production to freeze-offs in recent weeks. The spot gas price at ANR Oklahoma, a regional trading hub on TC Energy's ANR Pipeline, on Thursday surged to $7.715/mmBtu, double the week-earlier price and the highest since 17 January. By Julian Hast Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Uruguay eyes oil, gas E&P within energy transition


21/02/25
News
21/02/25

Uruguay eyes oil, gas E&P within energy transition

Montevideo, 21 February (Argus) — Uruguay's state-run Ancap has hopes for an offshore oil or gas discovery, even as the country gears up for its second energy transition. Uruguay has had only three exploratory wells drilled in its history, two in 1976 and one in 2017, and they all came up dry. Companies have completed 13,000 km² of 2D and 41,000 km² of 3D seismic testing this century. Today, its seven offshore blocks have contracts, plans are underway for a new round of seismic testing and one company, US-based APA, wants to spud an exploratory well in its wholly operated block 6 in late 2026 or early 2027. "For the first time in history, we have contracts in place for all the blocks and there is a great deal of interest that resources can be found" in Uruguay, Santiago Ferro, Ancap's energy transition manager, told Argus . A public hearing on seismic testing was held 13 February and the environment ministry is reviewing proposals for permits. Ferro said seismic testing will only be done in areas lacking data. "We want to take advantage of existing information and complement it with new data to encourage drilling," he said. The plan is for approximately 5,000 km² (1,930 mi²) of new seismic testing on two areas — block 1, operated by Chevron and UK-based Challenger Energy Group, and block 4, operated by Shell and APA. The work will likely happen in the final quarter of this year. Ancap's plans will unfold under the new left-wing government of president-elect Yamandu Orsi, who takes office on 1 March. The Oris administration is committed to deepening Uruguay's energy transition. It already has one of the greenest power grids, with 99pc of power coming from renewables, and the Orsi government wants to guarantee electrification of the transportation sector. He will arrive at his inauguration in an elective vehicle as a sign of the government's commitment. The administration wants to decarbonize transportation in 10 years, which will require incentives for vehicles and investment in additional renewable power, principally solar energy. It has not taken a public stand on oil and gas exploration or what it would do if recoverable resources were discovered. By Lucien Chauvin Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

US cites 'energy emergency' to expedite water permits


20/02/25
News
20/02/25

US cites 'energy emergency' to expedite water permits

Washington, 20 February (Argus) — President Donald Trump's administration is citing an "energy emergency" as the basis to fast-track nearly 700 water permits, including those tied to a tunnel for Enbridge's Line 5 pipeline, LNG infrastructure projects, solar farms and electric transmission lines. Trump declared a national energy emergency on his first day in office, unlocking permitting powers that are typically used in response to natural disasters. The US Army Corps of Engineers has subsequently reclassified hundreds of permit applications for review under expedited emergency procedures, in a move that environmentalists say they plan to challenge in court based on violations of the Clean Water Act and Endangered Species Act. "The Trump administration is planning to skirt legally-required review processes in order to fast-track permits for dirty energy projects under the guise of an energy ‘emergency'", Sierra Club policy director Mahyar Sorour said. The Corps is responsible for issuing water permits for projects that cross streams, rivers, wetlands and other water bodies. Issuing permits sometimes requires the agency to prepare a detailed environmental review that is open to comment and can take years to finish. The water permits classified for emergency treatment include a repair project for Sabine Pass LNG in Louisiana, dredging for Elba Island LNG in Georgia, temporary construction related to Port Arthur LNG in Texas, solar projects in dozens of states, and pipeline projects ExxonMobil is pursuing in Texas. Enbridge delayed construction of a protective tunnel for its Line 5 pipeline to 2026 because of water permitting delays . But environmentalists say the administration cannot cite an energy emergency — which they say does not exist — as justification to bypass permitting rules prescribed by the US Congress. The Corps has also provided emergency treatment to projects with no apparent connection to energy production, such as a housing project in southern California and a gold mine in Idaho, according to an online database. The Corps did not respond to detailed questions but said it was "in the process of reviewing active permit applications relative to the executive order." Congress is continuing to lay groundwork for a bipartisan permitting bill that supporters say could make it faster and cheaper to build pipelines, power plants, electric transmission lines, renewable energy projects and transportation infrastructure. But Democratic leaders are threatening to vote against such a bill so long as Trump continues to "pause" billions of dollars in funding for clean energy projects provided by the Inflation Reduction Act and other laws. "Until the administration shows it will honor its oath to faithfully and impartially execute the laws, we can have zero confidence that any legislative compromise on permitting reform will be executed lawfully," US senator Sheldon Whitehouse (D-Rhode Island) said at a permitting hearing on 19 February. Oil industry and renewable groups are continuing to push for a comprehensive permitting bill, which they say would bring down project costs and help the US meet surging electricity demand from data centers and manufacturers. Permitting changes are "needed for all technologies, and they are needed to meet our energy demand in the future," Business Council for Sustainable Energy president Lisa Jacobson said. "You can't walk away from those facts or that imperative." By Chris Knight Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Rare SK-PL gas flows as Polish demand surges


20/02/25
News
20/02/25

Rare SK-PL gas flows as Polish demand surges

London, 20 February (Argus) — Gas has flowed from Slovakia to Poland over the past two days, a rare occurrence since the commissioning of the pipeline, as demand in the latter surged on the back of plunging temperatures. More than 13GWh flowed to Poland from Slovakia at the Vyrava interconnection point on 18 February, and nearly 23GWh on 19 February, transmission system data show. These were the first receipts in either direction at Vyrava since 22 April 2024, as the pipeline has been little-utilised since its commissioning in November 2022 . In addition, there was nearly 40GWh of inflows from Lithuania, the highest for any day since 3 December. This helped boost Polish net imports to 669GWh on 19 February, the highest for any day since 31 December. Stronger imports have been needed as a result of higher domestic consumption caused by plunging temperatures. Overnight lows in Warsaw began to dip below the long-term average on 8 February, but gas demand did not start to significantly increase until 10 February, when minimum temperatures in the capital dropped to minus 7.7°C. Polish high-calorie consumption has since jumped to 903 GWh/d on 10-19 February from 782 GWh/d earlier in the month and 768 GWh/d in January. Demand peaked at 949GWh on 17 February, the highest for any day since 10 January 2024, and not far from the all-time high of 1TWh on 18 January 2021. On 17 February, overnight lows in Warsaw dropped to minus 14.3°C, by far the lowest for any day this winter. In addition to imports from Slovakia and Lithuania in recent days, there were net inflows from Germany at Mallnow of 55 GWh/d on 15-17 February, which is also rare given the expensive nature of these receipts. Because the Yamal-Europe pipeline is not yet fully integrated into the national transmission system, importers have to pay a double tariff to bring gas in at Mallnow and then out into the domestic grid, making imports through this route particularly expensive and uncompetitive in most cases. That said, these flows halted again on 18-19 February. Poland also imported at maximum capacity from the Baltic Pipe each day over 15-19 February, while LNG sendout from Swinoujscie surged to 257 GWh/d out of a maximum capacity of 264 GWh/d on 18-19 February after the arrival of a Qatari cargo a day earlier ( see February imports graph ). Strong imports from almost all directions have been driven by large premiums on the Polish prompt compared with neighbouring markets, with the day-ahead price on the Polish TGE exchange holding €4.23/MWh higher than Argus' Slovak day-ahead market on 1-19 February, and a larger €5.45/MWh and €6.32/MWh to the Czech and German markets, respectively ( see price graph ). Despite the cold snap, Polish firms still exported 25 GWh/d toward Ukraine since 8 February, with flows rising as high as 45GWh on 19 February. Ukraine has been importing heavily from all directions as cold weather has driven storage withdrawals to near their maximum and attacks on production infrastructure have reduced domestic output. Tightness to continue in short term The weather is expected to remain particularly cold over the next three days, likely continuing to bolster demand, but from 24 February onward it is forecast to turn much milder. Minimum temperatures in Warsaw were most recently forecast to reach minus 7°C on 20 February and as low as minus 9°C a day later, before climbing to minus 6°C on 23-24 February. These are all well below the 10-year average for the period of minus 4°C. And along with the continued cold weather, upcoming unplanned maintenance at Swinoujscie will take around 61 GWh/d of the terminal's regasification capacity off line on the 23 February-12 March gas days, further tightening the market. However, from 24 February onward minimum temperatures in Warsaw are forecast to increase significantly to around minus 1°C, and rise above freezing the next day. Overnight lows are then expected to hold above the 10-year average on each day from 24 February-6 March, which should curb heating demand, bringing consumption down and in turn requiring lower imports. By Brendan A'Hearn Polish February net imports GWh Polish day-ahead prices vs neighbouring countries €/MWh Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Generic Hero Banner

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more