Generic Hero BannerGeneric Hero Banner
Latest market news

US court halts RFS mandate for 2 refineries

  • Market: Biofuels, Emissions, Oil products
  • 27/01/23

An appeals court has suspended the compliance obligations under the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) for two small refineries that were denied hardship exemptions last year under a new federal policy.

The 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals agreed to stay the compliance obligations for the two refineries — which are located in Texas and Louisiana — after finding the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) likely violated the law last year when it denied all pending requests for small refinery waivers from the RFS based on a new interpretation.

"That retroactive application of EPA's 'new interpretation' — which quite possibly will read the exemption framework promulgated by Congress out of the statute entirely, such that no small refinery will ever qualify for one — is thus likely contrary to law," the court wrote.

The stay will remain in place until the 5th Circuit has time to rule on the merits of the litigation, which was filed by 21,000 b/d San Antonio Refinery (TSAR) and the 57,000 b/d Calumet Shreveport refinery. But the court order shows a likelihood the 5th Circuit will eventually find EPA overstepped when it revised its handling of small refinery exemptions last year.

EPA did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

EPA as recently as 2017 had approved exemptions to 34 refineries that claimed they faced "disproportion economic hardship" from the RFS, which requires refineries to blend biofuels into the fuel supply or purchase compliance credits called RINs. But EPA last year followed a new methodology that found there was no economic hardship and denied years of requests for waivers that small refineries had asked for dating back to 2018.

The 5th Circuit, in its ruling, found that TSAR and Calumet were likely to prevail in their claim that EPA's new interpretation was an "unlawful retroactive application" of a new standard. EPA "changed its rules retroactively" without providing refiners fair notice of the change, the court wrote.

"Nothing here is to suggest that TSAR and Calumet are entitled to continuing hardship waivers," the court said. "But they are entitled to know the ground rules by which EPA will grant or deny their hardship petitions, in advance of making their application."

EPA had argued against a stay, which it said would artificially inflate the number of RINs used to comply with the RFS, undercutting the goals of the program and reducing demand for renewable fuel. EPA had argued the two refineries should not be rewarded for their non-compliance with the biofuel program.

But the 5th Circuit said it found the arguments by the two small refineries more persuasive. TSAR had said that without a stay of its compliance obligations under the RFS, it would be forced to file for bankruptcy within months. Calumet said it would be insolvent in a matter of weeks.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News
17/03/25

EU prepares CBAM export scheme

EU prepares CBAM export scheme

Brussels, 17 March (Argus) — The European Commission is preparing a "solution" for exported goods under the bloc's carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM), to be presented before the end of the year. The commission will also expand the scope of the CBAM to "certain" steel and aluminium-intensive downstream products. The changes to the CBAM will be announced as part of a European steel and metals plan. In a draft of the plan to be formally presented on 19 March, the commission points to the need to address the problem of carbon leakage for CBAM goods exported from the EU to non-EU countries. The draft also notes that the commission is currently "quantifying" risks, before proposing an extension of the CBAM to "certain" steel and aluminium-intensive downstream products, so as to address the risk of European producers relocating outside the bloc to avoid higher carbon costs. The metals plan also announces an anti-circumvention strategy for the CBAM to be presented in the second half of 2025. The commission points to the risk of goods from low-carbon production facilities in non-EU countries being redirected to European customers, while carbon-intensive production continues for other markets. The metals plan also points to the risk of "greenwashing" carbon accounting practices, with "electro-intensive metals production benefiting from market-based instruments to appear low-carbon". The commission put forward proposals last month to simplify the CBAM, exempting some 90pc of the firms currently covered by the mechanism. By Dafydd ab Iago Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Find out more
News

Timing for EU's 2040 climate goal slips


17/03/25
News
17/03/25

Timing for EU's 2040 climate goal slips

Brussels, 17 March (Argus) — The European Commission appears to have pushed back an official proposal for a 2040 climate target for the EU, which will further delay the bloc's submission of a 2035 climate plan to the UN. The commission's agenda does not include the presentation of a legal proposal for a 2040 climate target before the end of the first quarter. The commission in February 2024 confirmed its preference for a 90pc cut in greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs) by 2040, from a 1990 baseline — but this was not a formal proposal. The commission had scheduled an amendment to the European Climate Law for the first quarter of 2025. That amendment would write an intermediate target for 2040 into EU law. The 2040 target would also provide the basis for the EU's updated nationally determined contribution (NDC) — or climate plan — to UN climate body the UNFCCC. Countries and jurisdictions were expected to submit updated NDCs, covering up to 2035, to the UNFCCC by 10 February. Officials said work is "ongoing" on the bloc's 2040 climate target. It would be presented "sooner rather than later" and there is still "time left until the end of the first quarter". An EU source indicated reluctance to present a 2040 climate plan before Poland's presidential elections on 18 May, which may have a runoff on 1 June. Poland chairs meetings of EU ministers until 1 July. The source also said several other parties to the UNFCCC have missed the 10 February deadline to submit their 2035 emissions reduction targets. By Dafydd ab Iago Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

UK launches anti-dumping probe into US-origin HVO


17/03/25
News
17/03/25

UK launches anti-dumping probe into US-origin HVO

London, 17 March (Argus) — The UK today began an anti-dumping investigation into hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) from the US. An application for the investigation was lodged by the UK Renewable Transport Fuel Association (RTFA) and UK-based biofuels producers Greenergy, Argent Energy and Olleco. The goods subject to investigation are "biodiesel obtained from synthesis or hydrotreatment of oils and fats of non-fossil origin, in pure form or as included in a blend". The UK trade remedies authority (TRA) specified that sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) is excluded from this definition. The investigation period spans from 1 January 2024 to 31 December 2024. During this time, the applicants allege HVO was imported into the UK at prices below the "normal value". They say this alleged dumping led to an actual and potential decline in production, domestic sales, and profitability. The UK removed transposed EU anti-dumping and countervailing duties on imports of HVO from the US and Canada in 2022. The EU first imposed anti-dumping duties for US-origin HVO in 2009 , and the current duties are in place until August 2026. Those in the market said the effect of the UK investigation is being mitigated by proposed guidance on the US 45Z clean fuel production credits released earlier this year. This has already slowed discussions around new imports of US-origin HVO into T1 duty markets. The guidance does not allow US producers to claim the tax credit using imported used cooking oil (UCO), meaning US supply of UCO-based HVO could decrease or be reserved for the domestic market, participants said. HVO, or renewable diesel, is a drop-in biofuel that can go well beyond the European 7pc blend wall for biodiesel. UK HVO consumption increased by 38pc on the year in 2024 to 699mn l, according to the latest provisional release of UK Renewable Transport Fuel Obligation statistics . This was mostly due to increased imports of US-origin HVO, according to market participants. Interested parties must register by 1 April, after which they will be able to submit comments. The TRA aims to make a final recommendation in March 2026. By Evelina Lungu Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Brazil to pilot reforestation concession


17/03/25
News
17/03/25

Brazil to pilot reforestation concession

Sao Paulo, 17 March (Argus) — Brazil's Para state in the Amazon basin will concede reforesting 10,000 hectares (ha) in the Triunfo do Xingu environmental reserve as part of efforts to protect more rainforest ahead of the UN Cop 30 climate summit in November. The 40-year concession will require R258.3mn ($45.3mn) in investments and capture an estimated 3.7mn metric tonnes (t) of CO2 equivalent (tCO2e)/yr, according to the Para state government. The 1.6mn ha Triunfo do Xingu reserve, which was created in 2006, has seen significant environmental degradation in recent years from illegal deforestation. Last year, the reserve lost 1,400km² (870 mi²) to illegal deforestation, the bulk of which was converted into pastureland. The concession, which will be Brazil's first for reforestation, will be a test case for the government's efforts to recover its tropical forests and is possible because of legislation approved in 2023, which allows carbon offsets to be issued on public lands. The auction will take place on 28 March at the B3 stock exchange, in Sao Paulo state. The winner of the project will be allowed to sell carbon offsets and environmental services credits, which will be generated by reforesting and preserving the forest. The sale of some forestry products is also approved. The Para state government estimates that the concession will generate gross revenues of R21.7mn/yr. Para will also sell two other 10,000ha concessions later this year, it said. Brazil has continued to reduce deforestation in the Amazon forest. It lost just 80.9km² of Amazon rainforest in February, down more than 64pc from the same month last year. February deforestation was the lowest on record, according to the science and technology ministry's national space institute INPE. Brazil's goal is to eliminate all deforestation by 2030. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

German gasoil demand rises but remains weak


17/03/25
News
17/03/25

German gasoil demand rises but remains weak

Hamburg, 17 March (Argus) — Wholesale diesel and heating oil sales in Germany continue to rise this year and supply is ample, particularly along the Rhine river. But demand remains weak compared with this time last year making imports uneconomical. Diesel demand is rising seasonally because of warmer temperatures and an associated uptick in agriculture and construction activity. Heating oil demand is being boosted by falling prices, which are as low as they were in December even with the increased German greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction quota and CO2 levy in place since the turn of the year. In the Rhine areas of western and southwestern Germany, the price of heating oil and diesel is lower than it is in northern, eastern and the southeastern Bavaria regions. This suggests that, partly because of ample refinery production in the west, available product exceeds current demand. Low Rhine water levels since the beginning of March, which reduce barge loadings upstream from Kaub, have not led to shortages. Another indication of low import demand is that freight rates have risen only slightly despite the low water levels and some canal closures. Argus ' calculations show spot imports from the Amsterdam-Rotterdam-Antwerp (ARA) hub along the Rhine would currently be loss-making. Maintenance work at the Bayernoil consortium's 215,000 b/d Vohburg-Neustadt refinery north of Munich, which started in early March, is leading to the highest regional prices in Germany. Traded spot volumes are correspondingly low. Gasoil imports by sea cargo into northern Germany are at their lowest level in at least two years. This could contribute to the price in northern and eastern Germany being somewhat higher than in the west and southwest. German diesel demand in 2025 remains below average in a multi-year comparison. The main reason for this is declining industrial production and a resulting decrease in freight activity. The German truck toll index fell to its lowest February value in eight years. By Johannes Guhlke Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Generic Hero Banner

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more