US court ruling may leave door open to CO2 trading
The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) may still be able to use emissions trading to reduce power plant CO2 emissions despite the recent US Supreme Court decision curbing its authority.
The high court ruling does not foreclose the ability of EPA to use a cap-and-trade system or requirements for the use of technology such as carbon capture, according to lawyers who spoke today during a virtual forum hosted by the Georgetown Climate Center.
"If anything, it gives them more flexibility than I think they thought they had," said Jeff Holmstead, head of the environmental practice at law firm Bracewell, who led EPA's Office of Air and Radiation during the administration of former president George W Bush. "They spoke approvingly of trading. They talked about the flexibility that states have in meeting any section 111(d) guidelines or limitations," referring to the part of the Clean Air Act used to issue the Clean Power Plan.
In a 6-3 decision, the court last week said EPA lacks the authority under the Clean Air Act to require generation shifting to reduce CO2 emissions from power plants, as envisioned by the Clean Power Plan the agency issued under former president Barack Obama. The majority, made up of the court's conservative justices, said that section 111(d) of the law does not grant the agency broad authority to use such measures that would, in effect, "restructure" the nation's energy mix. The justices called it a "major questions" case, citing the legal doctrine which says issues of significant economic or political importance require specific authorization from Congress.
But it did not say EPA could only use measures done "inside the fence line" at a power plant, a view the agency had taken under former president Donald Trump, nor did it say it had no authority to regulate CO2 at all under section 111(d).
That could also open the door to EPA mandating the use of carbon capture or co-firing as ways to address the power sector emissions, although each may face its own legal challenges.
"There's nothing in this opinion that would preclude that," said Jonathan Adler, director of the Coleman P Burke Center for Environmental Law at Case Western Reserve University School of Law. "I suspect the big argument would be over the cost side for carbon capture."
Another option for EPA could be to rely more heavily on other well-established regulations, such as standards for criteria air pollutants, that may have a co-benefit of reducing emissions.
"I think they should focus on things that can drastically affect coal but not because of climate change," said Lisa Heinzerling from the Georgetown University Law Center, who served as senior climate policy counsel at EPA during the Obama administration.
But EPA will also need to worry about using "policies that look like the agency is doing one thing but is doing it for the reason of reducing greenhouse gas emissions," Adler said.
Regardless of what path EPA choose, it will have to make sure it thoroughly explains its rationale for the regulations, or the agency could wind up losing again as the Supreme Court has given federal agencies less leeway in recent years.
One of the messages from the decision is "agencies if you want to have a prayer for deference, really explain yourself, Georgetown professor Bill Buzbee said.
EPA has said it is working on a successor to the Clean Power Plan that would incorporate lessons learned from that regulation.
Holmstead predicted the ruling will have little impact on how the agency approaches the issue in large part because it was ready to move on well before last week.
"I don't think that the political appointees or the career appointees had any interest in pursuing something like the Clean Power Plan," he said.
Related news posts
Toshiba, PLN eye CCS at Indonesian thermal power plants
Toshiba, PLN eye CCS at Indonesian thermal power plants
Osaka, 23 August (Argus) — Japanese engineering firm Toshiba Energy Systems and Solutions plans to explore installing carbon capture and storage (CCS) equipment at Indonesian state-owned power firm PLN subsidiary's thermal power plants. This is in line with Indonesia's net zero emission goal by 2060. Toshiba on 22 August said that it signed an initial agreement with PLN subsidiary Nusantara Power (PLN-NP). The target plants include the Paiton No.1 and No.2 coal-fired units that operate with steam turbines and generators supplied by Toshiba. Toshiba has delivered 32 steam turbines, with a combined capacity of 8,263MW, to thermal and geothermal power plants in Indonesia since 1981. Nine steam turbines totalling 1,845MW are currently in operation at four thermal plants owned by PLN-NP, the company said. Toshiba aims to minimise energy consumption required for CCS, while optimising generation efficiency of existing power plants. The deal came after Japan's trade and industry ministry (Meti) and Indonesia's ministry of energy and mineral resources (ESDM) signed an agreement on 21 August to form an institutional co-operation framework to facilitate and enhance collaboration to encourage decarbonisation of the energy sector. By Motoko Hasegawa Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Brazilian politicians, judges to advance green agenda
Brazilian politicians, judges to advance green agenda
Sao Paulo, 22 August (Argus) — Representatives from Brazil's three branches of government have pledged to work together to advance the country's green agenda by approving legislation, expanding funding and guaranteeing enforcement related to the environment and the energy transition. Representatives from the supreme court (STF) and congress, together with President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva and members of his cabinet signed an agreement on Wednesday aimed at reinforcing the country's commitment to protecting the environment. On the legislative front, lower house speaker Arthur Lira and senate President Rodrigo Pacheco promised to give priority to legislation that will advance the transition to low-carbon energy. This includes legislation that will create a regulated carbon market, a bill regulating offshore wind projects as well as a proposal that will create blend mandates for advanced biofuels. Pacheco plans to hold a vote for the bill that will create a carbon market in the first half of September, a spokesperson for senator Leila Barros, who is elaborating the text, told Argus . Barros has made significant progress on the new draft of the bill, but is finetuning the final text to address demands from specific sectors of the economy, the spokesperson said. The senate is also finalizing its analysis of the fuels of the future bill, which will create blend mandates for hydro-treated vegetable oil (HVO) and sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) as well as clear the way to increase the mandatory ethanol and biodiesel blends in commercial fuels. Senator Veneziano Vital do Rego presented a draft of the legislation on 20 August and is working to hold a vote in early September on the bill, which passed the lower house in March. Legislation for offshore wind has also made progress in the senate, but a proposal has not yet been presented. A draft of the bill was approved by the lower house last year, but included amendments that would expand subsidies for fossil fuels, potentially raising electricity prices for consumers. As part of the agreement, the executive branch has also promised to make further progress towards guaranteeing financing for energy transition projects. Likewise, the judiciary has agreed to give priority to cases that involve environmental, climate and land ownership. Lula stressed that the agreement among the three branches of the government shows Brazil's willingness to take a leading role to protect that environment as it prepares to host the Cop 30 meeting in Para state in 2025. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Sweden, Zambia Article 6 agreement eyes renewables
Sweden, Zambia Article 6 agreement eyes renewables
Berlin, 21 August (Argus) — Sweden and Zambia have signed an initial agreement on climate co-operation under the Paris climate deal, with a focus on investing in renewable power, the countries said. Zambia's ministry of green economy and environment and the Swedish Energy Agency are now negotiating a bilateral agreement under Article 6.2 of the Paris agreement. This will allow Zambia to generate so-called internationally transferred mitigation outcomes (Itmos), representing emissions reductions, that Sweden may count towards its own emissions cut targets under the UN framework. Most of the carbon credits that Zambia has generated under the UN's Kyoto protocol-era clean development mechanism and in the voluntary carbon market make use of the REDD+ programme, aimed at reducing deforestation and forest degradation and enhancing carbon stocks. Given the acute lack of electricity in Zambia because of a drought in the region — the country is 85pc dependent on hydropower for its generation — the Zambian government has proposed that Article 6.2 investments be directed at the country's power system, such as solar and wind power capacity. And experts from Kenya-based Climate Action Platform–Africa (CAP-A) and the UK's Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) have suggested that Zambia diversify beyond REDD+ and look at opportunities in sectors such as energy or waste management to maximise its carbon market potential. "The Zambian government has taken huge steps towards addressing the nation's current energy crisis," Zambia's green economy and environment minister Douty Chibamba said at the signing of the agreement in Lusaka yesterday. The Swedish Energy Agency aims for projects that provide "large emissions reductions" while having a positive long-term effect on Zambia's energy system, its head of international climate co-operation Sandra Lindstrom said. Projects must also benefit local communities and contribute to sustainable development, Lindstrom said, reflecting the shift away from the Kyoto protocol, under which issues such as indigenous rights or benefit sharing were largely ignored. CAP-A and the FCDO will launch a programme in September aimed at finalising Zambia's carbon market framework, notably a balanced benefit sharing and distribution system. The Swedish ambassador stressed at the signing of the agreement that Sweden's investments under Article 6.2 will complement existing support from Sweden's development agency in Zambia and the region. The initial agreement is Sweden's third with a project host country. Sweden has also signed a bilateral agreement under Article 6.2 with Ghana . By Chloe Jardine Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Indonesia may tighten POME oil export rules: Ministry
Indonesia may tighten POME oil export rules: Ministry
Singapore, 21 August (Argus) — Indonesian exports of palm oil wastes and residues including palm oil mill effluent (Pome) oil may soon be subjected to stricter export regulations, according to a draft document from its trade ministry. The ministry released the draft after a meeting with biofuel feedstock exporters on 20 August. The timeline for a decision on finalising the regulation is still unclear, although some market participants said it could be made by this month. Exports of Pome oil, high acid palm oil residue (Hapor) and empty fruit bunches (EFB) oil under the HS code 2306.60.90 are expected to require export permits, a change from the previous requirement of only export rights. While more details were not disclosed, meeting domestic market obligations (DMO) is usually a prerequisite to get export permits, suppliers said. This means that companies will need to sell a certain amount of cooking oil within Indonesia — or buy export quotas or credits from palm oil refineries around $15-$20/t — before they are able to export these products. This has led to expectations of potentially tightened feedstock exports. Refineries who sell cooking oil volumes to remote areas of Indonesia will also receive higher export quotas. As of January 2023, only crude palm oil (CPO), refined, bleached and deodorised (RBD) palm oil, RBD palm olein and used cooking oil (UCO) were subject to the DMO requirements. The previously-set domestic Highest Retail Price (Harga Eceran Tertinggi or HET) for cooking oil sold to consumers at 14,000 rupiah/l is now Rp15,700/l. This is likely because of higher CPO prices and packaging costs, a Indonesia-based supplier said. But market participants said they were also anticipating this increase previously. The higher HET implies that companies' cost of acquiring export permits in the medium to long term could fall, having sold cooking oil at higher prices domestically, market participants said. DMO for cooking oil Indonesia's Ministry of Trade also issued a regulation on 16 August stating that the DMO scheme for cooking oil will move fully from bulk to packaged palm olein – in 500ml, 1 litre (l), 2l and 5l volumes. This is likely to help maintain stable cooking oil prices and control inflation, as packaged olein is easier to monitor than bulk, a supplier said. The deadline for moving from bulk to packaged volumes is 12 November. Refineries under the DMO must also supply cooking oil volumes domestically of around 250,000 t/month, compared with approximately 300,000 t/month previously. But actual volumes will also depend on factors like how much palm oil wastes and residues exporters want to ship in a particular month too, a supplier said. The draft document did not include updates to long-awaited changes to export duties and levies to POME oil, UCO and other products, market participants said. They were expecting these changes in September or October when the new government is sworn in, although the actual timeline is difficult to determine. Current combined export duties and levies on POME for August is only $10/t, considering a CPO reference price of $820.11/t. UCO is not subject to duties, but have levies of $35/t. By Sarah Giam Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
![Generic Hero Banner](/_next/image?url=%2F-%2Fmedia%2Fproject%2Fargusmedia%2Fmainsite%2Fimages%2F14-generic-hero-banners%2Fherobanner_1600x530_generic-c.jpg%3Fh%3D530%26iar%3D0%26w%3D1600%26rev%3D8ec86dce0f724687bd325a9a917cffae%26hash%3D9FD39B08C9D84A160C91A3649C40A186&w=3840&q=75)
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more