CO2 prices soar as Germany hints at permit cancellation

Market: Emissions
15/07/19

Front-year delivery carbon allowances under the EU emissions trading system (ETS) changed hands at more than €28/t of CO2 equivalent (CO2e) for the first time in more than 11 years last week, after the German government indicated that it would be willing to cancel permits as part of its plans to phase out coal-fired power plants.

The EU ETS December 2019 contract ended trading last week at €28.78/t CO2e, having risen by a combined €2.40/t CO2e, or more than 9pc, over the course of the week — the product's largest week-on-week rise since the week beginning 1 April (see chart). This closing value was the highest for any front-year delivery EU ETS product since 1 July 2008.

The vast majority of the week's gains — €2.21/t CO2e — came in the final three trading sessions, after German environment minister Svenja Schulze confirmed on 10 July that her department would back a recommendation to cancel a proportional share of EU ETS allowances to offset the probable reduction in demand for carbon permits that would be caused by the country's closure of coal and lignite-fired units.

The December 2019 contract rose by €1.61/t CO2e on the day of Schulze's announcement — the product's largest day-on-day increase since 27 February — although part of this rise was driven by the absence of any fresh supply entering the market, because of the continuing Brexit-related suspension of auctions of UK-issued allowances.

EU ETS market prices have also historically been particularly susceptible to upward moves during July trading, as market participants expect thinner supplies in August — when allowance auction volumes are halved amid expectations of weaker holiday demand. The carbon market's front-year product has gained month-on-month value during July in all but one of the past six years in anticipation of these reduced supplies.

EU ETS price gains last week also drew support from weather forecasts pointing to the likelihood of another warm spell across large parts of Europe towards the end of July, which could boost the requirement for thermal forms of power generation to meet stronger demand for cooling. Highs of up to 30˚C are expected in Berlin by 20 July, while daytime levels in Paris could exceed 31˚C.

But an increase in thermal power output is unlikely to boost spot demand for carbon allowances as much as it might have done in previous years, with German coal-fired plants remaining firmly behind gas-fired units in the country's expected power sector merit order.

German gas-fired plants are on track to produce more power than coal-fired units for a second consecutive month in July, and for the third month this year, while wind farms remain on track to displace lignite units as the country's largest source of electricity over an entire year for the first time.

Auction demand, traded volumes

Last week's price spike resulted in a significant increase in primary market auction demand and secondary market traded volumes. The three auctions of EU-wide allowances drew bids for an average of roughly 7.4mn permits each, compared with an average of just 5.5mn for all of the sales in 2019 so far.

The auction on 11 July attracted particularly strong demand, with bids submitted for 8.7mn permits, as participants rushed to secure available allowances in the wake of Schulze's announcement before further price rises. This volume bid for was the most for any EU ETS primary market auction this year, and was more than three times the quantity of allowances made available for sale.

Stronger demand for carbon allowances was also reflected in the traded volumes of permits last week. An average of 18.8mn December 2019 delivery permits changed hands at the Intercontinental Exchange during each session last week, compared with a 17.6mn/d average for the whole of the year so far (see chart). More than 30mn front year delivery allowances traded on the exchange on 10 July alone, which was the most for any day since 10 April.

Outlook

A full five-day EU ETS primary market auction schedule returns this week, as a sale of Polish-issued permits will be held on 17 July, while an auction for 892,000 EU-wide aviation allowances is also due to take place that day.

This supply boost could limit the potential for further gains, although the carbon market is likely to find increased support and buying interest towards the end of July as August's supply crunch looms.

EU ETS Dec 19 price change by week €/t CO2e

EU ETS December 2019 contract

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News

04/11/24

Brazil launches reforestation plan

Sao Paulo, 4 November (Argus) — The Brazilian government launched its plan to reforest 12mn hectares (29.6mn acres) with native vegetation by 2030 as part of its efforts to meet its emissions-reductions target under the Paris Agreement. Of the 12mn ha of reforestation projected, 9mn ha will be on properties currently not in compliance with the 2012 forestry code, which requires property owners to maintain standing forest on a percentage of their land. Depending on the biome, property owners are required to preserve 20-80pc of native vegetation. The government estimates that nearly 24mn ha of privately owned land is currently not in compliance with the forestry code. The plan also foresees 2mn ha of reforestation on public lands, including conservation preserves and areas controlled by indigenous peoples. The remaining 1mn ha of reforestation will take place on degraded land which will be converted to be used for low-carbon agriculture. The government will provide financing and technical support for the reforestation program. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Find out more

News

US biofuel feedstock use dips in August

31/10/24

News

31/10/24

US biofuel feedstock use dips in August

New York, 31 October (Argus) — Renewable feedstock usage in the US was down slightly in August but still near all-time highs, even as biomass-based diesel production capacity slipped. There were nearly 3.5bn lbs of renewable feedstocks sent to biodiesel, renewable diesel, and sustainable aviation fuel production in August this year, up from fewer than 3bn lbs a year prior, according to the US Energy Information Administration's (EIA) latest Monthly Biofuels Capacity and Feedstocks Update report. August consumption was 0.4pc below levels in July and 0.5pc below record-high levels in June. US soybean oil consumption for biofuels rose to 39.3mn lbs/d in August, up by 2.1pc from a year earlier on a per-pound basis and up 6.9pc from a month prior. The increase was entirely attributable to increased usage for renewable diesel production, with the feedstock's use for biodiesel slipping slightly from July. Canola oil consumption for biofuels hit 14.2mn lbs/d, up by 58.1pc from a year prior on a per-bound basis but still 19.4pc below record-high levels in July. Distillers corn oil usage, typically less volatile month-to-month than other feedstocks, bucked that trend to hit a high for the year of 13.6mn lbs/d in August. That monthly consumption is up 13.6pc from a year earlier and 20.9pc from a month earlier. Among waste feedstocks, usage of yellow grease, which includes used cooking oil, rose to 22.4mn lbs/d in August, up 13.8pc from levels a year prior and 5.8pc from levels in July. Tallow consumption for biofuels was at 18.6 mn lbs/d over the month, an increase of 27.8pc from August last year but a decrease of 13.4pc from July this year. Production capacity of renewable diesel and similar biofuels — including renewable heating oil, renewable jet fuel, renewable naphtha, and renewable gasoline — was at 4.6bn USG/yr in August, according to EIA. That total is 24.1pc higher than a year earlier and flat from July levels. US biodiesel production capacity meanwhile declined to fewer than 2bn USG/yr over the month, down by 4.3pc from a year earlier and 1.3pc from a month earlier. US biomass-based diesel production capacity has expanded considerably in recent years, but refiners have recently confronted challenging economics as ample supply of fuels used to comply with government programs has helped depress the prices of environmental credits and hurt margins. The industry is also bracing for changes to federal policy given this year's election and a new clean fuel tax credit set to kick off in January. That credit, known as "45Z", will offer a greater subsidy to fuels that produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions, likely encouraging refiners to source more waste feedstocks over vegetable oils. That dynamic is already shaping feedstock usage this year, with Phillips 66 executives saying this week that the company's renewable fuels refinery in California is currently running more higher carbon-intensity feedstocks ahead of a shift to using more waste early next year. By Cole Martin Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

US court set to weigh biofuel blend mandates

31/10/24

News

31/10/24

US court set to weigh biofuel blend mandates

New York, 31 October (Argus) — A US court on Friday will weigh some novel issues that could affect enforcement of the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS), the federal program that sets minimum biofuel blending levels for domestic motor fuel supplies. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in last year's RFS regulation required refiners and importers to blend increasing volumes of renewable fuel from 2023-2025. But the rule differed from past obligations in a crucial way. While the RFS law set annual volume targets of cellulosic, advanced and conventional biofuels through 2022, it tasked EPA with setting volumes in subsequent years by balancing factors such as the environmental impacts of biofuels, energy security, expected production and consumer costs. In a consolidated case to be heard Friday by the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, environmental groups and oil refiners are separately challenging aspects of how the EPA applied those factors in setting 2023-25 volumes. The court has previously affirmed the legality of many RFS rules. "Past cases always give you some perspective on how the DC court might see it," said Susan Lafferty, a partner at law firm Holland & Knight. "But the DC court could also say, ‘not relevant anymore because this is a different part of the statute that we are working with.'" Refiners say EPA misapplied the criteria, upping compliance costs more than necessary by setting targets for cellulosic and conventional biofuels too high and targets for advanced biofuels too low. They also challenge EPA's balancing of potential impacts, noting that the agency assumed that all parties can easily pass the costs of compliance on to consumers. In a separate case this year, the DC Circuit discarded EPA rejections of program waiver petitions, in part because judges disagreed that refiners can easily pass on the cost of Renewable Identification Number (RIN) credits used to show compliance with the RFS program. EPA used this pass-through theory in the 2023-2025 rule "like a magic wand, waving it around to dismiss any argument that the rule will cause harm", the American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers and small refineries said in a case filing. Lafferty expects the judges at Friday's hearing to probe the extent to which EPA's volumes relied on this pass-through theory, "a policy that now this very court has gutted." Environmentalists have similarly targeted EPA's cost analysis, arguing that the agency downplayed the environmental drawbacks of growing crops for energy. The Center for Biological Diversity and the National Wildlife Federation argue that EPA has legal discretion to set post-2022 volumes for corn- and soybean-derived biofuels as low as zero. EPA counters that the court owes the agency deference in evaluating scientific data and making predictive judgments. And biofuel groups that have intervened argue that the program is designed to require more biofuel production even if there are no formal volume requirements in law anymore. While EPA's post-2022 authority to set blend mandates is a new issue, the DC Circuit has handled various cases about EPA's implementation and has generally been deferential to the agency's volume decisions. The court this year upheld 2020-2022 targets. In a 2019 decision, the court kept volumes in place , despite telling EPA to more deeply weigh endangered species impacts. While the court might take issue with some aspects of EPA's latest rule, including the agency's lateness in finalizing volumes, judges could again be reluctant to upend fuel markets if they find only small oversights. Depending on how skeptical judges appear about EPA's arguments on Friday, the case could cause concern for biorefineries. A decision is expected next year, meaning any order for EPA to better justify its decisions or go back to the drawing board would likely fall to the next president's administration. On the panel for Friday's hearing are two judges familiar with the program: Democratic appointee Cornelia Pillard, who wrote the opinion this year upholding 2020-2022 blend mandates, and Republican appointee Gregory Katsas, who dissented and said those volumes were excessive. The third judge on the panel is Democratic appointee J. Michelle Childs. RINcrease or decrease RIN market activity has thinned as participants await the results of the court case and November's presidential election. In its latest rule, EPA aimed to provide a clearer picture over a longer timeline by finalizing volumes over multiple years. But the agency underestimated the growth in renewable diesel production, partly because of unexpectedly high feedstock imports. The result has been persistent oversupply, which took D4 biomass-based diesel credit prices from around 150¢/RIN in spring last year to as low as 42¢/RIN a year later according to Argus assessments. Multiple refiners have consequently dialed back biofuel production. In the past, RIN prices have proven sensitive to legal developments as traders anticipate supply and demand shifts. Prices softened this summer after the DC Circuit vacated small refinery waivers, leaving it unclear whether many facilities would have to buy RIN credits at all. By Cole Martin and Matthew Cope Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

UK government consults on oil and gas scope 3 emissions

30/10/24

News

30/10/24

UK government consults on oil and gas scope 3 emissions

London, 30 October (Argus) — The UK government has opened a consultation seeking views on assessing the effects of scope 3 — or end-use — emissions from proposed offshore oil and gas projects. "Scope 3 emissions from downstream activities need to be assessed… in relation to offshore oil and gas production activities", the government said today. It proposed that a baseline scenario is defined for assessing scope 3 emissions, to set out how the environment "is likely to evolve without the development of a proposed project". The government also proposed that information on "relevant scope 3 categories" is included when a developers applies for a permit. This would include the effects of emissions from the combustion of oil or gas, as well as "other downstream activities", such as refining or transport of fuels. The UK's current process means that developers applying for consent must provide information on scope 1 and 2 — operational — emissions in an environmental statement. But scope 3 emissions are not included, despite making up around 80-95pc of emissions for a typical oil and gas company. The consultation was spurred by a ruling made in June by the UK's Supreme Court. The judgment ruled that consent for an oil development in southern England was unlawful, as the scope 3 emissions were not considered. The government — which was elected in early July, shortly after the ruling — has halted the assessment of any environmental statements related to oil and gas extraction and storage activities, including any that were already being assessed. These would be deferred until the new environmental guidance was in place, expected in spring 2025. The consultation will close on 8 January 2025. Separately, the government will consult by the end of this year on the implementation of its commitment to issue no new oil and gas licences to explore new fields, it said today. The UK has a legally-binding target of net zero emissions by 2050. By Georgia Gratton Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Australia to support four new carbon credit methods

30/10/24

News

30/10/24

Australia to support four new carbon credit methods

Sydney, 30 October (Argus) — The Australian federal government will support the development of four new carbon crediting project methodologies proposed outside of government, federal energy minister Chris Bowen announced today. A total of 39 expressions of interest under the proponent-led model launched earlier this year were submitted to the Emission Reduction Assurance Committee (Erac), the statutory body responsible for ensuring the integrity of Australia's carbon crediting framework. The four selected proposals will now move on to the development phase. "Capturing opportunities across Australia remains a key priority for the government, and we've been working to deliver on the Chubb Review recommendation to bring forward more innovative ways to reduce emissions," Bowen told delegates at the Carbon Market Institute (CMI)'s Australasian Emissions Reduction Summit in Melbourne on 30 October. Two of the selected methods were proposed by state governments — the "improved native forest management in multiple-use public native forests (INFM)" method, put forward by the New South Wales (NSW) department of climate change, environment, energy and environment, and the "improved avoided clearing of native regrowth (IACNR)" proposed by the Queensland department of environment, science and innovation. The two others came from indigenous groups — the "extending savanna fire management to the northern arid zone" proposed by the Indigenous Desert Alliance, and the "reducing disturbance of coastal and floodplain wetlands by managing hooved animals" proposed by Northern Australian Indigenous Land and Sea Management Alliance. The successful proponents will now lead work on the drafting of the methods, with the Erac to publish the draft methods for public consultation before recommending them to the minister. A representative from the Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water (DCCEEW) previously said that developing a new method under the proponent-led model could take 1-2 years. Delays with new methods The development of new Australian Carbon Credit Unit (ACCU) framework methods had been until now led by the federal government, but this has proved "too slow," CMI's chief executive John Connor previously said. Work on a remake of the Environmental Plantings (EP) method, which will make it easier for landholders to undertake projects, is expected to be finalised by the end of the year, Bowen said on 30 October. The method already expired on 30 September this year. And exposure drafts for three other priority methods will only be delivered in the first half of next year, Bowen noted, including the long-awaited government-led Integrated Farm and Land Management (IFLM) method that will combine activities of several existing soil and vegetation sequestration methods into a single method. This includes the key human-induced regeneration (HIR) ACCU method, which expired on 30 September 2023. The DCCEEW had previously indicated the IFLM exposure draft would be sent to Erac by the end of this year, which would then be followed by public consultation. The other exposure drafts are for new savanna fire management methods and for a reformed landfill gas method which could potentially lead to tighter supplies in the future . By Juan Weik Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more